Ratings & Reviews

Cannot recommend Jamie enough!! Ordered a gluten free sourdough and it was phenomenal and my favorite is the original sour dough!! I literally can finish the bread in a day, it’s that good.

I buy from Jamie every week and genuinely look forward to it. It’s more of an investment than store-bought bread, but the quality is on another level and so worth it to me. You can tell she uses the best ingredients and puts real care into everything she makes. The English muffins are my absolute favorite… I’m borderline addicted, but truly everything I’ve had has been so good. Love supporting local, especially when it’s this high quality.

Part time to the Naples area and had been following on Instagram for some time. Finally had the chance to order some sourdough bread and it was great! Bagels and chocolate chip cookies were delicious! I will be ordering again and looking forward to trying more products! Jamie was great to work with and coordinate our pickup!

So delicious and of course not only was the cake beautiful but it was made with quality ingredients ❤️

My grandchildren used to come down to visit us and enjoy Naples! Now they come down for Jayme’s bread. What more can I say?

My Naples Kitchen bakes the best sourdough bread. I was very surprised to find sourdough pretzels, which I love! I look forward to trying all the varieties.

Beautifully presented and delicious!

My husband and I are OBSESSED with sourdough everything, and this is truly the best sourdough we've had!! The pretzels, bagels, and bread are just incredible, the flavor is strong, and everything is so fresh!! Our new go-to sourdough, thank you Jamie!!

These were some of the best cinnamon rolls I’ve ever had. Soft, pillowy, and perfectly baked with the perfect amount of sweetness. The texture and flavor were absolutely flawless. They were such a special treat for New Year’s Day and made the morning feel extra celebratory. I could not stop talking about them and have told everyone I know in Naples to try them. On top of that, they are organic and seed oil free, which makes them even better. We will definitely be ordering again and can’t wait to try the other items!

Not only do I dream about those blueberry lemon cupcakes, they are delicious every single time!! And oh so beautiful! Thank you!

I ordered a loaf of the bread for Christmas dinner. I had tried it before and knew how good it was, but my guests had not. After their first slice they were going after more. When it came to packaging up left overs the bread was the first thing to disappear. It may seem a little pricey, but the loaves are huge. I strongly recommend all of her products. They are all just as good!! Enjoy!!

I will gladly drive out of my way or walk or whatever it takes to get Jamie’s deliriously delicious sourdough. I feel sorry for other breads as they will never measure up or rise to level of Jamie’s bread!

So happy with everything we got from Jamie . The cookies are divine

My Naples Kitchen delivers unbeatable quality with fresh, organic, non-GMO ingredients—never canned or engineered. Jamie’s baked goods look and taste amazing, from Thanksgiving pies to a custom CrossFit-themed cake. Even leftovers stayed delicious. Worth every penny, and I’ll gladly recommend her to everyone.

I ordered a variety of baked goods and every single item was absolutely amazing! You can truly taste the care and love put into the baking — everything was fresh, soft, and full of flavor. And the glaze on the rolls? Uniquely incredible. Sweet, smooth, and unlike anything I’ve had before. I’ll definitely be ordering again! Highly recommend. 💛🍞✨

I never have time to bake so I use My Naples Kitchen to do the baking for me. Not only are there products delicious, but very affordable with easy pick up options. Five stars all around.

Excellent

Ordered Thanksgiving pies, cookies, bread and pumpkin loaf. All were excellent

A huge thank-you to Jamie for coming through on my short notice request. The cookies and pumpkin muffins were absolutely delicious—everyone at our gathering of old friends was thrilled with your baked treats. Your consistency and exceptional quality are truly appreciated.

Jamie, your baked goods are outstanding once again-so delicious, fresh, and full of flavor. Thank you for having everything prepared right on time for my family’s arrival from Canada. We truly appreciate your consistency and care!

Everything I ordered was fresh, delicious and packaged nicely. It was an easy process from ordering and picking up.

We really enjoy all of the products Jamie offers.. thanks!!

