Ratings & Reviews

nailed it again & made my vision come to life!! i could not have been happier with the end result & the amount of compliments given on how insanely good it was speaks to the quality provided to customers. 100/10

What a treat not only was this cookie delicious and soft… the work put into the design was perfect!! Will definitely be back!

You hit it out of the park again!

Dakota is amazing! I had a last minute request for a cookie cake and she came through! The cookie cake was amazing and the design was everything I'd hoped for! Highly recommend and will definitely be ordering again!

Dakota was great to work with: quick with correspondence & great attitude! The cake its self was absolutely amazing. 10 out of 10 highly recommend!

Amazing communication through the entire process, great pricing, and a stellar product! I’m already planning my next purchase!

Absolutely beautiful and delicious! Her cookie cake was a huge hit. Can't wait for our next event to order another one!

Both of my cakes turned out more amazing than I could have imagined! They look and taste fantastic ❤️❤️

So talented & always delicious!!

I ordered a cookie cake for my daughter t-ball trophy party she did amazing job the details were perfect better than I could have imaged. go order a cake from Dakota !!!!!

This cookie cake is phenomenal! Dakota put so much time into this to ensure it was perfect. She was also very understanding when things kept happening out of my control that led to me having to reschedule when I needed the cake ready by. She was such a pleasure to do business with! I will definitely be back for more! Thanks again!!

Beautiful decoration and always taste amazing!! Never disappoint and can't go wrong with any flavor not to mention she's so sweet

I would recommend 100%. The design was exactly what I wanted and the kids loved the cookies! Dakota is awesome and very kind as well to work with!

I just received my order for my daughter's teachers. They're just the cutest mini cookie cake! Perfect for teacher appreciation! Even decorated in the cutest boxes tied in a bow with a cute tag!

I have purchased cookies from Dakota for 3 different occasions and they have all been incredible. Her artistic ability to decorate is unmatched and the cookies taste SO GOOD!

The cookie was perfect picture matched my mom's dog perfect easy to order and was quick to make and respond 10/10 recommend

It was great! Everyone enjoyed it. Will definitely be placing more orders.

2nd time using Gimme Sugar Cookie Co. and once again impressed!! Amazing taste, customer service and talent put behind every order!!! 10/10.

There is not a way to express how amazing these cookie cakes look and taste. I sent Dakota a picture that my daughter drew explaining what we wanted. Not only did she do the picture justice. She nailed it. Thank you always for delivering the best cookie cakes!!

My cookie cake turned out exactly as I imagined it would! Perfectly made & delicious!

The cakes decoration were beautiful and tasted delicious. Dakota was very professional. I will be ordering from her again.

As always, taste was amazing and the design was impeccable! Always my goto for cookie cakes!!

10/10 recommend Gimme Sugar Cookie Co. for any and all celebratory needs! These are the absolute cutest and most delicious cookie cakes I’ve ever had. Easy communication and astounding customer service. Affordable and feeds well. I can’t rave this local business enough!!!

Amazing cake. Awesome experience. ❤️

Dakota's work and service was nothing less than exceptional! She was professional, prompt, and the quality of her work was superb! We will be reaching out to her to order cakes for other events in the future!

My daughter LOVED her cookie cake! It was the best we have ever had…highly recommend ordering soon! 🥰

I sent her an info picture and she did the exact same but even better!!! She is so talented

This is my second chocolate chip cookie order with GMSC. The product is well worth the money and she is an absolute sweetheart. She doesn’t shy away from my ideas and is always up for the challenge. Picking up my first brownie cookie order Sunday and can’t wait.

The cookie cake we got was beautiful! I asked for something simple for a birthday, and it’s perfect and SO GOOD!

The presentation was beautiful! The M&M flavors with the icing was so good, and each one looked like a rose. Will definitely be ordering more!

We were in LOVE with the result. It looked so good and it tasted just as good as it looked. We ordered an Atlanta Braves cookie cake and it exceeded our expectations. She was so easy to work with and great at communication. I’ll definitely use her for any needs in the future.

She made our vision come to life! The details and coloring were perfect. Our cake was so unique that our birthday girl didn’t even want to cut it!

