Ratings & Reviews

This was the perfect cookie cake and traveled well all the way from Georgetown to Gatlinburg for my nephews birthday. We ate it as soon as we got there and could sing happy birthday, loved every crumb! Thank you so much!!!

I ordered a custom cookie cake, and it completely exceeded my expectations! The cookie base itself was perfectly baked—soft and chewy in the center with just the right amount of crispness on the edges. But the real star of the show? The icing. It is absolutely amazing! It can be tough to find a cookie cake where the icing isn't completely overwhelming, but this one has just the right amount of sweetness. It balances the rich cookie flavor beautifully instead of hiding it. Everyone at our gathering raved about it, and there wasn't a single crumb left. If you need a custom treat for an event (or just because!), do yourself a favor and order one of these. It really is so good!

We ordered a cookie cake for my son’s graduation and it was perfect! The cookie was perfectly baked and the icing was so smooth and just the right consistency. The cake was beautiful, but tasted even better! This was not our first and will not be our last Second Slice! 10/10 recommend.

My daughter had a vision for her graduation/birthday cake and Second Slice brought her dream to life. Not only was the cake absolutely gorgeous, it also was delicious. The cake pieces even came home with us wrapped in cute little boxes! We can't wait for our next order! Thank you Second Slice!!!

Order was perfect in every way! It was beautiful and tasted great too! Would highly recommend!

The cookie cake was exactly what I wanted, delicious and made our celebration special.

I ordered a number cake for my son’s birthday from Meagan and it was fabulous!! The cookie itself was incredible and the icing design was so pretty. Will order again !

I ordered a chocolate chip giant cookie for my son’s birthday and it not only looked amazing, but the taste was AHMAZING!!! It gave the homemade warm and fuzzy feeling without me having to make it myself! It won’t be my last time ordering!!

She went above and beyond with my girls 13th birthday cookie cake! It looks amazing and tastes even better! I will definitely be ordering again and soon!

Sent a photo of a Lego cookie cake that we wanted and it turned out perfect! Her cookie cakes are hands down the best we have ever had, so yummy and gorgeous.

I ordered a cookie cake recently to celebrate a Bride-to-Be. The ordering process was quick and easy and the cake turned out exactly how I imagined! The design was beautiful and the cake was delicious! There wasn’t a piece left in the box. I will definitely order again!

The double decker cookie cake was perfect for my daughter’s 13th birthday! Not only was it delicious, but also beautifully decorated! I will definitely be ordering again!

This was the BEST cake for a surprise 50th birthday! Delicious and decorated exactly like I had asked. Easy pickup too!☺️

I stumbled upon Second Slice just in time for a last minute work "thank you" gift. My coworkers loved the gesture AND the cake! I hope to use Second Slice again in the future.

I ordered a cookie cake for my daughter’s birthday. It was a big hit at her party! The cookie was delicious and the design was exactly what I wanted. I will definitely be ordering again for future occasions!

Tasty cookie cakes and wonderful service! Order and pickup was a breeze! Will be ordering again soon!

The best cookie cake that I have ever eaten!

I immediately ordered to support a friend and important cause that I care deeply about, but I was delightfully surprised at the professional quality of service, packaging, and product. I had this made for a friend's birthday and she loved it! It was pretty, exactly as the inspo pic I shared, and her even her 7 y/o gave it a 10 out of 10. I'll definitely be a returning customer; check it out!

Meagan makes the most delicious cookie cakes! They are so fresh!!!! She does a wonderful job making sure the decorations on the cake is exactly what you want! I have ordered two of her cakes and plan on ordering a lot more!!!!

Cookie cake was perfect! Chewy and soft throughput. Great taste and beautiful design.