Ratings & Reviews

The absolute best cookie cake and cookie cups ever! The design was also perfect and exactly what we asked for! So grateful to have found this shop and will keep ordering every time we need a cake! Couldn’t recommend more!

1000/10 recommend!! Amazing customer service, design looked exactly as requested picture, tasted even better, my guests were fighting over who was going to get the last piece. You will not be disappointed ordering!!

I love ordering all the sweet treats from Mary! Her cookies are so yummy and cute and she’s so easy to work with! I’ll be ordering do however long she bakes!

The mini-cakes were delicious and so cute. Perfect to celebrate February birthdays in the office.

Best cookie cake we've ever had! We will definitely be ordering again soon! Thank you!!

I have used Mary with Grisham Hill many times and not once have I been disappointed. She has been able to pull off any request I've had, even last minute ones, and has done it well. And the flavor, so good!

The cookie cake was fantastic! It was perfectly chewy and rich with chocolate flavor. The Halloween-themed design on top was absolutely adorable and very well done, and the icing had a great flavor to match. It was a huge hit at our party and everyone loved it. I will definitely be ordering again!

We love ordering from Grisham Hill!! She is so creative and helpful! Bonus - it is delish too! Perfect for any occasion! (And you can even get fresh eggs in season!)

I always struggle finding bake goods for my daughter who has an egg allergy. We are often very limited and what we can find isn’t always the cute decorated cake baked goods. I came to Mary looking for cake pops that were disco ball and cherry themed but egg free and she delivered beyond what I could imagine. It was the highlight of my daughter’s day and they were so delicious!! My forever go-to for all our baked goodies!

From the cookies, cookie cakes to the Cinnamon Rolls. Everything I have had is wonderful. Plus I love supporting someone local and wonderful.

Mary always goes above and beyond to put the utmost care and love into baking these amazing treats for others. Whether it’s a hostess gift, a teacher appreciation, a fun celebration or just for your own enjoyment, her baked goods are always so fresh and rich in flavor. We will continue to return to Mary at Grisham Hill for any of our sweet treat needs.

Grisham Hill Homestead is my one stop shop for birthday celebrations to hostess gifts. Mary does an exception job creating custom cookie cakes and goodies for any theme. She recently designed a PGA Masters golf cake for my husband’s birthday. Her confections are divine in taste and presentation!

Mary has made me multiple cookie cakes and individual cookies for parties and they have been absolutely amazing!! She is great at communicating ideas and always has items ready to go at the perfect time❤️

We purchased a cookie cake for our daughter’s birthday, it was SO DELICIOUS!!! her friends still talk about how much they loved the cake!

I love getting my special treats from Mary@ Grisham Hill! Everything I have purchased has been fresh, delicious and packaged beautifully! If you haven’t ordered from her, you’re missing out! High recommend!♥️

Everything is excellent quality and tastes just as amazing as it looks!!

Mary makes the best chocolate chip cookie cake I’ve ever eaten! 10/10 recommend!!

I have gotten a couple cookie cakes and every time they are a hit! Decorated so cute and the taste is always amazing!! Can never go wrong with a cookie cake from Mary!