Ratings & Reviews

Exactly like the photo I sent her! Tasted AMAZING!

I was blown away at how beautiful my order of cake pops looked and they taste absolutely delicious l. I ordered vanilla,chocolate, and red velvet.. from starting my order to delivery I am so pleased with the entire service .all my guest for our baby shower enjoyed them and everyone commented on how beautiful they were . I will most definitely use Pyle on the Sweets for future events and highly recommend using them for any event !

Absolutely love all of her baked goodies! My kids said “best cookies they’ve ever had” a super great pricing and very responsive

Stephanie is so talented. I ordered two different cookie cakes from her, and both were spot on! Very yummy too! We will be reaching out to her for our next celebrations! Thanks again Stephanie!

Just got my first cookie cake from Pyle On The Sweets this weekend for my daughter's 10th birthday. My daughter and everyone else at the party LOVED the design and the taste! It was adorable, absolutely delicious and so fresh! The free delivery to the venue was an added bonus and made my job as the host so easy! I have no complaints! Will definitely be ordering again and recommending to anyone needing a fun dessert!

Look no further! You have an idea, she has the skills to make it happen. She made me a cookie cake a found online. My friend was a nurse and she made a cake very similar to my inspiration but custom it to make it look like a nurse. It was so fun to see my friend’s reaction and her kids when they saw the cake. We all enjoyed the cookies and the funny 😆 design of the cake! The kids had a blast! She loved it so much that she saved it for her other dinner with her other nurse friends to show them how cool and funny the cake was!

From ordering to delivery, working with Stephanie was so easy. Our treats turned out incredibly impressive and professional and were so delicious! I will be ordering for every event moving forward! Thank you so much!

These Easter box was amazing I really liked the cake pops, I also got some cookie from them for teacher appreciation and they were BOMB also! I plan on contacting her in a couple months to do my wedding cookie cake!

These cookies brought my whole weekend joy and made me sad I’m PCSing soon. Stephanie was lovely with communication and worked with me so my husband could pick the cookies up. The frosting is so friggin yummy and she did amazing with the colors I gave her. And the cookies are the perfect level of chewy and theyre just all around goodness. I would absolutely recommend her if you’re having a party or, like me, just want a little weekend snack.

My order was not only delicious, but the attention to detail was fantastic!! Stephanie asked questions to make sure everything was perfect and the cake topper she created was exactly what I wanted. I will definitely be using her again in the near future!

Stephanie did an amazing job on my daughter’s birthday cookie cake! It was a huge hit with the kids and the adults! The cookie was so moist and the flavor was delicious! Definitely recommend getting your sweet tooth taken care of by Stephanie!

Thank you for the Valentine’s Day goodies, we loved them! ✨✨✨

I ordered a cookie cake and it was beautiful and delicious! It was so pretty I didnt want to cut into it. The frosting and the cookie itself tasted amazing. I will definitely be ordering again.

We ordered a Ninja Turtle cookie cake for my daughter’s 5th birthday and it turned out SO cute and delicious. She absolutely loved it and it made her day extra special. Thank you for putting so much care into it. Highly recommend

The red velvet cookies are to die for. I know I’ll be ordering more

I ordered a cookie bucket to bring to a superbowl party and it was a hit! The cookies were well loved by both my toddlers.

Just moved to the Island about 3 weeks ago and found Pyle on the Sweets on Facebook. She made a cookie cake for our daughters 2nd birthday and it was delicious!! We ordered a number 2 and did a Sing theme, and when i couldn't find any cake toppers she was able to make us a custom cake topper which was incredible quality as well, and made for a fun little bonus present for our daughter. The cake itself looked incredible and so yummy, but she really went above and beyond to really understand what we wanted and more than delivered. We will be ordering all our cookie cakes from her in the future!!

The cookies I ordered knocked the socks off our feet, we look forward to ordering more in the near future! Thank you ✨

She does such a great job. Everything looks and tastes amazing.

I made a large order after trying her cookies at a market to give to co-workers. At the last moment, I needed to double my order, and Stephanie was so accommodating!! It was very unexpected, since I’m sure she is swamped this close to Christmas, but she went above and beyond and everyone was absolutely thrilled with their gifts! Thank you so much Stephanie, you are amazing!

