Ratings & Reviews

I was in search of a local baker for custom beach themed cookies for my mom’s surprise 60th birthday, and Caiti executed my ideas perfectly and the cookies were a hit both in design and taste!

I ordered 4 dozen logo cookies for 2 of my daughter’s cheer team bonding event. These cookies were absolutely beautiful and tasted just as good as they looked! Communication was great from start to finish, and pickup was fast and easy. The details and packaging were so well done, and they were such a fun addition to our event. I would definitely order again!

The taste, designs, and service are all top-notch!

These cookies were just so beautiful and tasty. A lovely statement piece to have at any event.

Caiti has created beautiful and tasty cookies for my family times over the years and her designs have never failed to disappoint. She always shows the design beforehand for approval & is quick at responding. Looking forward to my next order!

I was so busy that I forgot to order cookies earlier for my sister’s bridal shower, but Open Window Sweets made the situation a breeze!! My friend had referred me to Caiti weeks in advance and I remembered one night that I had completely forgotten to reach out and there was literally 5 or 6 days till the shower. I messaged Caiti and she helped me every step of the way! She matched the colors to my sister’s wedding perfectly and made them custom for her. The cookies were an absolute hit and everyone who had one asked me to send them the link!! I could not be more grateful not only for the willingness to take on 3 dozen cookies last minute, but also to deliver them day-of to me!! I ordered lemon basil (EVERYONE NEEDS TO TRY THESE), her signature almond vanilla, and chocolate. Unfortunately I didn’t get to try the vanilla because they were gone so quick!! Without a doubt, I will be ordering cookies here in the future! Caiti is awesome!! The cookies are fantastic and soft and the frosting is delicious! You can tell the attention to detail and the pride in her work.

Caiti was quick with communication and great to work with! Would highly recommend her cookies too as they are delicious!

I was blown away by how adorable my cookies came out. Not only did they look amazing but they tasted great too!! 4 dozen personalized cookies was no small order either. Beyond happy. Thank you!!

These cookies are always fresh and delicious. From small orders to big orders we have never been disappointed.

My cookies were perfectly decorated amazingly colored and detailed. The flavor was superb. I can't say enough about the service I revieved from Catie and Open Window Sweets. These cookies were fantastic on my sweets table. Thank you !