I special ordered oatmeal cranberry cookies. Picked them up this morning and enjoyed a special treat. The best oatmeal cookie I ever had. Thank you Jamie.

Love the pretzels and cream cheese rolls and pumpkin bread—So delicious! Can also be frozen

I was so happy when I found Jamie! I have ordered from her many times and just wished I lived closer so I could order more often. Everything I’ve had is amazing and she always responds back quickly. My kids love it all too!

So far I’ve tried the pumpkin cream cheese muffins- and they’re amazing! Not too sweet and no seed oils! They were packed perfectly in a nice box. Excellent quality and presentation. I also ordered a couple pies for pickup for our Thanksgiving dinner.

The cupcakes were super yummy! And perfect for a baby shower.

Everything I have purchased from My Naples Kitchen has been outstanding, but special shout out to the sourdough blueberry and plain English muffins. Delicious! 😋 And if you ever need cupcakes for any occasion, be sure to contact Jamie!

Wow, not only delicious but also Organic! Very tasty and so fresh - totally recommend!!!

I took my boule home, sliced her up and toasted my first piece with lots of Kerrygold butter and I have to say, it’s the best I’ve ever had.

My daughter has been enjoying the sourdough bread, bagels, and cookies made by Jamie so I decided to try a custom birthday cake for my daughter’s big birthday. She made her dream cake craving come true . A moist rich devil foods chocolate with some sour dough starter added to the cake with pumpkin cheesecake frosting . A perfect fall themed unique birthday cake flavor combo and it was delicious . Everyone enjoyed it and look forward to future cake and baking orders.

All I can say is WOW!! Delicious sour dough bread! Last night I took the cupcakes to an event with 12 ladies & they were all crazy about the cupcakes! They couldn’t stop asking where I got them! The cupcakes were gorgeous done in light pastels & so delish! I’m forever a customer! I’ll be ordering again & again! And Jaime the owner is a doll! Thank you!

This cake was beautiful and delicious! The flavor was better than expected, loved the frosting flavor too!! It was decorated beautifully and Jamie communicated super well with updates and was very accommodating. Highly recommend!! She made out little family even so special ❤️

Everything was delicious! Easy pick up. Will definitely will be ordering from them again!

So good ,so fresh

We had family in town and used it as an excuse to order baked goods from My Naples Kitchen. The miso chocolate cookies and the pumpkin cream cheese muffins were absolutely amazing and a crowd pleaser! We also ordered the soft pretzels, so delicate and melt in your mouth! Will absolutely order again!

Coming from Connecticut and missing the Pumpkin flavors and the Fall Sweater Weather season this Baker brought me back to memories of tasting seasonal treats. Her Pumpkin Bread had a Slight Crisp to the outside while moist and flavorful on the inside. Definitely worth a 10.

Jamie’s sourdough baked goods are truly delicious! We love the clean ingredients she uses and all the different choices offered. She made the pick up super easy with great communication from the moment I placed the order.

I’m really picky when it comes to sourdough, and this was my favorite loaf! Perfect level of crustiness and so soft and fluffy on the inside. I had to be careful not to eat half a loaf instantly. Oh and the cinnamon raisin bagels were a hit! Can’t wait to try to rest of her offerings. Pickup process so easy and convenient, I didn’t even have to leave my car, so the babies could stay asleep.

Jamie didn’t just make cupcakes, Jamie created edible works of art. These beauties were almost too pretty to eat… almost. Once I took a bite, though, it was game over. The espresso martini cupcakes were absolutely amazing. 10/10 highly recommend !

Best donuts and cookies in Naples! Excellent taste, healthy ingredients and beautiful presentation.

I ordered two loafs. Blueberry/lemon and sourdough..both were delicious! Cant wait to try some of the sweets. Jamie was very easy to work with and easy to get a hold of.

Absolutely Delicious and great communication, fast and easy order!

The best cookies and brownies!

