Ratings & Reviews

I have ordered baked goods a couple of times. I have never been disappointed. They are always so pretty you hate to eat them but once you take that first bite, you are hooked amazing cakes by an amazing lady never any leftovers.

Realized I spaced and forgot to order my daughter a themed cake she asked for her 16th birthday, found Donna within seconds and she delivered exactly what we asked for in Just one day! Not to mention it was delicious! Keeping her info for future birthdays. I cannot thank her enough for this.

This cake was not only the PERFECT cake for a Harry Potter fan, but it was also delicious! Honestly, after seeing what a fantastic job she did on the design, I was not too concerned if it didn't taste great, but it did! This was the best tasting cake i have ever had. Every person was amazed at how good it was. This cake was the talk of the entire restaurant! It all started wet me sending a picture i find online. My son is a huge Harry Potter fan and i really wanted something extraordinary for his birthday. Donna was so good about communicating with me throughout the process of this masterpiece. I do not know much about baking or designing, but thank goodness Donna does. She kept me in the loop throughout the process and explained my options on flavors, icing, design,etc. I could not be happier with the results! Thank you Donna for your time, your patience, and your skills. Every cake for any occasion will now be from My Fancy Little Cakes!

This was my first order with My Fancy Little Cakes and we can’t wait to have an occasion to order from Donna again! She created the viral “Squishy Dumpling” that my son is obsessed with and it was amazing! He squealed with delight and amazement when he saw it! The chocolate cherry cake was delicious. Donna is a true artist baker! She was so kind and professional as well. Just an awesome experience!

Donna is fabulous to work with! I had an idea I wanted for a bridal shower, and she made the most beautiful wedding dress cupcakes! And they tasted amazing! I highly recommend her!!!

Wow! Donna did an amazing job! The cake was delicious and a masterpiece. She nailed the design! Thank you’

Another fantastic cake ! Such a delicious treat For special birthday friends! Cannot wait to order another cake soon.🎂

Great Cake, nicely designed

I was recommended to Donna for a cake and she amazingly delivered! It was exactly like the inspiration picture I showed and she even accommodated a last minute delivery to my home. We loved it.

Best cookies in town!

10/10 I love you thank you so much

We couldn't have been happier with our wedding cake! It was absolutely beautiful and tasted even better than it looked. Highly recommend.

What is the best way to find the best cake in town?? Look no further folks. The best advertisement is word of mouth!! That is how I found My Fancy Little Cakes. Donna made a delicious German Chocolate cake for my friends birthday and it was delicious. This is a cake your grandmother would be proud of. Honestly, this is a cake your grandmother would have made. So delicious!! Thank you Donna for putting love into your cakes!!

Our family loves to celebrate birthdays with German chocolate cake. Donna outdid herself with her delicious coconut pecan delight! It was loved by all! 🙌🏻

Donna, created a delicious masterpiece for our Grand Opening event at Olive Tree Family Counseling! It was gorgeous and scrumptious!

My cake was gorgeous done in Margaritaville style. It was absolutely delicious!! Highly recommend!!

The carrot cake was delicious and large. It could feed 15 people or more easily. Meet up in New Bern was good. Thanks again.

I love key lime have never had a key lime cake. Donna obviously puts her heart into her "Fancy Little Cakes" sweetest woman ever. I know it will be enjoyed by my Bible Study Group my mouth is watering just looking at it!

Not only were the cakes beautiful and turned out WAY better than the inspiration pictures I provided, they tasted amazing. I would absolutely recommend getting cakes from her for any occasion.

We had a surprise party for my MIL in November and everyone loved the vanilla cake with buttercream icing! And the design of the cake exceeded my inspo pic! We were very pleased😊

Not only are the cookies and cupcakes outstanding, the customer service is top notch! Can’t go wrong ordering from My Fancy Little Cakes!

Friendly, prompt service. Good communication. Cupcakes were just as expected. Packaged in nice box for easy transportation. Excellent taste, beautifully decorated. You won’t be disappointed with My Fancy Little cakes.

Donna made a cake and cupcakes for a baby shower and I hosted and she did not disappoint. Very professional and polite. Her artistic ability is phenomenal and they tasted good as well. Recommend to all my friends and family!

Bought sweet potato cupcakes with marshmallow icing and chocolate chip cookies for my husband birthday, absolutely delicious

Lovely pumpkin taste with light butter crème icing. Pairs well with a dark roast and cool autumn weather!!

The yummiest and so beautiful!!!! Would highly recommend to anyone!!! Everyone commented how delicious they were

I ordered cupcakes for a co-workers birthday and they were both gorgeous and delicious! They arrived on time and the customer service was outstanding! Will order again in the future!

