Ratings & Reviews

Extremely responsive, flexible, professional, and makes the absolute best cookies! As long as you keep selling these delicious cookies… we will continue purchasing them!

The cookies were soft and delicious. Love the different flavors, especially the salted chocolate cookie. Something about sweet and salty that taste really good. In my family we can’t just buy one flavor.

I can’t recommend these cookies enough! I ordered a couple of times already and the cookies are always a big hit. The presentation, flavor and customer service are always on point! The kitchen sink, chocolate and red velvet are my faves 😊!

Best homemade cookies in the DMV. Love the flavors. Freshly made!

Some of the best cookies I’ve ever had. I’m a repeat customer. Great for special occasions or whenever we have out of town guests.

Oh My Gooey Cookies truly are my favorite in the DC, Maryland and Virginia area. I previously loved the “pink box” cookie shop but I find Will’s cookies to be far superior. My favorite flavor is the Kitchen Sink. My husband loves the chocolate chip peanut butter cookie. We buy a dozen at the time and since they are individually wrapped and sealed, we freeze them! We take out one or two when we have a craving. Sometimes we put them in the microwave for a few seconds to melt the chocolate! So delicious. The customer service is great as well!