Best Blueberry muffins I’ve ever had… didn’t even need butter because the taste was so good!

I ordered the Nutella pop tarts as a special treat for my family and we all loved them. You can taste the good ingredients used for the pastry which is refreshing.

The cake is amazing. Exactly what I want. My son is so happy to see it and taste delicious. Thank you.

Ordered Pretzel bites for a Father’s Day BBQ. They were made fresh that morning & delivered on time. Fresh & just great tasting!! Would highly recommend.

I ordered a custom birthday cake from My Naples Kitchen and it completely exceeded my expectations! They took an idea and brought it to life in the most beautiful way! And it tasted incredible! It was a hit at the party! Highly recommend for any special occasion!

Good home baked goods are always good but from someone who loves baking they are even better! Naples kitchen makes everything personalized for your order & everything is the best in Naples! I have eaten entire batches of cookies in 24 hours . So delicious!

Absolutely the best chocolate chip cookies (with sea salt) that have ever had ! Great service great selection !

Jamie’s gluten, sugar and dairy free cookies were amazing. I popped them in the freezer for a delicious post workout treat! I will be ordering more.

The chocolate chip cookies are worth every calorie! The hot out of the oven bagels are a morning treat!

I am in LOVE!! The best baked goods I’ve had in years!! This time we got the pretzel bites…hands down the best I’ve ever had!!!

the best cookies I have ever had! !!will definitely order again .

The aroma of freshly baked bread seeped from the bread bag to start with . Took all my willpower to bike home with it . Upon slicing the perfect size of bread slice; thick , thick . Yum !! Scrumptious!!! Devine ! Fact is ; If you bread . This is the bread to bread with . Thanks Jamie for the best bread !

The birthday cake I ordered was fabulous. Everyone raved about the presentation and most important the taste. It had no dairy, no nuts, no refined sugar and was gluten free. It had have tons of flavor and fresh berries. I highly recommend Jamie for your special dietary needs. You will not be disappointed.

As a foodie I love to eat ALL sorts of food and it doesn’t matter where it’s from. I heard around town of this nice lady that bakes, so I got My Naples Kitchens info from a friend, I am thrilled I did! I got sourdough bagels that were honestly life changing! The smell of them alone probably made me gain 20lbs-LOL! But seriously they were spectacular, they were light, fluffy with a bit of a crisp! I ate them all by themselves because I was fearful butter, cream cheese or jam would have ruined the deliciousness of the actual bagel! I highly recommend this business and can not wait to try her pretzels because I heard they were out of bounds!!! Thank you for feeding me My Naples Kitchen!!!!

My Naples Kitchen catered a celebration of life breakfast for a member of our community. There were 3 kinds of muffins, 3 kinds of bagels, the most incredible cinnamon rolls you’ll ever eat in your life + chocolate chip cookies that you’ll wish you knew how to bake… all I can say is that thank goodness the leftovers got spread around because I have no self control when it comes to Jamie’s baked goods. From start to finish, she had everything covered, delivered food on time, was present to make sure everyone had what they needed, etc. My Naples Kitchen will be our go to caterer from now on. 10/10 recommend! Thanks Jamie!

Naples Kitchen has completely won me over with their treats! The Cookies and Cream Protein Bars are the perfect mix of delicious and satisfying — I could eat them every day and not get tired. And don’t even get me started on the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake — it’s pure heaven! Rich, decadent, and absolutely worth every bite. You can tell they put love and quality into everything they make. Highly recommend!

Picked up English muffins, bagels and cinnamon buns. What can I say. Delicious. Jamie uses the finest ingredients and she has made my household very happy. I forgot to mention her chocolate chip cookies are the bomb!!!!!

Beautiful cake, tasted amazing and fast

I can’t recommend Jamie’s Sourdough Creations enough. They are the best and unbelievable delicious. Our fav is the Boule!

Jamie’s baking skills are incredible. Everything she made for us was better than what we purchased at any bakery around here and her buttercream frosting has ruined my diet for Months!

