Ratings & Reviews

The cookies turned out exactly like I wanted and they were SO good! Will definitely be ordering for my next event!

After looking at Kelsie’s page and seeing the most perfect cookies ever, I immediately knew I wanted her to make my cookies. After giving her my theme, I let her design my cookies and she nailed it! They were everything I could imagine and more!! We got so many compliments on our cookies and the taste was the delicacy on the top!! She is now my go to cookie lady and I can’t wait to order more!!

Kelsie was quick to respond to my original order request. I just let her do her thing with the colors and the theme for the gender reveal. She was upfront with all Cost and she delivered on all counts and The cookies were delicious!

The cookies were amazing!! Not only did they look good, but the taste was A1. Definitely exceeded my expectations. I highly recommend 😍🥰

Amazing service, very professional, and truly saw the vision for the request. I ordered a dozen custom cookie for a baby shower I was hosting and cookies were truly a hit. I will be a returning customer.

After 3 or so orders from this lovely baker, I find any reason to place an order! Not only are her sweets absolutely stunning, they taste amazing! Thank you for always making our occasions special! 💕

I have ordered from OH sugar more than once and I love them EVERYTIME! They are so good, and absolutely beautiful no matter what design you pick!

The cookies came out so much better than I could have ever expected. They are beautiful and perfect!!

We lovedddd are cookies so much! They fit the theme just right. The sugar cookie was soft and not overly sweet which we loved. & the chocolate chip cookies were also a big hit! The best cookies we’ve had in a long time!!

This young lady did an amazing job not only with my cookies by doing exactly what I asked, but also with her services. She made sure to reach out before doing something out of the ordinary, and I received my order in a timely manner. Now that’s how you handle business. Def will be booking again! Thank you girly pop, I wish you nothing but the best! (:

We asked Kelsie to make custom decorated cookies for our son’s graduation and they turned out beautifully. These cookies taste as good as they look- everyone loved them!! Highly recommend Oh Sugar!

Kelsie is nothing short of an amazing Baker! I said i would wait til the day after my daughters birthday to ask everyone “how were the cookies?” immediately after taking bites everyone wanted another! Presentation was almost as good as the taste! EXCELLENT JOB Kelsie we will return AND ORDER MORE (: P.s her customer service was top tier thank you SO MUCH again!

An absolute hit!

Kelsie has been making my sons birthday cookies for the past few years and it’s never a disappointment!! She’s the best !

Cookies were beautiful just like the pictures I sent in! And they’re so delicious! Kelsie was also very sweet and responded quickly to my messages!

Kelsie always does an amazing job and her work is beyond incredible!! We will continue to book with her for all our events!

New to the area and looking for a cookie person. I decided to give Oh Sugar a try and I was not disappointed! She was the sweetest lady and was willing to make the changes I requested. Not only did the cookies look amazing they tasted great!

The detail in each cookie was amazing. You know she took time and love in this set. My favorite set so far. All her cookies are amazing don’t get me wrong. CAREBEARS are my favorite though. I rate her 10 out of 10. You won’t be disappointed in ordering with her. She’s always there to answer any of your questions. She’s truly talented and her cookies taste amazing.