Ratings & Reviews

I sent a few ideas of what I was looking for, and this cake was so much more than I could have imagined! Not only did it look great, it tasted great too!

The cupcakes and smash cake for this "1" year old birthday party were perfect! We sent only a couple of pictures for reference and the results were amazing. Wish I was able to submit pictures, so cute! The treats were moist and so flavorful...everyone wanted to know where they came from! This is our second time ordering from this "sweet little cottage bakery" and it's our go to bakery from now on out. Thank you!

Beautiful cake! I had an inspo picture and she match it perfectly. Very, very easy to work with. I was in a time crunch and she more than willing to help! I would definitely recommend OnTheSweetList to anyone who needs a cake. Thank you!

They did amazing! Both birthday cakes looked exactly like the inspiration photos. These cakes didn’t just look amazing they also tasted amazing. 10/10 would always recommend them to others.

Absolutely exceeded my expectations. She went out of her way to meet me half way in a snow storm. She's the best!

Absolutely LOVE the cakes we have had done at On the sweet list bakery! She does such an incredible job with the smallest of details and has made my kids dream cakes come to life. Not only do they look fabulous they taste AMAZING!! Every single person at both parties have been blown away and have asked where I had the cakes made! We will be costumers from here on out!

They always knock it out of the park. She always nails the design/inspiration I have and to top it off the taste is out if this world. Hands down top teir work.

They were beautiful and delicious. I recommend bakery.shop. I’ll be ordering again. And Jenny and her husband were sweet and carried to my car. 5 stars from me!!

They taste as amazing as they look!

On The Sweet List came in clutch for me today! I dropped the ball on ordering a birthday cake; she came in last minute and made a BEAUTIFUL cake for a party tonight. Will definitely be using her in the future!

We enjoyed the cupcakes. Very beautiful and tasted delicious.

The cupcakes were ABSOLUTELY delicious and was a hit for our bridal shower! Everyone raved about the cupcakes being stunning, and they tasted amazing!

Everything was amazing, looked awesome and tasted great!

Beautiful AND delicious!!

This cake is everything I could’ve imagined. Stress free and beautiful. Can’t wait to use OnTheSweetList for all our parties

Loved the cake and cupcakes I ordered! Everything turned out beautiful and tastes great!! Highly recommend!!

So often you see beautiful desserts but the flavor doesn't match the beauty, but not my cupcakes I ordered for my mom's 75th birthday party! They were stunning, exactly what I requested and the most delicious buttercream icing and moist cake.

It was my first time using Sweet List Cottage Bakery, wow did we love our cakes or what!? I sent inspo. pics and she delivered! Even better they tasted amazing!

Cannot get over how cute my cake turned out! The turn around time and price were perfect for what I needed!!

The BEST cupcakes I have ever had! They were decorated beautifully. They were incredibly moist and they were HUGE! What a wonderful bakery.

We totally love this cake and cupcake. Best frosting and amazing soft and moist cake. We will definitely be ordering many more holidays from them.

Excellent service and cupcakes! Called at the last minute to add an order that I forgot and she made it happen! Cupcakes were personalized and tasty! Highly recommends!

I was shocked at the detail and time that was put into my cake topper and cupcakes! It was above everything i expected and is a show stopper!! On top of being so well decorated they were delicious. I will come to her for ALL MY CAKES AND SWEETS!!! She also did it a day earlier then I asked and was so sweet about it. 10 out of 10 definitely recommend :)

We had On The Sweet List complete a Winnie the Pooh themed caked for my sister's baby shower. Great communication, nailed the look we wanted, and the cake was AMAZING. The best, and most moist cake I've have had ever in my life. I will be ordering all special occasion cakes from here. 100 out of 10 rating.

The birthday cake was so cute and tasted great highly recommend!

Beyond my expectations!

Beautiful cake, flexible with flavors, willing to work with us, and it tasted amazing! Loaded with sugar.

We DEMOLISHED our chocolate cake with raspberry filling for our daughter’s birthday this weekend. No crumb left behind! It was delicious and absolutely beautiful. We will be repeat customers 🙂

We ordered cake and cupcakes for our daughter’s graduation party. Everything was beautiful and we got so many compliments on how delicious they were! Will definitely order here again!

Wow. It was so very perfect. What a super cute cake. Exactly what I wanted. So much talent. And it was truly the most delicious chocolate cake I’ve ever had. It was moist, delicious and absolutely delicious. Amazing cake

Speedy fast service absolutely beautiful cake packaged with care! Thank you so much!!

This is the second cake I have ordered and both times my experience has been easy, got exactly what I wanted, and cake was wonderful.

My daughter wanted a cowgirl heart shaped birthday cake, I sent Jenny & Nathan the inspiration photos online (easiest ordering process ever) and they created a beautiful cake that was just what she wanted. Easy pick up, and had no issues at all.

Love love love the cake! Beautifully done, can’t ask for anything better!

Did even better than I could have expected. Will be buying again!

I ordered a emoji cake for my daughter’s 11 birthday and it turned out amazing. I sent a couple pictures what I wanted and it was better than I had imaged. My daughter loved it. Ordering process was easy. I’ve been looking for someone local to make cakes as I have five kiddos will definitely be ordering again in the future.

That’s what my husband, a man of few words, said while eating this cake! And placing the order was fast and easy. I love having a local bakery here in Kearney to buy fresh baked items. Great job Jenny!

This cake was soo amazing! He was soo cute and soo delicious!! Highly recommend!

I ordered a cake for my wife’s birthday. At first it was just supposed to be her, the kids and myself. My in laws decided to come in town and I was able to adjust my order for a bigger size cake with no issues. My wife had no idea what kind of cake I got her but she absolutely loved it, ran around the house waking everyone up to look at it after Nathan delivered it. Thank you guys so much for an amazingly designed cake that was so delicious too!

The cake was delicious and exactly what I wanted. Jenny, you never fail to amaze me with your many talents.

I'm leaving one letter per review because I'm planning to buy many cakes from this amazing baker. I've been wowed each time, and I can't wait for the next time I can come up with any excuse to eat cake.

The cupcakes we ordered were fabulous! I highly recommend Jenny!

We ordered a 16th birthday cake and it was beautiful and delicious! Would highly recommend! Thank you for an easy experience and great cake!

I ordered a birthday cake and it was beautiful! Jenny made pickup quick & easy as well. It was everything I asked for & was delicious! Everyone kept commenting on how moist it was how great it looked!😋