Thank you for the amazing birthday cookie! We have ordered several now and they have all exceeded our expectations! Beautiful and delicious!

I cannot recommend these enough! The designs are flawless no matter what you choose, and they taste like the best homemade baked cookie! Perfect for any and every event and so easy to order!

I ordered a cookie cake 2 weeks before my birthday.. my only request was it had my furbabies on it… this place absolutely nailed the markings on my furbabies from the pictures i sent. It turned out so much better than i thought and was worth the price.. it taste amazing!!

It was perfect and so delicious! Thank you

genuinely the best cookie cake i’ve ever had! was a total hit for the bridal shower, the bride is a cookie cake fanatic & i’ve watched her drive over 2 hours for good cookie cake. after today, she will officially have a local cookie cake supplier on her hands lol. she hasn’t stopped talking about it. 10/10 i could not recommend Gimme Sugar Cookie Co more!

The decoration was so beautifully detailed and the cookie itself was delicious!! Exactly what I wanted and visioned!

I cannot give a better rating! The cake was adorable & tasted amazing. We will definitely be back❤️

Perfection! That’s one way to describe our cake. From the design to the taste Gimme Sugar never disappoints!

I wanted a realistic looking sea turtle with hibiscus flowers and Dakota did a fantastic job! The colors and details were perfect and the cookie cake itself was delicious! Thanks!

I reached out very last minute about a cookie cake. Dakota did not disappoint. She was so easy to communicate with and created a fantastic cake. My little boy is so excited about it. We cannot wait to taste it at the party tomorrow. Definitely recommend purchasing from her!

Presentation was everything and more. Truly can not grasp how much I love the look of this cake. But even better it tasted amazing!!!! I got the coffee flavor with white chocolate chips and omg so good.

We ordered a brownie cookie cake for our son’s birthday and it tasted so good! It was sweet but hit the spot perfectly. Can’t wait to order again in the future.

10/10 - just the right amount of coffee flavor! Absolutely loved this cake! Frosting is sweet but not overly sweet!

The gingerbread toffee and white chocolate is my favorite. I also had the sample and everything was great! Thank you .

Dakota knocked it out the park again with an awesome cookie cake for my brothers surprise party! It tasted even better than it looks.

I placed a very last minute order for a cookie cake and not only did Dakota come through on short notice, but the cake was delicious. So good and decorated with such detail. We will be using Gimme Sugar Cookie Co more often.

Absolutely love all the detail in Dakotas cookie cakes! Not only does it look good but it tastes good as well

The coffee cookie cake with coffee icing is delicious! If you are a coffee lover, you need to try this one!

Dakota did an amazing job designing a cookie cake for a Bachelorette!

Dakota has an amazing talent. Not only did she make the cookie cake that I sent her a picture of. She made the cookie cake better than the picture!! Not only does the appearance look amazing. The cookie is delicious!! I would highly recommend 10/10. 🤩 Thank you so much!! I cannot wait to make my next order!!

I have purchased several cookies from Dakota since she began her business. I have absolutley loved each one! My recently purchased an apple pie cookie to taste. Oh my word it is simply amazing! It is my new favorite!!! The cookie itself is soft with bits of apple mixed in. It has the perfect amount of spices that give an apple pie taste without the actual apple pie. The icing is literally the icing on top! It adds just enough sweetness to the already perfect cookie. This is a 10/10 cookie in my book.

The designs are better than I can imagine and the taste is SO GOOD! Truly blessed to find company that cares for their customers needs and wants ❤️ can’t wait for my next order!

Highly recommended!! The best cookie cake I have ever had! The cookie and the icing taste amazing! I bought one for my son’s birthday and everyone was going back for seconds! Needless to say there was none left. The design looked like a picture. Truly talented!

This is my 3rd order and as usual, it’s amazing!!

The detail was awesome! And the cake tasted amazing!

The mini sugar cookie cakes were absolutely delicious and a huge hit at my son’s FFA Christmas party! The kids loved the Grinch-themed cookies, and they turned out even cuter than expected. Dakota is incredibly easy to work with and responds quickly to any order questions. We’ve ordered from Dakota multiple times, and every experience has been consistently wonderful. Highly recommend!

