Ratings & Reviews

I was lucky enough to purchase from Sarah. And I’m so excited to say I’m in love with her bread!! Very soft, very tasty, and you can eat every bite by itself. When you love what you bake, the results show. Thank you Sarah!!! I will continue purchasing from you!!

This bread is delicious and she was able to respond so quickly and was so fast to make sure I had what I needed! Will definitely be reordering!

Simply Sarah Bakes did not disappoint!! Our expectations were significantly exceeded! The Apple Fritters were the best we’ve ever had!! The bagels and sourdough bread are both absolutely beautiful and delicious!!! Can’t wait to try some of her other creations!

After having the chocolate/peanut butter cookies and the sourdough I am hooked. I had the perfect weekend thanks to Sarah. Her sour dough is devine with softened butter or as the strong arms embracing my cold cuts, lettuce, and mayo. I was in heaven and Sarah is my angel. Her cookies took me over the edge as a sweet treat and now my husband is jealous.

Sarah made a peanut butter and chocolate chip cookie so good I briefly considered proposing to it. This review is basically my next order - please make more before I start showing up with puppy eyes. 10/10!

Perfect rustic sourdough loaf; toasted slices are particularly awesome! I know bagels are supposed to be a little chewy, but in the past I have found a lot of them to be excessively so, even tough. But this sesame seed bagel I had was just right and very tasty. Hard to describe the cookies (we had chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin) except for maybe "food of the gods" and best we've ever found. And the size/weight of each cookie---WOW!

I got the sourdough and it was hands down the best sourdough I've ever had! It wasnt too sour and its going to be in my rotation

I couldn’t wait to try some of Sarah’s cinnamon bagels, they were perfect by themselves. They were even better toasted with some honey walnut cream cheese! I can’t wait to try her other flavors and breads!