Ratings & Reviews

These cookies were beyond beautiful, they are phenomenal. The logo cookies are on point and the fact that each one was hand-designed speaks volumes about the artistry and care behind them. A truly special and memorable detail for the retreat!!

As an event professional, I look forward to seeing my cookies from Matildee’s every time! She is incredible with detail and the cookies actually taste amazing! I cannot recommend her enough! 10/10 and a glowing recommendation to anyone looking for custom cookies!

I cannot say enough good things about this company (Mattie ❤️) and my custom cookie order. Not only were the cookies absolutely delicious, but they were truly the prettiest cookies I’ve ever seen. Every detail was beautiful and exactly what I envisioned. She was so kind, patient, and helpful throughout the entire process helped guide me working with my timeframe and bringing my vision to life perfectly. You can tell how much care and talent goes into her work. I will 100% be ordering again and recommending her to everyone!

This class explained a lot about the challenges in decorating cookies. While there is a learning curve, I was surprised how well mine turned out. Definitely worth the time. Our location was wonderful and our teacher, Mattie, was very easy to understand and follow. Her cookies are wonderful.

Mattie is the best. I just picked up my third order from her and they are even better than the last. She’s done my daughter’s 1st birthday, my sister in laws shower and now Christmas cookies for a wedding and they have all been perfect! She’s great with working with you to get exactly what you’re looking for and the cookies are beautiful but also delicious. I’ve had people ask me at every event where I got the cookies. She decorates them perfectly on theme for every event. Cannot recommend enough. We will continue to order from Mattie for every event that needs cookies!!

Mattie’s cookies are amazing! The taste and design of the cookies were amazing! They were a big hit at the bridal shower I hosted!

These cookies are always a hit! I love ordering them for our special events or as gifts. They are so cute, but they also taste great! I will always recommend Matildee's.

So easy to work with and as always the best & cutest cookies! ❤️

BEAUTIFUL and delicious! Mattie is so easy to work with, quick to respond, and incredible at what she does! All the guests were amazed!

Mattie created a beyond-gorgeous set of cookies for my best friend’s bridal shower. They made the shower so special, and I honestly couldn’t imagine it without them. Thank you so much, Mattie, for always taking your time with my orders and making sure everything is perfect! The cookies were, as always, absolutely delicious!

I can’t say enough about how amazing Mattie is! She is beyond talented and the cookies she puts out are delicious. As long as Mattie is taking custom orders, I will always be a client!

I brought cookies to my friends wedding and everyone loved it 😍

When I offered to do a bridal shower for my best friends daughter I KNEW the first thing that I wanted to do was order custom cookies from Mattie at Matildee’s Cookie Co. LLC. I have known her for over a decade and have watched as she has grown her business. I was beyond impressed when I picked up my order today. They are STUNNING! Not only are they beautiful, but they are significant cookies and taste glorious! If you are thinking of ordering custom cookies look no further!

No matter what artistic inspiration I give her for my event, Mattie delivers with beautiful cookies that are the best I’ve ever tasted.

A phrase that has been said numerous times by me and my family throughout the past few years! They really are the best, cutest cookies! The designs are gorgeous and she always executes my ideas even better than in my head. I've found with a lot of specialty/designed cookies, you sacrifice a good cookie for a fancy design... not here! They're SO GOOD. And they stay fresh forever (which is good since I hoard/ration them for weeks on end haha) Will forever be celebrating with Matildee's!!

I truly can’t recommend a better place for adorable cookies! I have purchased from Mattie multiple times, and every time I’m so impressed! I recently just placed an order for mini cookies to bring to an event. Every cookie was individually wrapped, beautifully displaced in a box, and ready to go! Not only were they stunning, but equally as tasty (we couldn’t stop eating them)! If you’re looking for a cookie spot- this is the way to go!

The cookies turned out perfect as always! The best part was everyone saying how incredible the cookies tasted!

Mattie does a fabulous job executing your vision for your personalized cookies! Not only that but they taste oh-so-delicious. Everyone raved about them at my daughters’ birthday party. Do yourself a favor and order some of her cookies for your next event - You won’t regret it!

Mattie created the most perfect, beautiful dinosaur cookies for my baby boy’s first birthday party. I sent her the invitation for his party to go off those colors and she completely took care of the rest. They are even cuter than I imagined. Almost too pretty to eat but they were delicious, a big hit at the party. She was even willing to meet me for the cookie pick up since I was pretty far. I’ll definitely be getting cookies from her again 💕

I purchased a set of Valentine cookies for my coworkers and they were a hit! I will definitely be ordering again!

Gorgeous designs and top notch taste! A+ customer service!

Do not miss out on these incredible cookies!! Mattie pours her heart into each one and takes the time to capture exactly what you envision. Not only that, but they taste AMAZING. She is flexible and timely and oh so talented. I 1000% recommend her tasty treats for your next event! You will not regret it.

AMAZING set. Made my vision come to life. They were such a hit and everyone raved how equally beautiful and delicious.