She did an amazing job! It was beautiful and was all the designs were drawn beautifully! I loved it all around!

I ordered the cookie bites in macadamia nut and red velvet white choc. They're absolutely delicious. She really does a great job on presentation, and decorations. These cookies have exceeded my expectations. I will be ordering again.

Dakota'swork is truly amazing! Her artisitc style is unmatched. The cookies themselves are above average. We have not had one yet that we have not absolutley loved!!!

The cookie cake was absolutely amazing! We did the chocolate chip cookie cake filled with the buttercream and an apple pie cookie cake. They were Perfectly soft, rich, and so delicious. Everyone loved it, definitely ordering again

Awesome

My son loved his cake! The flavor was awesome and cookie had a super soft center with crunchy edges! It has something for everyone! The design was a reach with two themes together and she KILLED it! Thanks so much for making this the best birthday!

Dakota did an amazing job! She took my vague idea and made the perfect cookie

Absolutely adorable!!!! Was the talk of the night and taste amazing too! Thank you!!

Not only was the cookie super cute it taste great too!

I ordered the cookie bites in Reese’s and Red Velvet, and they were absolutely delicious! I didn’t have any special decoration requests, just something simple, but they were still so cute! Dakota provides amazing customer service as well! Would definitely recommend for sure and will be ordering more in the future!

Is exactly the way I imagined it should be! Beautifully executed! I cannot wait to cut into this and try it!

These were so delicious. The decorations were better than I hoped for. You will not be disappointed!!!!

Beautiful job. Thank you.

100/10 !!!! This was such a cute cookie cake and delicious at that! I had to snag a bite before taking it home. Would def recommend and plan to for birthdays and events! I gave what I wanted and let her go free with the design and she went beyond my expectations!!!! I love it and thank you so much again!!!!

Not only was the cake unbelievably cute and delicious.. The customer service was amazing. Will definitely order again! 🙌🏼

Awesome doesn’t begin to describe how great our cake was. From the design to how it tasted. Our cake was great!! Thank you for making my husband’s birthday special!

Great detail and everyone was jumping over each other to get a piece I already have 2 more orders picked

Dakota done amazing. I literally sent her a picture of the invitation for my friends gender reveal and she made us a beautiful cake to match it perfectly! The chocolate chip cookie cake itself tastes awesome! 10/10 recommend!

it was wonderful we were very pleased

I ordered a Simpsons themed cookie cake for my husband’s birthday and it was absolutely perfect! The design was better than I imagined and the cookie itself was delicious!

We tried the apple pie cake today, and oh my word—it’s incredible! The perfect blend of apple, cinnamon, and sweetness. It tastes homemade and cozy, like a slice of fall comfort. Dakota, you outdid yourself!!!

I am blown away by how amazing my cakes turned out. I can’t wait to surprise my boyfriend. I couldn’t have imagined them turning out this good. I will definitely be using this company for future birthdays. I haven’t even tried them yet!

We absolutely loved our cookie cake! Ordering was super easy and the options for customization are fantastic. I will definitely be ordering again

The chocolate chip cookie cake was not only absolutely beautiful! It was also so delicious! Highly recommend!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I can’t say enough good things about the pumpkin cookie cake! It was perfectly baked — soft in the middle, just the right amount of sweetness, and absolutely delicious. It disappeared in minutes! Hands down the best cookie cake I’ve ever had. I’ve ordered several, and they never disappoint. The décor is always outstanding!

So far we’ve tried the smores, Reese’s, chocolate chip, and brownie. They are all good! But, smores and the classic, chocolate chip are my personal favorite. Cookies are tender & perfect and the buttercream is not too sweet.

Dakota made a custom cookie cake for Sheriff Kevin Chaney, complete with our Camden County Sheriff’s Office patch — and it looked incredible! The detail was spot on, and it tasted just as amazing as it looked. Dakota is so talented and puts so much care into her work. Highly recommend for any special occasion!

My wife is a big cookie fan and I wanted to try something other than a cake for her birthday. The order was easy to place and after sending in some reference for the design I wanted, plenty of questions were asked to make sure the order was correct. I gave lots of room for an original design and it turned out perfect; colorful, fun, but still tasteful for an adult. I appreciate that most of the flavor and sweetness came from the cookie and not a mountain of frosting, and what a flavor it was. I opted for cookies and creme and it was a huge hit!