These cookies were delicious! 10/10

I ordered some delightful items because my grandchildren are coming for a visit. When I brought them home, my husband and I couldn’t help but try a few! The chocolate chip cookies are the best I’ve ever had…. and the strawberry pop tarts are delicious!!! I can’t wait to try the bagels!!!

Just picked up my first order of sourdough from Jamie. Couldn’t wait to taste it, so dug right in. Best I’ve had yet! Got the boule (which is what I tasted) & also the sandwich loaf & English muffins. Glad I found her & I’m sure this will be on repeat! So so good ❤️

These cookies were truly excellent, definitely recommend trying!!

The chocolate chip cookies with sea salt were amazing . Jamie was a pleasure to order from and accommodated our request so quickly .

These cookies were by far the best I’ve ever tasted! Nothing would even come in a close second. Will order again soon!

The cinnamon bread is absolutely amazing! It is suppose to be for guests and I keep eating it! The bagels were very good as well !

Very professional. Met me at the car with my order. Can’t wait to try the sourdough.

Outstanding - the most delicious treats!!!

Not only are the cookies delicious, Jamie is so sweet! Also ordering was super easy!!

Delicious cupcakes!!

I loved the sourdough chocolate chip cookies and cinnamon rolls. They are so light and fresh . I’m so thrilled that we have a baker in town that will take her time and love to make such healthy and delicious treats . I would definitely purchase again!

Hands down the best bread I’ve had! The sourdough was flavorful and fresh, and the cinnamon bun was a delightful treat with its soft, buttery texture. Worth every bite!

Jamie was so easy to work with for my wedding celebration; she made the process seamless, provided communication every step of the way, and my desserts came out amazing! I ordered a cake and 5 dozen cupcakes in different flavors, all of which were the best we have ever tasted! I had a sunflower theme and the cake was just beautiful. Jamie also gave me so many different flavors to choose from which helped a ton because we didn’t know what we wanted. Our main wedding cake was chocolate with peanut butter and our guests were raving; a number of my friends even requested her contact. I am so happy to have chosen Jamie and highly recommend her bakery, we look forward to using her again in the future!

We ordered a bunch of blueberry donuts and chocolate chip cookies as some vacation treats. The donuts were good—big & filling, but not too sweet. The chocolate chip cookies were stellar—like seriously as good as it gets. Can’t wait to get some bread and try some other unique creations next time!

I ordered a dozen bagels & English muffins for my family, and we are really enjoying them! They taste so different from store bought and I love knowing that we are putting healthy ingredients into our bodies. My 7yr old especially loves the bagels! Thank you!

Look no further for you breads, English muffins, and chocolate chip COOKIES. Jamie has the secret sauce. The second I took a bite of the chocolate chip cookies, (which by the way has salt on top)… I was transported to a chocolate paradise of deliciousness. Everything she makes is amazing. Support this amazing local baker!

These muffins are incredible! Jaime never disappoints. We get all our baked goods from My Naples Kitchen and really grateful she’s right here in East Naples. Other items from the bakery we love are (all organic) : pumpkin protien bites, sourdough ciabatta rolls and loaf as well as an amazing cheesecake key lime pie! Highly recommend.

Thoroughly enjoyed yet another sourdough bread from Jamie. Her baking never disappoints!

Jamie is amazing! Her baking skills are unmatched ❤️

The sourdough jalapeño bagels are amazing! Off the charts….

The loaf is beautiful looks like artwork! I have so enjoyed both the loaf and bagels. They are awesome. So happy I found you.

Despite Naples reputation as a destination for fine dining I have had little success in finding bread like I grew up with until now. My Naples Kitchen bakes a crusty, flavorful Sourdough boule that brings back memories of bread baked in coal fired ovens. All ingredients are reported to be organic and the quality is evident from the first bight!

Amazing!!!!

Delicious😋

My kids loved the pop tarts!!! We are all enjoying them. The peppermint mocha sourdough is delicious !! Perfect addition to our christmas ! Jamie was awesome ans easy to work with. Highly recommend and cant wait to purchase more !

