Reynolds Cookie Co

The Cabin Cookie

Our signature cookie—rich, cozy, and unforgettable. Made with deeply golden brown butter, these chocolate chip cookies are soft in the center with perfectly crisp edges. Each bite is layered with notes of toffee, vanilla, and just a hint of sea salt to bring out the depth of flavor. Packed with gooey, melty chocolate chips and baked to rustic perfection, they’re the kind of cookie that feels homemade—but better.

$25.00

click for description

4th Of July Velvet Delight

🎆 4th of July Velvet Delight 🇺🇸 Celebrate in sweet style with our Velvet Delight — a patriotic twist on our beloved red velvet cookie cake! This rich, buttery red velvet base is soft-baked to perfection, topped with buttercream frosting, and decorated in bold red, white, and blue. It's the perfect centerpiece for your Independence Day celebration. Available in multiple sizes for sharing (or not!). (The picture above is not mine!! It’s just an example of what you’ll receive!)

$45.00

click for description

The Big Bake

Indulge in our irresistible Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake — a perfect blend of soft, chewy cookie goodness baked into a cake-sized treat! Loaded with rich, melty chocolate chips, every bite offers a warm, buttery sweetness that melts in your mouth. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just craving a comforting dessert, our cookie cake brings joy and nostalgia in every slice. Freshly baked with love and the finest ingredients, it’s the ultimate crowd-pleaser for cookie lovers of all ages.

$40.00

click for description

4th Of July Sugar Slab

🎆4th of July Sugar Slab🎆 Our soft-baked sugar cookie slab is a celebration on a tray—thick, buttery, and perfectly sweet with that classic melt-in-your-mouth texture. It’s generously frosted with velvety vanilla buttercream in red, white, and blue. Perfect for BBQs, fireworks, and every patriotic sweet tooth! (The picture above is not mine!! It’s just an example of what you’ll receive!)

$45.00

click for description

4th Of July Big Bake

🎆 The 4th of July Big Bake 🎆 Celebrate Independence Day with our extra-large, chocolate chip cookie cake—The Big Bake—decked out in festive red, white, and blue! This soft, chewy cookie cake is baked with rich, buttery dough loaded with melty chocolate chips and decorated like a firework show on a plate. Topped with classic buttercream, patriotic sprinkles, and bold piping details, it’s the perfect sweet centerpiece for your holiday cookout or family gathering. (The picture above is not mine!! It’s just an example of what you’ll receive!)

$45.00

click for description