These cookie dippers were amazing! Just the perfect sweet treat for when you don’t need a whole cake!

I have gotten a couple of things from Dakota. Everything always looks great and tastes even better!

Cake was delicious and adorable! Very happy with it.

We had the Recees cookie and it was delicious! Took the stress out of ordering a birthday cake Thanks again Dakota

The cookie cake is everything I asked for and more. Dakota is professional, reliable, and truly talented. I look forward to ordering more cookies.

We got a 12 inch chocolate chip cookie cake and it was cooked perfect. The icing looked just like the picture I requested. I highly recommend trying her cakes.

Cutest packaging ever. Cookie was super fresh and my daughter was soooo excited. Everything tasted delicious! Will definitely be ordering again! 🖤🖤🖤

From birthday cakes to bulldog’s cakes, she’s the best around!

This cookie cake was amazing! Soft, chewy, and delicious with perfect frosting. The Georgia Bulldogs red and black colors made it look incredible and extra festive. A big hit for Paul's birthday! 🐾❤️🖤

Absolutely perfect! I sent Dakota a message telling her what I wanted for my bosses 96th birthday and she nailed it! Cookie cake is delicious and the graphics were amazing!!

It was easy to order, was accommodating to a short notice order. Presentation was spot on & pricing was so fair! Will definitely be ordering again in the future.

Dakota went above and beyond! The cake looks exactly like the photo I sent her for the design we wanted and it tastes amazing! we will definitely be back for more in the future!

Ordered a double cookie cake very last minute & she went above and beyond to get it done! It was gorgeous and tasted delicious!

Amazing job all the way around, we had to cakes make for our sons birthdays and the graphics and taste did not disappoint. We will be ordering again because the taste,look and customer service was amazing

Delicious cookie cake. I give her the theme and gave her free reign over the project. As always...she nails it.... EVERY SINGLE TIME. Top quality artisan.

This was the cutest cookie cake I've ever seen. My kids love it so much. It tastes absolutely phenomenal! We will definitely order more!

Delicious & pretty! Cookie cakes are our favorite & Dakota never disappoints 🤩

Loved everything about it!

Dakota did an amazing job on Ava’s basketball cake for her 14th it’s everything we wanted! Thank you!! 😊

From the design to the flavor, it’s our favorite ! Will definitely continue ordering 🙌🏼

Amazing every time! Thank you!

Dakota did an amazing job on the bow cookie cake. She far exceeded our expectations. The cake was delicious and pretty.

Dakota did a fantastic job on making the perfect welcome home cookie cake for my perfect girl. Not only did it looked good, but it tasted so delicious as well! I can’t wait to order another cookie cake from her. ❤️

Requested a 10” round cookie cake (red velvet white chocolate chip) and it was amazing and the design on the top was amazing as well! Loved every bit of it! Very detailed and perfection!

I ordered a cookie cake and just told Dakota the theme. Her design was amazing and so beautiful. The cookie cake tasted just as good as it looked. I would definitely recommend and will be ordering more.

This cookie cake looked and tasted amazing 🤩 the cutest cookie I’ve ever seen! Gimmie sugar cookie co you have outdone yourself☺️

Cake turned out very cute for my 2 year old granddaughter.

You knocked it out of the park with the design & flavor! Will definitely be getting more!

We love our cookie cake - perfectly decorated to the unique tropical theme and melt in your mouth delicious! Can’t wait for my next one!

Dakota’s work is phenomenal! Plus, the taste is DELICIOUS!!

Sooo yummy, and cute Mikayla loved it!!

I will never buy from a store again! These cookies are worth every penny! Not only are the designs great, but the cookie is delicious. The owner is such a sweetheart and this is what makes the experience worth it ❤️

For something better than a cake, this is your best all around! Delicious and beautiful!

I would give 10stars if I could. Service, quality, taste, price all out of this world. Even my youngest granddaughter, who only ever eats the icing on cakes, tore through this cookie! When I placed my order all I told her was my husband was a huge Alabama football fan and she absolutely nailed it!!! I seriously can not recommend her enough!