Our Christmas order was perfect and it was a miracle it even made it home in one piece! Jayme is the best and we are so lucky to have her in our area!!

Really enjoyed the cookies we ordered. Also, very easy process getting custom order. Highly recommend!

The exceptional quality of the ingredients truly shines through in every bite. I’m so glad I decided to try these beautifully crafted pies and rolls this year! They’ve exceeded my expectations, and I’ll definitely be ordering more for Christmas. Thank you for your outstanding work!

Jamie’s bread and pie are awesome! She’s the best in Naples !!

Everything I always order is amazing! Had the apple cinnamon rolls for the first time…11/10 🩷

I ordered My Naples Kitchen’s sourdough loaves and cookies and had them shipped to Connecticut for Thanksgiving. They arrived in perfect shape and were so fresh and delicious! They were such a hit with the entire family! Can’t wait to order again soon!

Delicious, not too sweet. Very enjoyable with my afternoon coffee

The items were made with organic fresh ingredients and were absolutely delicious. I can’t wait to order them again ! Highly recommended

easy ordering and sourdough loaf was hot and delicious

Cinnamon bread was incredible! Fresh baked day of when I received it. I will purchase more again.

Another order with My Naples kitchen and she never disappoints! 5 stars

ordered my stock of peanut butter and vanilla oreos, sourdough and pumpkin cheesecake muffins. everything was amazing and lasted less than 48hrs in my house.

The English Muffins are our favorite. They are healthy with organic ingredients and they are delicious.These muffins are not like store bought, they have the homemade taste. 🥰

First time trying the blueberry donuts! Jamie once again didn't disappoint. Can't wait to try the pretzels and English muffins.....all of her products are always so fresh and delicious.

Highly recommend! Not too sweet…first time trying them & it won’t be our last 👍🏻

i ordered strawberry poptarts, chocolate cherry sourdough, plain sourdough AND apple pie cinnamon rolls. everything was gone within two days. delicious and fresh every single time. once you order, you won't stop.

This is convenient and simply to use!

The cookies are amazing!

Everything bagels, pop tarts and cherry espresso loaf and it’s hard to pick what’s best, because they all taste amazing. I’m looking forward to trying something different with every order! 5 stars!

I love love everything Jaimie makes but i especially love her pretzel, pretzel bites and sourdough breads!!!! She is an amazing baker!

If you haven't tried these sourdough pretzels yet, you're missing out! They didn't last a day in my house—they're that good! I'll definitely be ordering more soon. Highly recommend giving them a try!

As a nurse I commit myself to feeding my body clean food with no artificial sweeteners or dyes. Jamie is the most dedicated baker for ensuring her baked goods satisfy what’s best for your gut and is absolutely delicious. She delivers the most perfectly crafted baked goods. Support local and try it you won’t go back.

Amazing! Absolutely recommend, my entire family loves the bagels!

I’ve been ordering Sourdough bread from My Naples kitchen and I must say it is delicious! My 89 year old mother in New York loves sourdough and when I visit her I bring her the bread and/or the gigantic English muffins Jamie makes. I will continue to order the sourdough.

i have been ordering from jamie for awhile now and i try to order once per week. i have become spoiled with her fresh sourdough and you should do it to yourself too. THE BEST!

Ordered a sourdough and chocolate espresso loaf. It’s absolutely like nothing I’ve ever tried before or any flavor you can ge tin the area. Worth every penny!

Ordered the pretzel bites for a party & what a hit. They were fresh , soft, & of course tasty. I also got a sourdough loaf and made avocado toast on it …so good. Support small local business & fresh homemade

Utterly amazing!

I’m writing this as I eat warm delicious bagels I just picked up from Jamie’s place. Can’t say enough good things about how awesome these bagels are. Highly recommend them and I’ll be a return costumer.

The bagels are fresh and absolutely delicious!