Moon&May Bakery
Featured Products
Cakesicles
Cakesicles are a fun, elegant dessert made with moist cake, molded into popsicle shapes and coated in smooth almond bark. Perfect for events, party favors, or dessert tables. Sold by the dozen and available in chocolate or vanilla.
Starting at $35.00
click for description
Signature Torte Cake
Sweet & Simple Signature Torte Cakes From-scratch torte cakes made with rich batters, creamy buttercreams, and thoughtfully layered flavors. These cakes are designed to highlight quality ingredients and balanced sweetness, finished with a clean, minimal look. Focusing on flavor and NO customizations. Sizes 6” or 8” round Flavors Triple Chocolate Deep, chocolatey cake layered with silky chocolate buttercream and finished with a smooth chocolate ganache drip. Confetti Birthday Soft vanilla confetti cake frosted with classic vanilla buttercream and folded with cheerful rainbow sprinkles in every bite. Red Velvet Moist red velvet cake paired with smooth vanilla buttercream and a delicate layer of white chocolate buttercream for added richness. Cookies & Cream Fluffy vanilla cake layered with cookies & cream buttercream, packed with crushed cookies and finished with Oreo crumbles throughout. Details Minimal, standard design Focus on flavor over customization “Happy Birthday” topper available upon request Ordering Notice 3–5 days’ notice preferred. Need it sooner? Reach out to check availability.
Starting at $45.00
click for description
Custom Cake
Got something to celebrate? We’ve got the cake. Pick your flavor, design, and message, and we’ll make a custom cake that’s just right for your occasion. Fun, fresh, and made just for you. Cake Sizes: 6”, 8”, 10” Round/Heart Two-Tiered Custom Add-Ons: • Edible images • Custom toppers • Chocolate lettering & numbers • Detailed piping designs+fondant details
Starting at $75.00
click for description
Cookie Cake
Our cookie cakes are soft, buttery, and baked to golden perfection—then finished with our signature vanilla buttercream. Each one is handcrafted from scratch and fully customizable with your choice of flavor, shape, lettering, numbers, or design. Perfect for birthdays, celebrations, or anytime you want something a little extra special. Available in 1–2 layers.
Starting at $40.00
click for description
About
Cottage home bakery located in
Andover, OH!
Specializing in custom cakes, cookie cakes, cupcakes, and other sweet treats.
Uniquely handcrafted from scratch with quality ingredients.
Capabilities & Pricing
We specialize in handcrafted, made-from-scratch cakes and treats designed for small to medium-sized gatherings. Every order is fully custom, thoughtfully crafted to match your vision and made with the quality ingredients. Because each creation is unique, our pricing reflects the care and detail that goes into every bite.
Ready to bring your idea to life? Submit an order request for a personalized quote today. Prices vary by size, flavors/fillings, and design complexity!
Policies
About Me
Hi friends! I’m Macie — the baker and mama behind Moon&May Bakery. I’ve been baking for as long as I can remember and finally decided to turn my passion into a business I love.
Moon&May Bakery is a small, home-based cottage bakery where every cake is made with care, creativity, and a personal touch. Before starting Moon&May, I worked in the food industry for several years, where I learned the ins and outs of great service and running a business.
Now, I get to pour that experience (and a whole lot of love) into creating custom cakes that help make your celebrations extra special.
Terms & Conditions
A 50% non-refundable deposit is required to secure your order.
Full payment due is before/at time of pickup.
Cancellations: Deposits are non-refundable. Full payment is non-refundable if canceled within 7 days of event.
Pickup/Delivery: Client assumes all responsibility once order leaves premises/once order is delivered.
Customers are required to pick up their order during the agreed-upon pickup window. Please respect this scheduled time, as we carefully coordinate our baking and family schedules around it.
If you are running late or need to adjust pickup, clear and timely communication is expected. Likewise, Moon & May Bakery will communicate promptly if any changes arise on our end.
We ask that both parties respect each other’s time to ensure a smooth and positive experience. Failure to show up during the scheduled window without communication may result in a cancellation with no refund.
Allergens: Products are made in a home kitchen and may contain or come into contact with milk, eggs, soy, wheat, and food dyes or common pet allergens.
Storage & Handling
All products are baked in compliance with Cottage Food Law. Items are made from safe, high-quality ingredients and are shelf-stable at room temperature. To maintain freshness and quality, store cakes and cookie cakes in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight or heat. Refrigeration is optional but recommended in warm environments or if the product will not be served within a day or two. Avoid exposure to heat to prevent melting or damage to decorations.
Customer Responsibility: Customers assume the responsibility to properly store cakes as instructed. Moon&May Bakery is not responsible for products once picked up or after delivery.
Design Disclaimer: Each item is handcrafted, so slight variations in color, design, and decoration may occur. Exact replicas of inspiration photos are not guaranteed. We celebrate our creativity and the artistry of other bakers, so while we’re happy to use photos for inspiration, every cake we make is our own unique creation made in the Moon&May Bakery style.
Powered by
