Ratings & Reviews

Wow! Oh wow!! Thank you so much for your amazing cookies and the cookie cake. The presentation was amazing. How do you do those graphics? My team loved them. The cookies tasted great and the chocolate chip pie was gone faster than I could blink my eyes. Kudos to you for a job well done and thank you for the personal touch. We will definitely order from you again! Sincerely, Rachael & the All American team players

We ordered these for my mom’s 51st birthday which was also to celebrate her 50th, we did a murder mystery party with the theme 5150 and Emily absolutely blew the expectations out of the water. The cookies were BEAUTIFULLY DONE, tasted AMAZING, and truly complimented and elevated our guests’ experience. Everyone loved them, it’s rare to find a cute sugar cookie that actually tastes good but she has the flavor & art wrapped all into one. These were better than the inspiration we had sent for reference, Emily is truly gifted with her communication, talent, and attention to detail, we will be ordering again for future events because who doesn’t love delicious & decorative cookies?! Hands down the best we’ve ever had!

I ordered some last minute cookies and Emily was so sweet to accommodate me! She did a fantastic job with creating my vision and on top of that the cookies were DELICIOUS. I will definitely be placing more orders in the future! (:

We hired Emily for our son’s second birthday party and the cookies were such a hit! Not only adorable and anything I would’ve hoped for in design but also tased so delicious! Will be using Sif & Sugar for all my future cookie needs.

Emily is an absolute gem! She was great from start to finish with helping plan and coordinate the best style and flavor cake for what I needed. She’s prompt on her response, has great feedback, and her cookies/cakes taste amazing on top of looking so good! We’ve used her services on multiple occasions and will continue to do so!

We ordered a giant cookie for Father’s Day and it was delicious and beautiful! The peanut butter buttercream frosting is to die for. We also sampled the vanilla buttercream frosting — we aren’t usually fans but this was delicious! And Emily is super friendly. Highly recommend!!

My cookie is beautiful and delicious! Excellent customer service! Thanks Emily!

Absolutely LOVED working with Emily. She nailed my daughter’s first birthday cookies. Everyone loved them and turned out SOOO cute. 10/10 ❤️

I ordered an off to college theme for my grandson‘s graduation party. Amazing service. Absolutely delicious cookies, and incredibly beautiful. I would highly recommend this business and I look forward to using them again.

Phenomenal job on my order. Looking forward to the next one. Thank you.

So easy to work with. I also received multiple compliments about the detail of each cookie and the taste of them. Thank you for taking your time and truly delivering what I imagined.

Emily was super communicative and understanding during the ordering process. Cookies were super soft, and the frosting wasn’t too sweet. They made for a very delicious and perfect gift

Emily is always so easy to communicate with. Most delicious and beautiful sugar cookies!!!

Cookies were so cute I didn’t want anyone to eat them 🤣 but after giving in , they were so yummy and everyone enjoyed them ! The pictures & writing were perfect almost too perfect to eat ! Would def recommend, have ordered cookies from others before but this quality and delivery by far exceeded others!! I rate 10/10 thank you so much !!

Sig and Sugar made us THE CUTEST disney princess cookies for our two year olds birthday. She also did crowns with my toddlers name on them and number two shaped cookies. They were exactly what we wanted and tasted SO YUMMY! 10/10 recommend!

Emily made beautiful cookies for my twins first birthday party. Communication was great throughout and she really brought the vision to life. Couldn’t have loved the cookies more! Everyone loved the flavor of them as well. Will order again. Appreciate all the effort that went into these works of art on cookies!

Emily has such a streamlined process for her cookies. From design ideas to final pickup, it was flawless! She brought my vision to life, and exceeded any expectations. The cookies were a hit at our event and I received multiple comments on how the cookies were not only cute, but ALSO delicious. She heat seals each individual cookie so they stay fresh until you’re ready to eat them! I look forward to working with her again!

Emily’s decorated cookies are obviously beautiful… but can we please talk about the flavor and texture of the cookies?! Incredible. She’s nailed the recipe and not only that, she’s nailing recipes while raising 3 babies! Emily can’t be stopped and I’m stoked to be supporting her business. It’s hard to believe she’s just starting out as a business owner, but her work shines already. In addition to all of this, she’s got a big heart and is a great friend. ~thank you em for simply being the best!

I was so very happy with the presentation of the box of cookies with ample decorating supplies. The cookies were delicious and vanished off the plate before I could take a picture. What a wonderful gift to share with loved ones who are wanting to have a fun time. I hope there will be more for Mother’s Day.

Such a tasty cookie and I LOVED how there was a dye free option. My 3 year old had a blast decorating and wanted to eat all the cookies.