Ratings & Reviews

Besides the oatmeal cream pies being delicious, the ordering and pick up process were a breeze!

The tantalizingly soft and chewy oatmeal cookies surrounding key lime flavored cream and topped with a touch of flaky salt are to die for! Do yourself a favor and place an order.

These are seriously the best oatmeal cream pies that you will ever get your hands on! I just picked up a dozen of her special order, seasonal salted Keylime pies, and I’m not ashamed to admit that I hoard them! My children have never had one of these before, because my husband and I both agree that we’ll go broke by having to buy so many oatmeal cream pies!

My new favorite! Perfectly sweet, salty and tart. A must have summer treat!! 🍋‍🟩

The family member who orders and picks up the OCP’s should be entitled to the last OCP…. that’s all I’m saying. These key lime OCP’s did not last long in our house. The touch of salt was (chef’s kiss), perfection.

Great communication, speedy service, and amazing product!! Always the best!

OCP are the best! I buy them for gifts, celebrations or just as a nice treat All of the flavors are delicious and everyone loves them!

My husband and daughter love oatmeal cream pies and when we saw OCP's Instagram page I knew I needed to order some. I accidently ordered too many but I'm glad that I did because they were so good! We gifted some to our neighbors who loved them as well. We got the original and the chocolate chip. Ordering was easy as was picking them up and I appreciated the directions for storing the oatmeal cream pies. Thank you Oatmeal Cream Pie Company!

My favorite oatmeal cream pies! Key lime and plain are my favorites. You can’t beat the friendly and responsive customer service. She’s so accommodating and payment couldn’t be easier. Thanks!

The ultimate best oatmeal cream pies that I have ever tasted and my kids agree on their amazingness and beg for me to buy more. Andrea is always lovely and professional, too :)

Seriously the most delicious oatmeal cream pies! The cream filling is light and yummy and the cookies are the perfect texture. It takes a lot of self control to not eat an entire bag in one sitting! The owner is also wonderful and always has orders ready on time. We are repeat customers!

A little taste of heaven. These pies are *better than you imagined. Just the right mix of oatmeal cookie and fluffy sweet inside. It’s a treat that will have you thinking about the next bite all day. Share or don’t. Sometimes you just *have to let others know….and sometimes you’ve just gotta make sure your stash is full. Once you’ve tried one, you’ll get it! 😋🍪💯

Excellent oatmeal cream pies. Great snow day treats as a surprise! Loved the fact that I constantly got text message Updates that my order had been received, the invoice had been sent, the invoice was paid, my order was ready, my order had been picked up.

These Oatmeal Cream Pies are the perfect treat for Valentine's Day. My friends and family love them. They are delicious!

OCPs are the best around- gingerbread, key lime, and original are our favorites! Wonderful for gifting too!

We love these treats that are beautiful and absolutely delicious! Small business doing it right - a simple but exquisite product, consistency, & kind customer service.

Andrea is so talented! Her OCPs are amazing!

I have been a customer for 3 years and my family and friends absolutely love these! We get them for our kids birthdays, holidays and just because days! We love supporting such an amazing local business ❤️

This company never disappoints. Their quick responsiveness and customer service are 2nd to none. And the product is to die for, any time of year, but especially at the holidays!

We order oatmeal cream pies from Andrea several times a year and they are consistently fresh and delicious no matter the flavor. My personal favorite is the holiday gingerbread while my husband loves the butterscotch. And you can never go wrong with the original! These are great for family gatherings, hostess or teacher gifts, client gifts, or for birthdays. Highly recommend!

I gave these oatmeal cream pie cookies as Christmas gifts to my child’s teachers, and they were a huge hit. The gingerbread flavor is my new favorite—it’s perfectly spiced and makes the treat feel extra festive. Definitely a go-to for anyone looking for a delicious and thoughtful gift for someone else (or yourself!).

OCPs are always a hit! I appreciate that they are always baked fresh and ready on the day and time as promised! These make great gifts and are always a favorite!

These are my favorite cookies! You can’t ever go wrong with an OCP!

I have ordered a few times from this wonderful small business. This time I ordered the gingerbread oatmeal pie which are so delicious!!! I am making baskets for friends which will include the scrumptious gingerbread pie along with a bag of coffee/tea and a package of pretty napkins. Makes the perfect gift any time of year. The owner is quick to respond to orders and any questions. Always friendly and easy to work with. Will definitely be ordering again.

I could’ve eaten the whole bag myself! We can’t get enough of them.

The OCPs are our family favorites - awesome ‘cookie’, always fresh and great customer service.

OCPs never disappoint. The level of artistry Andrea employs to make these is unmatched. Our family loves all the flavors, but especially the Butterscotch!

I bought these to serve for my Thanksgiving dessert this year and I honestly don’t know how I’m going to have any left by then!!! They are the BEST! Thank you Andrea! I will absolutely be ordering again very soon!

Love the versatility of this grab and go dessert for our 20+ person dinner. The homemade flavor is unmatched and it’s always the star of the show. Thank you!

Nothing compares—these are the best of the best and worth every calorie!

Great product, great customer service, consistently consistent! They are always a huge hit.

These oatmeal cream pies never fail. Every bite is a gift.