Came out exactly how we wanted and it tasted amazing couldnt have asked for a better cake

Dakota exceeded my expectations for my son’s cookie cake!! The design was amazing and the cookie and buttercream combo tasted so good! The cookie was soft, thick, and absolutely perfect! We look forward to our next event, we will definitely use her again!

In love! Not only is cookie wonderful, but so is the owner ❤️ can’t wait to order our next cookie!

My coworkers loved the cake it tasted so good!! The Hobby Lobby truck looked so cool!!

I have zero notes – the betty boop cookie from Gimmie Sugar Cookies Co absolutely perfect. From the moment I opened the box, I could tell it was made with care and creativity. The designs? Flawless. The flavor? Even better. Soft, buttery, with just the right amount of sweetness – they practically melt in your mouth. Not only beautiful, but you could taste the quality in every bite. Honestly, they were almost too pretty to eat… almost. Whether you're ordering for a special occasion or just to treat yourself, this is your sign to go for it. She truly did amazing – can't recommend her enough!

The cookie cake was delicious. You did a great job with the designed and everything.

I highly recommend Gimmie Sugar Cookie Co. Yo everyone. If cookie cakes are what you love then this is the place to go. She does not disappoint, the cake for my son's birthday not only looked amazing and flawless but the taste is out of this world. The cookie cake itself was soft and taste great the icing was perfect not too sweet just right. Y'all need to run on over to her page and get those orders in ASAP. I will be back for more have another bday coming up in October.

The cake was beyond expectations. The detail the color the image. All top tier.

Asked for a short notice cookie cake decorated with my wife favorite plants for her birthday, Dakota with Gimmie Sugar did NOT disappoint! Not only was she able to get it done by when I needed it, but she nailed it and my wife loved it! Highly recommended them and I will be a return customer!

Amazing!! She did such a great job on this! I told her what I wanted and left the rest up to her and it turned out amazing. And it was so delicious!

Ordered a birthday cake for my husband, and Dakota hit it out of the park! My husband said we can’t even cut it, it looks so good!

I loved it!! such good detail. Taste Amazing. All the party people loved it!! will buy again!!

Our cake was not only the cutest but tasted absolutely delicious! 10/10 recommend! Will for sure order again!

This big cookie was not only good but sooooo cute. Thank you Dakota. It was perfect.

I have had multiple cookie cakes but these are hands down the best!!! They are absolutely delicious and she can do any design on them!!! I definitely recommend and you won’t be disappointed.

These are the best cookie cakes I have very had. My cake was beautiful and delicious. I ordered a last minute cake and she made sure to fulfill my order.

It was adorable and delicious! Perfect size

So far we have had the chocolate chip and s’mores cookie cake and they not only taste amazing but Dakota absolutely kills it with the details she puts into these cakes! She is so talented at what she does!!

The design surpassed my expectations.

I ordered the s’mores cookie cake for my step daughters birthday and not only was it beautiful, it was absolutely delicious. Everyone raves about how good it was! I will definitely be ordering more in the future

Dakota did an amazing job from Start to finish! Quick communication, so creative, and the cake tasted soooo good!

The cookie cake was decorated beautifully and exactly what I wanted. The smores cookie was also perfect!

Ordered a Cookie Cake for our 10 year old boys birthday. Requested something with a police car. What we got was more like art that we wanted to hang on the wall. The details in the Georgia State Patrol car, to include the "shadow" underneath, were exquisite. For as awesome as it looked, the taste and flavors were superb as well. We will be ordering more in the future. Thank you so much!!

I was absolutely blown away by how AMAZING my daughter’s axolotl birthday cake turned out. I sent a picture of her invitations and Dakota was able to make an exact replication of the Boba Axolotl on the cake and it was so adorable! We ordered the s’mores cookie cake with marshmallow buttercream and it did not disappoint. It was honestly the best s’mores creation that I’ve ever had. Everyone at the party loved it as well! I will certainly be a returning customer and recommend Gimme Sugar Cookie Co. 10/10 🍪

The best cookie cake I’ve ever had and the design was even better than the picture I sent her to go off of!

The best tasting and most artistic cookie cake around!! We enjoyed it!