Ratings & Reviews

From planning, to delivery, to enjoying these cookies, everything was top tier. It was so fun watching the theme for our cookies come to life and they were a HUGE hit with everyone at the party. Will definitely be ordering again in the future!

I had her make some cookies for my sister’s bachelorette trip and she completely blew me away! The cookies are soft and delicious and the cutest ever! Highly recommend! She is the best! 🤩

Sarah is so talented but these aren’t just pretty cookies- they are really the best tasting cookies!!!

I ordered Easter cookies from Nancy Jane's and had them shipped to me. They arrived in perfect condition and were the talk of our gathering. So beautifully decorated and also delicious. I will definitely be a repeat customer and will recommend these cookies to everyone I know! Thank you!

I was scrolling through Facebook the other day when I saw that Sarah happened to have some cookies that looked just like deviled eggs. I dont know if someone forgot to pick their order up or what, but she posted in our neighborhood group she had a couple of dozen for sale. It was lucky I saw that because it happened to me my daughter's birthday the next day and I was supposed to make lemon bars for the party - but there were too many people coming I would have been baking lemon bars for hours, so I jumped on Sarah's offer. These cookies are so good I was so surprised! First of all, they look just like deviled eggs. Everybody at the party was talking about it. The ladies who like deviled eggs were marveling at the paprika which is not paprika but some kind of colored sugar but seriously if you looked at the table you would think we had some lemon bars and some plates of deviled eggs. And here's the thing: they look so good that I thought - well they're probably just going to be serviceable and taste ok. WRONG. The cookies were really good!! I was really surprised! The cookies had a great texture and they were soft and chewy. The icing wasn't hard even though it's set, so I thought it might crumble when I bit into it, but it just melted in my mouth. These were great cookies, we will totally get cookies again from Sarah. Thank you so much!

These custom cookies are absolutely amazing! They look stunning and taste even better. You can tell they’re made with love and serious talent. Perfect for any event or just a sweet treat for yourself. The owner is super kind, easy to work with, and puts so much care into every order. Highly recommend!

We recently placed a very large cookie order (240 cookies!) for a corporate event and we’re more than pleased with our Nancy Jane’s cookies!! Not only were they so beautiful (Sarah went above and beyond to come up with fun and beautiful designs that fit our event), but they were so delicious. The cookies are so soft and have the best flavor! Often times, custom sugar cookies are hard and chalky.. but these were wonderful. We got many comments from attendees that were impressed with the cookies 🤍 Highly recommend Nancy Jane’s!!