Ratings & Reviews

The cookies that I ordered FAR exceeded my expectations. Each on is extraordinary. She makes the very best cookies that I have ever had. Just WOW!

I ordered a 30th birthday cake and it was exactly what I had envisioned and the cake was so moist and the strawberry filling was delicious, everyone loved it.

This cake was absolutely delicious, and so beautiful! Will definitely be returning in the future!

Selby makes the most delicious cakes!

We were blown away by the amazing cake from Selby’s Sugar Shop! From the detail of the design to the delicious taste of the cake and icing, Liz knocked it out of the park!!!

Absolutely Amazing! The cookies and cakes are next level. Made with love and attention to detail. Not only gorgeous but delicious!!

Can’t rave enough about how professional her customer service was! I requested a last minute request on her site and heard from her within hours of request. Communicated every step of the way! Very thoughtful design, tasted amazing, and expertly packaged for pick up.

Went above and beyond! I messaged night before needing a gender reveal cake for my daughter in San Angelo while I’m in El Paso, and responded quickly and kindly. Communicated with me every step of the way—details, delivery, and payment were all handled smoothly and professionally. Cake was delivered exactly as agreed, and my daughter was so happy. I couldn’t be more grateful for Shelby Sugar Shops’ help in making this day so special for our family. Highly recommend services—reliable, responsive, and truly caring!

10/10 will always choose selby sugar shop. Our wedding cake came out absolutely beautiful. It got delivered and got set up for us. So helpful and makes it all stress free. And all my cakes were delicious!!! Literally had no left overs. And made my husband's tres leches and he said it was the best tres leches.

I have ordered cupcakes twice now and both times they were fresh, delicious and beautifully decorated to fit my theme.

Liz did an excellent job on my shower cake! I sent her a few inspo pics and just asked her to combine best way she could & she also gave me some additional ideas and it turned out so pretty. I was so in love with it!!!! The cake itself was very moist, good flavor which we went with pecan and pecan pie filling, def very different my guest all loved the cake as well. We communicated through Facebook and she was very fast with her responses and pick up was on time and easy. Price was very good as well for size/style. 10/10 for Liz 👏🏼

Cookies and cupcakes were beautiful and tasty. Service was great. Will use again.

Everything was absolutely amazing as always

Beautiful and delicious!

100/100

Soooo happy with my son’s Where the Wild Things Are cookies! Came out so beautiful. Will be a returning customer.

The smash cake for our daughter was larger than we anticipated and so stinking cute! It was beautiful and tasted wonderful! Reminded me of the strawberry cake my grandma used to make 🥹. The cupcakes were not only gorgeous but absolutely delicious as well. There was not a single one left after the party! 💜💜

soo amazing & delicious!! the cookies were absolutely the cutest! I recommend 100%.🥰

Back to school cookies are so cute and taste delicious!

I’ve ordered 4 times an the cookies are always perfect and taste really good highly recommend

I absolutely loved the cake and cookies that I got. It was everything that I envisioned and more. It also tasted amazing and everybody enjoyed it

The order I received from Liz was exceptional. The cake was moist and delicious. The cookies were perfect. Thank you for making this such a special occasion!

Our cookies turned out amazing ! I have ordered many times from Selby Sugar Shop and have never been disappointed. Thanks again ! And I’ll be ordering from her again !

Every single cookie was perfect !

I cannot say enough good things about Elizabeth’s cakes! She is such an artist taking so much time and effort into creating the most beautiful cakes to suite the occasion. On top of the work of art she creates, her cakes taste so good! We had the lemon and vanilla flavors. Both were perfectly moist and packed with flavor. Highly recommend!!

Amazing!!!!!! The cake was done exactly how I asked! The cake itself was so good! My family and I were very pleased!

We absolutely loved our cakes 😍 they were so tasty!!

Liz hands down makes the BEST cookies! So fresh and so personable! We couldn’t thank you enough!!

Very professional! Was right on time, looked as expected and tasted sooooo good! Would order from Elizabeth over and over again with no hesitation

Our cake was exactly what I wanted! It was perfect for our sweet babies 2nd birthday! Everyone complimented not just how adorable it was, but also how yummy the cake actually was! I will definitely order again!

I got a smash cake and some cookies for my son’s first birthday. Everyone loved them and it was delicious. This is the second time I’ve ordered from her and she does not disappoint. Will continue to come back for all my orders.

She brought my vision to life, exactly what I wanted for this year’s birthday pictures for my daughter. Beautiful and delicious!

Not only did the cake look stunning but it tasted delicious! All of my guest said they loved it, I could not be more happy with how it turned out!

Liz did such a great job with the limited info I had to give her and exceeded all my expectations! The cookies were beautiful as well as delicious and communication was easy and prompt. Will definitely be a returning customer!

