Ratings & Reviews

From the very first discussion about my vision for these baby shower cookies to the picking up of the order everything was first class. Siobhan couldn’t be easier to work with and kind. Her cookies looked better than I envisioned and were extremely delicious. My go to for treats every time!!

Yum, great tasting cupcakes with delicious frosting, thoughtfully prepared- each one was perfect! Will be ordering again!

The cookies you made for my daughter's bridal shower with both beautiful and delicious! My guests absolutely loved them; they were a hit!! Thank you!!!

Another fantastic job! I can’t wait for everyone to see them tomorrow. Thank you!

Amazing!!!! The cookies are amazing , the way it was decorated was amazing!!! And the way it was packaged was beautiful . Thank you so much . Can’t wait to book again with you!

I ordered cookies for a baby shower. The final product was better than I imagined. The cookies are all individually sealed and packaged beautifully. They are delicious too. They were a big hit at the shower!

As always, these cookies were unbelievable. Gorgeous and absolutely delicious! So many commented and wanted her information! Love love love

I ordered cookies for my husband’s surprise birthday party. They were a huge hit! Not only were they amazingly decorated and fit perfectly to the theme ( she even customized!!!) but they were delicious. Guests commented that they were the best tasting ones they’d ever had!!!

We had two Baby Showers this weekend and everyone raved about how delicious and gorgeous the cookies were. The attention to detail was so impressive. It was the perfect treat and party favor! Thank you for making these special moments magical!!

This cookie cake went beyond my expectations! It was not only beautiful but also tasty! Everyone at the party loved it. Such a fun spin on a traditional cake. Siobhan is so easy to work with as well!

I can’t recommend Shibs Cookie Studio enough! Her cookies are not only absolutely adorable, but they’re also the best tasting decorated cookies I’ve ever had. The s’mores cookie is hands down my favorite cookie I’ve ever eaten in my life—it’s THAT good! Every order has been fresh, delicious, and beautifully decorated. She’s always quick to respond, friendly, and so easy to work with. You can truly tell she puts so much care into every detail. If you’re looking for cookies that are as delicious as they are beautiful, this is the place to order from!

I didn’t know anything about this company other than they were in the same town I am, so when Shibs was doing a pre-order, I figured I’d get some cookies, support a local business and hope they were good. We had sea salt chocolate chip, chocolate caramel, s’mores, and coffee cake. All four of the cookies could not have been more delicious! We were blown away by how amazing they were! All were cooked perfect, had excellent flavor and well worth the money. We will definitely keep ordering from Shibs and I encourage everyone to do the same.

The cookies were both delicious and beautiful! Communication was great and pickup was easy. Will definitely be using her again

Amazing service and response time and delicious cookies!

Cookies are the best we’ve ever had! Super easy to order and pick up too! Siobhan is the best around!

I ordered cookies for my daughter’s baby shower. Shibs came up with some beautiful designs right on theme and color scheme. Everyone at the shower was obsessed with them. I couldn’t be more pleased

I placed my cookie order for teacher appreciation week and they were BEYOND my expectations. They were decorated perfectly and Packaged so cutely. I was super late to pick up and Siobhan was so lenient and patient. This was our first custom order but I already cannot wait for the next.

The cookies I ordered came out absolutely perfect, just like the images I shared! Communication was seamless throughout the process. I’ve officially found my go-to cookie baker, and I couldn’t be happier with the results.

These are hands down some of the best cookies I’ve ever had. Every flavor is so rich, delicious, and perfectly made. You can truly taste the love and care that goes into each one. If you’re thinking about ordering, do it — you will not be disappointed!

Shibs cookies have never done my tastebuds wrong! Adorably decorated sugar cookies that melt in your mouth, and the divine variety of her thiccc cookies keeps me hooked for more. I’m looking forward to doing some decorating with my niblings using the diy Easter kit (fun holiday idea!) and then devouring our delicious creations. <3

Delicious, Beautiful, affordable, most creative! Highly recommended for any occasion, not my first and most def not the last!👌

The cookies came out great!! They look amazing. She is so talented!

I ordered cupcakes for a baby shower they looked and tasted amazing!

I contacted Siobhan a few weeks in advance of my son's first birthday, and am so pleased I did. She was extremely responsive, working with me on deciding cake shape, size and decoration. I sent her our theme and a couple of inspiration photos, and was blown away by her creativity and attention to detail. All our guests commented on how beautiful and tasty both the cookie cake and decorated cookies were. We couldn't recommend Siobhan more, and definitely plan to reach out for future celebrations!