Ratings & Reviews

The cookies were absolutely amazing. She did a great job and made the cutest Winnie the Pooh cookies! They tasted amazing. Highly recommend and will buy more anytime for an event!

I gave a brief description of the event and then let Shea take it from there and they are so perfect! Can’t wait to make my next order.

Thank you, Shea, for the perfect cookies for my son’s rehearsal dinner. They looked beautiful at each place setting and were absolutely delicious! I got so many compliments and pointed everyone to your QR code on the back of the packages. I will recommend Second Shift Sweets every chance I get!

I ordered cookies for my daugters 12th birthday. I was able to just tell Shae what I wanted and she nailed the design. The taste was so so good! Best custom cookies I have had!

Shea’s cookies were absolutely beautiful and delicious for my daughter’s baptism. She was quick to answer my questions and easy to work with. I will definitely order cookies from Second Shift Sweets again!

These cookies were phenomenal! So many amazing comments on the attention to detail and how cute they were. Perfect colors and followed the inspiration pictures. These cookies were not only beautiful but were so delicious!

Cookies were almost too pretty to eat but so glad we did!! They tasted as good as they looked !

Delicious cookies and great service! They made the perfect gifts for our teachers. Thanks Shea!!

I have ordered cookies three times now from Second Shift Sweets! The cookies are so beautiful and delicious! My three daughters, my niece, and nephew loved the Easter Bunny cookies I ordered them! They especially loved how the cookies had their names in their favorite color! I highly recommend ordering cookies! I am a happy customer, and will continue to order cookies in the future! I appreciate the care and time that goes into creating such amazing baked treats! Tracy Lopez 😍🥰💜❤️

Second Shift Sweets absolutely nailed it! The cookies were not only adorable but tasted amazing too. Everything was fresh, beautifully detailed, and ready super fast. You can tell so much care goes into every order. Highly recommend for birthdays, teacher appreciation, parties, or any special occasion! 💕

Phenomenal experience and perfect cookies !

Amazing custom cookies! They were delicious! Highly recommend.

Second Shift Sweets did such a great job on my cookies. The creativity and detail showed in every one! The flower artwork matched our theme perfectly. Everyone at the shower thought they were yummy and super cute!

We have ordered cookies from Shea a few times and now makeup reasons to order more. We are big cookie people and these are the best without question.

Flawless decorating but more importantly- delicious.

These cookies were so cute and so delicious. Husband approved as well! Highly recommend. All cookies came individually wrapped as well was a great extra! Will order again.

These cookies are absolutely gorgeous. The surprising part is that they also taste absolutely delicious. So many beautiful cookies are a disappointment when you bite into them, not the case here! I highly recommend!

Not only are these cookies absolutely beautiful, they taste amazing! The artwork was stunning and my daughter loved the surprise. We will definitely be ordering again and again as these are a new family favorite.

Shea’s attention to detail is unmatched. She will go above and beyond to make sure your order is exactly what you want & delicious.