I have ordered cookies from Stephanie and few times now and I’m never disappointed. They are always so delicious and festive! I give them as gifts and the recipients are always loving them.. She’s better than Crumbl and local, so it’s a win win! Will definitely order more in the future and would love for these to be available for purchase in a bakery.

Pyle On The Sweets did a fabulous job making my son’s birthday cake. We ordered a number 7 Pokemon themed cookie cake and it looked absolutely amazing and was so so so yummy! This cake made my son’s day. Going forward we will be ordering all of our cakes from her. She was so kind and great to communicate with. Highly recommended trying her cakes and cookies- you won’t regret it!

She is so talented and every thing I've had so far is amazing!!

The flavor was absolutely amazing !! it was a massive hit with my entire family and the decoration was exactly what my son wanted! Thank you for making my son‘s fifth birthday a good one!

Made my cookie cake vision come to life perfectly, and it tasted even better than it looked! So many people loved it and we made sure to pass on the name for others to order. Thank you so much!

The Boo Buckets were a huge hit. The kids loved every bit, and we’ve already enjoyed most of the goodies. Here’s to making this a yearly tradition!!

We got 2 boo buckets and absolutely LOVE them! Not only was each item well done, they tasted great!

The cookie cake was so much better than I expected! I absolutely loved the design and it was delicious. Can’t wait to order again!

Absolutely awesome! Loved the presentation and, honestly, I was surprised at the size of the treats (bigger than expected!). The cookies looked great and the names of all the treats were cute. I look forward to ordering again! Thank you for sharing your treats!

I am so happy to have found this business!! I’ve tried the oatmeal cookie sandwiches and the DIY Halloween cookie kits and have absolutely loved both of them! The flavor is great and the cookie kit is the coolest idea- nearly mess free cookie decorating with kids because of the way everything is packaged. I hope they are available for every holiday because I will absolutely order them every time. Thank you for such an excellent experience!

Purchased 2 dozen monster cookies for Halloween to send into work and they were a smash hit! Not a single cookie came home (to my selfish disappointment really), and I’m pretty sure several people were caught trying to sneak cookies into pockets without others seeing. She individually packaged and delivered these adorable, beautifully made cookies. Nothing better; wonderful customer service, amazing look, and 10 star taste! I may be on the hook for Christmas cookies now. :)

Have purchased a few times now and they are consistently amazing baked goods! The Oatmeal Cream Pies were the best, and the Halloween basket presentation was perfect.

Ordered the Boo Basket and was so impressed! It was put together beautifully and the treats were amazing. Will definitely be ordering again.

Prompt, efficient, and oh so good!!! Everyone loved them & they were the perfect addition for our event. Thank you for helping to make our day so special.

SUPER CUTE & TASTY ❤️ everybody loved it! Will definitely be ordering for future birthdays 🩷

Stephanie did it again!!!! Absolutely beautiful and delicious #1 cake and smash cake!😍

Stephanie did a fantastic job with a super hero themed cookie cake for my son’s 4th birthday. Not only was it gorgeous, but it was delicious. We added an additional sugar cookie bucket to our order after more than anticipated RSVPs rolled in. She was more than willing to accommodate, prompt, and we definitely recommend her to all of our friends!

These were the CUTEST little cookies I have ever seen. They were executed perfectly and done way above my expectations and tasted SO GOOD. Perfect little bites of happiness!

This was such a clever way to mix up a birthday cake option! Super tasty and quick service! Will be a returning customer 😋

We absolutely loved it! I ordered a cute little cookie cake for my son's first of homeschool and this was a great way to celebrate the first day. It was delicious and the service is also amazing!!

Amazing and beautiful cookie cake. Great taste and perfect for any occasion. Definitely would recommend!

I ordered for 2 teachers, and both orders were perfect! The ordering process was very easy-pick up was easy, and the pricing is phenomenal. I will definitely order again!

Our cookie cake was PERFECT. Stephanie is so talented. It tasted amazing, looked amazing, was right on time and insanely affordable. Will definitely be a returning customer.

