Best Sellers
Cookies
πͺ Classic Cookies Freshly baked classic cookies made from scratch, including favorites like chocolate chip, sugar, and more. Cookies are soft, flavorful, and perfect for any occasion. Sold by the dozen only. Minimum order of $25 applies.
Starting at $4.00
click for description
Cupcakes
Freshly baked cupcakes made to order and customized to match your theme. * Basic cupcakes: $33 per dozen * Custom designs: $45+ per dozen Pricing varies based on design, detail, and add-ons. Sold by the dozen. Minimum order applies. βΈ» Edible images, toppers, and detailed designs will increase pricing.
Starting at $33.00
click for description
Layer Cakes
Custom layer cakes made to order and designed to match your theme. Each cake includes multiple layers of cake and filling, finished with buttercream and your choice of basic design. Pricing starts at $65 and varies based on size, design, detail, and customizations. Perfect for birthdays, celebrations, and special occasions. βΈ» Custom designs, characters, toppers, and detailed work will increase pricing. βΈ» Cakes include 2 layers and filling. Additional layers may increase pricing.
Starting at $65.00
click for description
Tier Cakes
Custom tiered cakes designed to make a statement. Perfect for larger events, celebrations, and special occasions. Each tiered cake is made to order and fully customized to match your theme. Pricing starts at $150 and varies based on size, number of tiers, design, and detail. Please submit an order request for an accurate quote. Tiered cakes require additional time, structure, and support, which is reflected in pricing.
Starting at $150.00
click for description
Cinnamon Rolls
Freshly baked cinnamon rolls crafted to order, each one soft, fluffy, and baked in its own pan for the perfect gooey center. Finished with rich icing and indulgent flavor combinations. Designed to impress. Hard to share.
Starting at $5.00
click for description
About
Weβre all mad hereβ¦ especially about dessert π€
π Custom cakes are our specialty
πͺ Cookies β’ cupcakes β’ cake pops β’ cinnamon rolls
β¨ Sweet treats made fresh & made to order
π Neighborhood Favorite 2024 & 2025
π Galloway, NJ
π Pickup & Delivery Available
Order online or catch us at a local pop-up!
Capabilities & Pricing
π CUSTOM CAKES
6" β $65+
8" β $85+
10" β $105+
12" β $125+
Half Sheet β $140+
Full Sheet β $185+
Custom designs, themes, colors, and decorations available. Pricing varies based on size, design, and level of detail.
π§ CUPCAKES
Basic β $2.75 each
Custom β $3.75+ each
πͺ COOKIES
Classic Cookies β $4 each
6 for $22 β Mix & Match
Custom/Decorated Cookies β $2+ each
Minimum order: 1 dozen
π₯ CINNAMON ROLLS
Classic β $5
Specialty β $6
4 for $20
π° CAKE POPS
Starting at $2.75 each
Custom colors, themes, and decorations available.
π LOAF CAKES & BAKED GOODS
Starting at $15
Flavor availability varies.
β¨ CUSTOM REQUESTS β¨
Don't see exactly what you're looking for?
Tell me what you have in mind! Additional options may be available by request. Please include your request in the Additional Comments section when submitting your inquiry, and I'll review your idea and let you know what I can offer.
Custom orders are subject to ingredient, product, and availability requirements. Custom pricing will be provided based on your request.
π Thank you for supporting Mad Batter Bakeshop!
"We're all mad here. Especially about desserts."
Policies
Delivery
Delivery is available for an additional fee based on distance.
As a small business owner balancing a full-time schedule and family, delivery must be arranged and confirmed at the time of placing your order.
A minimum order of $75 is required for delivery.
Please ensure that someone is available to receive the order at the scheduled delivery time. Mad Batter Bakeshop is not responsible for orders left unattended or delayed due to customer unavailability.
Delivery times are scheduled in advance and must be respected. Delays caused by the customer may result in additional fees or cancellation of delivery without refund.
Pick Up
π¦ Pickup Policy
Pickup is strongly recommended.
The pickup address will be provided the morning of your scheduled order. Your pickup time will be confirmed when your order is placed β please arrive on time.
Once your order is picked up, you are fully responsible for the care and condition of your items.
βΈ»
β οΈ Important Transportation Rules
Cakes are fragile and can be easily damaged if not handled properly. Please follow these guidelines:
* Place cakes on the FLOOR of the front passenger seat (never on a seat or lap)
* Keep your vehicle cool β heat can melt icing and damage decorations
* Drive carefully β avoid sudden stops, sharp turns, and fast driving
* Do NOT hold cakes while driving
* For large or tiered cakes, bringing a second person is strongly recommended
βΈ»
π« Liability
Mad Batter Bakeshop is not responsible for any damage once your order has been picked up.
Failure to follow proper transport guidelines may result in damage to your order.
Damaged Goods
β οΈ Damaged Orders Policy
While every order is handled with care, damages can occasionally occur. If your order is damaged at any point, please contact us as soon as possible with photos.
βΈ»
π§ Assessment & Fixes
We will review the situation and determine if the item can be repaired.
* If damage occurs after pickup or during transport, it is considered the customerβs responsibility
* Repairs for customer-related damage may be available for an additional fee (based on severity and availability)
βΈ»
π§ Bakery Responsibility
If damage is determined to be the fault of Mad Batter Bakeshop (examples may include structural issues, items not properly secured, etc.), we will make every reasonable effort to correct the issue. This may include a repair, partial refund, or other resolution at our discretion.
βΈ»
π Important
* All claims must be reported promptly with clear photos
* Availability for fixes is not guaranteed, especially for last-minute issues
* Final resolutions are determined on a case-by-case basis
Non - Refundable Deposit And Cancellations
π° Deposit Policy
A 25% non-refundable deposit is required to secure all orders. This deposit is used to purchase materials and reserve your date.
Orders are not confirmed until the deposit has been received.
Deposits are non-refundable and non-transferable under any circumstances.
In the event of an emergency, please contact us directly. Rescheduling may be offered at our discretion based on availability.
The remaining balance must be paid in full before pickup or delivery.
π Cancellation Policy
All orders are final once booked.
Deposits are non-refundable and non-transferable.
Cancellations made within 48 hours of the scheduled pickup or delivery date are not eligible for rescheduling or credit.
Cancellations made before 48 hours may be eligible for a one-time reschedule, based on availability and at our discretion.
No-shows or failure to pick up orders at the scheduled time will result in forfeiture of the order and all payments made.
Rush Order Fee
Orders placed with less than 5 days notice may be accepted based on availability and will require a rush order fee.
Rush fees typically range from $15β$50+, depending on the size and complexity of the order.
Payments
All orders submitted are considered a request and are subject to approval. Payment is not required until your order has been reviewed and confirmed.
Once approved, a non-refundable deposit is required to secure your order. Orders are not confirmed until a deposit has been received.
The remaining balance is due prior to pickup or at pickup.
### Accepted Payment Methods
Online Orders:
- Credit/Debit Card (via secure checkout)
In-Person Pickup:
- Tap to Pay (Apple Pay, Google Pay, contactless cards)
- Cash
---
π² For future orders and weekly drops, please visit our website or scan the QR code provided.