The best cookies and the decorations on them are amazing ❤️

These cookies are AMAZING!!! They’re huge, and just the right amount of soft. I’m fortunate to get to be there when they’re fresh out of the oven, but their life span days later is still the same! Such a wonderful treat, and my clients love them!

She did an amazing job. The ring cupcakes were amazing. Personal delivery. Really put an amazing touch on the wedding shower!!!!

The special cupcakes were perfect. Tasted wonderful, workmanship perfection. Can’t wait for our next gathering!

Donna made a fishing cake for my son’s 5th birthday. It was delicious AND adorable! My Fancy Little Cakes will be my go-to for occasions in the future!

We enjoyed our dozen cupcakes 🧁 full of flavor & beautiful presentation. Definitely ordering again & soon!

Cake was identical to the picture shown and colors! It was very pretty and detailed . The cake was also very good and everyone loved it .

Donna always makes the best cupcakes. We have ordered them many times and they are always delicious.

The cupcakes are absolutely delicious on top of great customer service

The strawberry cupcakes were a BIG hit!!absolutely delicious!!

Best cake, very fair pricing, fast turnaround. Personal delivery. I have noting but the best say. Second time ordering and there will be more orders. I’m a repeat customer for life!

The cupcakes were delicious! Definitely can't eat just one! Loved the drum decorations for my husband. The chocolate chip cookies are out of this world!! I will definitely be ordering again!! Thank you, Donna! These were the best treats we've had in a long time!

Thank you for the delicious up ales for our company monthly birthday celebration. Everyone said they were awesome! I indulged in the chocolate ones. Fabulous!

Donna did an outstanding job providing our church Lambs Care graduation cup cakes. She got so creative and decorated way beyond our expectations and they were so cute. And Delicious!!! Thank you Donna, you have a special gift. Thank you for sharing that with us!!!!

OMG AMAZING, delicious, affordable, easy to order and meet up with for delivery! 100% recommend!

The ease of ordering and the best chocolate icing I’ve ever had! And I can not say enough about the chocolate chip cookies. Will be ordering again soon! Thank you!

I’ve ordered several batches of cookies as closing gifts for my clients, and some for my own household. They’re ALWAYS a big hit!! I’m always hearing how wonderful and delicious “those cookies were”! The cupcakes are a favorite as well. Donna is always responsive and prompt with orders. The app is also easy to use for ordering and invoicing. I cant say enough good things! Fancy Little Cakes is definitely my go-to!

Delicious and beautiful!

I ordered the carrot cake for Thanksgiving and chocolate cake for Christmas. Best decision I have ever made. Both were delicious and family raved about them. Will definitely be ordering again in the near future. Thank you, Donna for your beautiful Fancy Little Cakes, though little they are not! Perfection!!

I can’t recommend My Fancy Little Cakes enough! Her cakes are not only absolutely delicious but her creativity is truly on point. Every detail is beautifully executed, and her designs are a perfect blend of artistry and flavor. Whether it’s a special occasion or just a treat, her cakes never disappoint. She’s my go-to for stunning, mouthwatering desserts! Thank you Ms. Donna for always coming through!! 💕

3rd or 4th time ordering from Mrs. Donna and they are just as delicious as ever!!! 🥰

Cake and cupcakes were awesome! Thank you!

Absolutely awesome! Beautiful cake for our family Christmas celebration. Highly recommend. Thanks for helping make our Christmas even more special!

Beautiful and delicious! You can't go wrong with these goodies!!

I ordered 2 dozen, 2 different flavors and they are absolutely delicious !!!

Donna made Christmas cupcakes for us to sample for an upcoming event. Not only were they beautiful, they were delicious! Thank you!

Donna did a wonderful job of making a chicken cake! Tasted wonderful, it was absolutely perfect!

The cupcakes for my baby shower were absolutely beautiful and delicious! Donna even customized them to match my woodland themed baby shower. We will definitely be ordering again!

The best cupcake the name says it all ‘better than sex pumpkin’ I was planning to share these 6 I bought but as my count lowered I somehow forgot. Every bite I wanted to savor to the last crumb. Definitely will be ordering again. I'm hooked

The cake was for my daughter’s birthday and it was so cute and delicious! She was really happy. Thank you, Donna!

This is the third time I have ordered from My Fancy Little Cake and they never disappoint. Can’t wait to see what new and exciting flavors are up next!

The honey lemon cupcakes were a hit at a party I hosted! They were everything and more😋 Donna is an amazing baker and I’m sure the other flavors are delicious as well. Can’t wait to try more!

The gluten free chocolate cupcakes with chocolate frosting and caramel drizzle was AMAZING. 10/10 will be ordering again.