I had Stephanie do a cookie cake for my daughter's 21st birthday. It was absolutely amazing! Gorgeous to look at. Delicious to taste. She included samples for me as well, which gave me a preview of what was coming. I recommend Stephanie for any of your baking needs!

I bought a cookie cake for my daughter's birthday party. Not only did it look AMAZING, but it was so yummy! We were so happy with the cake, my daughter loved it, and we even had multiple people come up to us asking who made it so that they could order one too. Seriously so good!! Thank you Stephanie, we're definitely going to be repeat customers :)

Spectacular job! I will definitely use her again!!!!! 10/10! A thousand percent yes!

EVERYTHING was just as ordered and ready for pick up on time! Not to mention, delicious 😋 I will definitely be a repeat customer!!

From ordering to pickup, the process was swift and stellar. I included a few inspiration photos in my order and Stephanie knocked it out of the park. The cookie cupcakes were not only adorable, but everyone at my daughters’ birthday party raved about the quality and taste, dying to know I ordered from. Communication, execution, presentation — 5 stars all the way. I’ll be ordering more in the future, just for fun! Highly recommended.

We ordered a sugar cookie cake and it was absolutely delicious! The texture was perfect—soft, chewy, and full of flavor. Communication was fantastic with quick responses to our requests. It was a huge hit with the kids and the adults. We’ll definitely be ordering again!

The cookie cake was amazing! The cookie was soft and so delicious. The icing was sweet, the colors were spot on to what I had sent in! Will definitely be ordering again!

The Father's Day cookie cakes were perfect. Beautiful and delicious. Stephanie was amazing. Will definitely order again.

I ordered a 6” double layer vanilla buttercream cookie cake, and it was absolutely amazing! The flavor was perfect— sweet, soft, and delicious. My husband loved it!! Stephanie was so kind and incredibly helpful. I forgot to include design details on the order form, but I messaged her and she responded quickly and took care of everything with no problem at all. I highly recommend her to everyone! The cookie cake was not only delicious but the whole process was smooth and stress-free thanks to Stephanie’s great communication and talent. I’ll definitely be ordering again!!😍🤤

I ordered a cookie cake for my son’s graduation! I don’t know where to begin. The quality, taste, presentation, and professionalism was AMAZING! I’m a FOREVER customer. Thank you so much for making our event even more special!

The graduation cookie cake that was made for my child was beautiful. What made it even better was the taste. Go order one today!!

The cookie cakes are amazing!!

Pyle on the Sweets absolutely knocked it out of the park with their Father’s Day cookie cake! Not only was it beautifully decorated and customized just right, but the flavor was out of this world—soft, rich, and packed with that perfect homemade touch. You could taste the love in every bite. It was the highlight of our Father’s Day celebration and had everyone asking where it came from. If you haven’t tried one of their cookie cakes yet, you’re seriously missing out. Can’t wait to order again!

Stephanie did an amazing job on my daughter’s cookie cake. Cookie cake was soft and everyone enjoyed it. It was beautifully decorated.

Not only was the cake we ordered beautiful, it was delicious! I threw a cow themed party for a friend of mine and Pyle on the Sweets decorated the cake PERFECTLY. We received so many compliments and there wasn’t a crumb left!! I will definitely be ordering another cake in the future :)

Stephanie make amazing cookie cakes. My daughter wanted a tangled themed cake with #16. Stephanie knocked it out of the park!

Im from the south and my grandma cookies USED to be my favorite UNTIL I tried these cookies, these had my mouth watering just looking at them, compliments to the chef! I cannot wait to try everything else!

Taste: amazing. Appearance: amazing. Ease of ordering: amazing. All was absolutely perfect. Will be ordering again for the husband’s birthday :)

Listen, I'm not a skinny lady. I've eaten thousands of cookies in my life, but Stephanie has outbaked them all! I know people hate the word, but they are MOIST while still being crispy (no idea how that works...)! I ordered a sample of everything and OMG, they just kept getting better and better!! Let's just say that I'm glad I'm not diabetic because I would have died and gone to actual heaven instead of just cookie heaven! Thank you thank you!