She LOVED them! You did an awesome job! They are not only so cute but very delicious!

Elizabeth is such a sweetheart and nailed it!! Couldn’t be happier, thank you so much!

100/100 will recommend! Was recommend by an established event designer here in San Angelo! Saw a pic on the instagram, she had stated it was an inspirational one but she said she would tackle it! She absolutely killed it the cake was perfect and everything I wanted to the T! Thank you!

The best cake I have had made in San Angelo by far! Not only did it look exactly like the inspo picture I sent her, it was one of the best tasting cakes I have ever had. I will not be using anyone else for my cakes or cookies going forward.

I’ve ordered with Liz twice now and she has yet to disappoint! I’ve ordered cakes, cookies and cupcakes and they all came out so delicious and totally satisfied my vision!

The cake came out so cute! It was just how I wanted it. She was able to get me in last minute and worked with me on every detail. I highly recommend for any of your events big or small! 😊🫶🏻 Her cookies are also really good 😉

Cookies came out absolutely amazing! Will be returning for all future events!

Selby was amazing throughout the entire order process. The cake was very delicious everyone loved it at the baby shower!

The cookies and communication was TOP notch. I gave 2 inspo pics and she delivered!!!!

Selby did so good on my cake from the presentation down to the flavor! I sent her an inspo pic and she matched it exactly and it was delicious, everyone complimented the cake and are asking for her information!

Liz has always done a FABULOUS job on every order we’ve gotten. She made me a beautiful baby shower cake after I was so indecisive about what I wanted. She took the reigns and made me a cake better than I could have ever imagined myself!!

We LOVED the way the cake turned out, just what we expected🤩 can’t wait for future orders we might need!!

Cakes and cookies are absolutely truly the best! They also look absolutely beautiful and taste amazing!!

Repeat buyer… Cookies always come out amazing!! Great customer service and can’t wait to order again!

Her work is amazing the cookies were so pretty an they taste amazing usually you don’t get both taste good an look good highly recommend thank you again

I cannot say enough good things! Not only do the cookies and cake taste amazing, but they LOOK amazing!! The details she puts into her stuff is amazing!! I do not use anyone else in town!!

Amazing taste beautiful presentation! Honestly the best cookies

Cake and cookies were absolutely stunning! Flavors out of this world! Order was placed for my daughter’s 10th birthday with the theme of Rock Band A Day To Remember and she absolutely loved them! Highly recommend. Definitely worth the price!

The cookies and cake I ordered were exactly what I wanted. The designs were perfect and everything tasted as good as it looked!

I ordered the father's day burger cookie basket!!!! They were super cute and taste amazing!!! I would definitely recommend and I will definitely be a repeat lifetime customer!!!

This is my third time ordering custom cookies and Liz never disappoints! She is so talented and the cookies always taste amazing! Thank you!

Liz absolutely make the best western theme cookies I could ever imagine for my birthday. I cannot wait to get into them and show them to my family and I highly recommend anybody to her because she is incredibly talented.

Absolutely loved my cake, the color and pattern was exactly what I was hoping for, the cake was moist frosting and flavor was lovely I couldn’t have been more happy with this cake!! Thank you

Shelby’s cake was amazing! Absolutely soft and moist. Even the frosting was amazing. Thank you so much for an amazing graduation cake.

Awesome decorations! My husband loved it and the chocolate cake was rich!

Love ordering cakes from her! Does a good job and cake is so moist!! Great communication!

Love the birthday Cake she made for my daughters 13th birthday. Daughter even loved it too!!

Ordered cake for Sweet 16! It was beautiful and matched what we wanted perfectly!! Thank you!!!

It took me awhile to write this review because I wasn’t positive what to say but I decided I just need to say exactly how I felt. The cake was very moist and tasted delicious!!! The color of the heart cake was not the color I excepted and the icing felt grainy, but tasted good. For the price I paid, I expected more but would give Selby Sugar Shop another try due to the delicious flavor.

The best cookies ever!! Beautifully made with so much detail!!! We love Selbys Sugar Shop!!

Absolutely amazing and very impressive work!! Highly recommend!!

Best cookies by far!!! Liz always sees my vision and makes it come to life and then some!

Amazing job as always!

Thank you for making our daughter’s baby shower cookies! They were beautiful and delicious!

Simply Amazing..!!

Lizbeth and the Selby Sugar Shop are the peak of professionalism. When my daughter wanted axolotl cookies for her birthday, Liz not only made amazing cookies, she delivered them to our party. I highly recommend her to anyone looking for cookies

The cookies were perfect!! They tasted sooo good and the designs were spot on!

5 stars will never be enough! Her work is exceptional and she is more than accommodating! They also taste as good as they look!