Ratings & Reviews

I just want to highly recommend Frosted Custom Cookies! I had cookies made for my daughter’s college graduation, and the cookies were not only delicious, they were beautiful! I had great communication with Deena, and I found her rates to be excellent! Thank you, Deena for making my daughter’s celebration so special!

I am so pleased with my cookies! They taste and look amazing. I am very impressed with this small baker. Communication was great as well as packaging! Thank you!

These cookies were a hit at my sheriffs office! Not only did everyone think they were cute but they couldn’t get over how good they were. I will definitely be placing another order for the holidays coming up.

The Baby Shower cookies were absolutely perfect! Not only were they gorgeous, but they were delicious!! I will 100% be ordering again for any event that I have coming up!! They are the best!

Beautiful and delicious.

Received my night before cookies from frosted custom cookies and I absolutely LOVE THEM! I sent her a "inspo photo" and what she delivered was exactly what I sent her. OBSESSED to say the least! Baby Shower cookies are next. <3

Perfect! Soft cookies, tasty frosting and amazing design. Great price.

I recently ordered 2 dozen cookies for a formal bridal shower. The cookies looked like a watercolor painting and matched the theme perfectly. Would definitely order again.

These cookies were not only nostalgic but yummy. I will be ordering again for all holidays! Still dreaming about them.