Ratings & Reviews

We weren’t able to eat the cookies right away & they were still SO good being individually wrapped/sealed. They tasted like they were baked that day!

I saw Allie post a picture of her cookies she was selling today and just knew I had to have some! I sent her a message with what I’d like and she had them ready for me to pick up on a short notice since I missed the sale which I was very thankful for. We tried four different cookie flavors, they were all delicious! The sea salt she uses really brings out the flavors. She has some really great flavors like the salt n sugar marg which was both my husband and I’s favorite flavor! The cookie is soft and the icing is great! The presentation is also wonderful! I’d recommend her if you have a craving as it looks like she does different kind of great desserts too! We ate all the cookies in one sitting. I can’t wait to order in the future!

I ordered a cookie cake from Allie for my mom’s birthday, and we absolutely LOVED it! The design was perfect—she did a beautiful job with the writing and color choices. You can really tell she puts care and creativity into her work. It not only looked amazing but tasted incredible too. I’d definitely order from her again. Highly recommend!

Midwest Sliced & Iced has the best cookies I’ve ever had. The oatmeal cream pies are simply divine. They taste exactly reminiscent of childhood oatmeal cream pies, but feel a lot healthier and upscaled. I’ve also had the pleasure of getting her blueberry pop tarts and they are simply to die for with the shortbread crust and the homemade jam inside it is amazing. Everything I’ve tried on the new drop menu has been delicious as well, a few that were gotten in the past were lemon bars, and the magic cookie bars! You’ll want to eat everything up so fast but I try to save them and savor each taste. 😋

I just love love love the Chocolate chip cookies with little bits of salt on them! So yummy! The whole family enjoyed

The new summer pop tarts are amazing! The flavors work so well together and the pop tart is a mix of crunchy and yummy goodness! The lemon blueberry pop tart is probably my favorite out of the 2 new flavors but they are both so tasty! The OCP’s of course are a CLASSIC and are so good!! You can tell that Allie puts a lot of time and effort to bake all of these goodies! I shall be buying more from her!

Absolutely delicious! Every bite of these baked goods is a perfect balance of flavor, texture, and love. From the flaky pastries to the soft, chewy cookies, everything is made with obvious care and talent. The presentation is beautiful, and the taste is even better—like something out of a high-end bakery. You can tell fresh, quality ingredients are used. Truly a five-star experience. Can’t wait to order again and try even more! Highly recommended to anyone with a sweet tooth.

I've had a chance to try a handful of items from Midwest Sliced & Iced and everything so far that I have tried has been SO GOOD!! She continues to crank out new items too! Her communication, ordering, and timeliness is top notch. I am crazily obsessed with the oatmeal cream pies in particular lol. When I took my first bite into one, I was not expecting them to be that good!!! It is PERFECTION. Like melt in your mouth deliciousness!!! I can be picky about my sweet treats but this item in particular is a pot of gold!

Allie’s baked goods are so delicious. You can tell she puts her whole heart into preparing treats for her customers. I recently tried the brown sugar and cinnamon pop tart and the strawberry pop tart and it’s SO much better than store bought… like not even comparable. Plus, pick up was super easy.

Omgoodness! These are AMAZING. Absolutely delicious 😋Look forward to order from this talented lady again soon!

Dessert therapy!! You think it’s going to be good, but then it’s better. Allie is the sweetest & works sweet treat magic. Brownies are so rich they should come with a trust fund, cookies could start a cult, & the homemade poptarts are what poptarts want to be when they grow up. Pro-tip: buy extra to “share.” 🤤🤍 5/5 stars. 6 if she throws in an extra cookie.

I’ve had just about every treat and I couldn’t recommend them all enough!

We love Midwest sliced and iced! Everything we have tried is so yummy!

Some of the best sweets I’ve had!! <3

Every thing this gal makes is delicious!

The taste of my husband and I’s childhood. Loved the nostalgia theme she has brought to the markets and now on their site. Tucson will miss you!

I bought the two different types of pop tarts, the brown sugar, chocolate chunk, cookies, a galaxy brownie, and an oatmeal cream pie. I am not kidding when I say these were some of the most delicious baked goods I’ve ever had. The oatmeal cream pie was by far my favorite, and that’s hard to say because I enjoyed everything. Allison was a pleasure to work with and very accommodating. I will definitely be ordering again in the future.

Ordered a dozen cookies for a work training and they went very quickly! Loved the bit of salty with the sweet, so good 😊

Great communication and service! And the treats were sooo good!