Ratings & Reviews

Outstanding! Super happy with my sourdough starter, thanks again!!

First time ordering and won’t be the last. Everything we ordered, from the cinnamon rolls to the pepperoni bread was freshly baked and delicious.

English muffins are incredible. Soft and fluffy inside. The butter soaked right in. I will definitely want more of these.

I am a first time customer and ordered the Pepperoni Cheese Sourdough bread along with 2 pizza crusts. Delicious is not a strong enough word to describe the bread! My family devoured half the loaf before I even had a chance to enjoy a piece. I had a special request for the pizza crusts to be on the thinner side and their thickness was perfect for my homemade pizza. They baked up crispy with a nice chewy texture. I have already placed a new order and look forward to trying several other of these yummy sourdough treats!

I don’t think there’s any bagels that you can buy in Erie County that are better than hers. We purchased the cheddar bagels and the cinnamon bagels and both were spot on. Fresh, scrumptious, packed well. We also purchased the cinnamon rolls, but weren’t used to eating sourdough cinnamon rolls so the texture is much different than yeast raised cinnamon roll. Flavor was delicious, my husband and I just prefer yeast rolls.

I 100 percent recommend Alicia and the Bakesy Shop. She's a wonderful bakery, her cinnamon rolls are perfection, and she is amazingly generous.

The complete order was packaged up nice.At the top, wrap was tied with a 🎀 having red hearts. Each item individually in its own container.You could tell it was put together with care. Appreciated the total work done in this order. Highly recommend 👌 Gary R

Awesome flavor I bought lemon/blueberry bread and Bagels. All are exceptional. Thank you

Very good bread!

Your sourdough is so delicious, beautiful and well priced! I’m a big fan! ❤️

Absolutely delicious. Wish you made smaller breads for soup bowls