Ratings & Reviews

Karen did a great job on the Minecraft cookies for my son’s 7th birthday! They were so cute and tasted amazing!

The cookies were so well done and delicious and Karen was super easy to work with. So creative too. She is now our go to!

I would recommend them to anyone. Her gulten free tastes just like a gulten cookie. I love all her cookies.

Frosted by Gia created the perfect cookie kits for my students!! Not only were the cookies themselves fantastic - so tasty! - the theme was perfect for the occasion, and the kits had clear directions and helpful hints, as well as all the supplies we needed. The kids are asking when they can do it again!!

Beautiful cookies and they taste amazing. Would definitely recommend. I will be ordering again!

We hosted Night to Shine at our church and needed a large cookie order. The cookies were so beautiful and delicious! The gluten free cookies tasted amazing, too. We loved that they were individually packed and included the ingredient list. Would definitely order again!!

Do yourself a favor and place an order with Frosted by Gia! These cookies are always so fresh and the flavor is outstanding. By far, the best sugar cookies I’ve ever tasted, thanks to her special (secret) recipe. I’ve placed several custom orders and Karen’s designs are so creative and unique. You can tell that she has a passion for baking and making sure the customer is happy with the order. Whether you're planning a large event, a small gathering or simply just want a delectable treat all to yourself, you can't go wrong here. These cookies are next level!

Karen decorated the most amazing cookies for my baby shower. The butterfly cookies turned out exactly how I hoped they would. I provided her with all copy of my invitation, and she was sure to match them perfectly. Normally people get sugar cookies for decoration purposes, however, Karen’s tasted delightful. I will recommend Karen 10/10 times.

Delicious cookies and my daughter and her friend had so much fun decorating! Cannot recommend enough!

Gia’s cookies are fantastic! So beautiful and custom-made to your preference. She will work with you to design a cookie for any occasion. She is so kind, so lovely and most accommodating! I’ve ordered many times and have always loved my cookies. Plus, they are yummy and fairly priced! The best ever! ❤️

These cookies made our party so special! We love getting cookies from Gia. She’s our go to cookie girl for sure!

Delicious designer cookies, perfect frosting/cookie ratio. Made, and delivered as a gift. Came in cute gift bags for each of the recipients. Cost appropriate for the quality and detail of these cookies. Highly recommend.

We ordered the mini-cookies for our son’s second birthday and they turned out great- they completely matched our theme and were a huge hit! Not to mention, Gia was able to take our order last minute and her responses were always timely!

So proud to get these cookies and give to my son and DIL for their new born twins! They so impressed not just with how cute they were about how good they tasted. They passed them out to family and friends and also the nurses for a thank you! Everyone loved them!! Highly Recommend !!

The cookies were beautiful and very tasty. Everyone loved them.

I ordered cookies from Karen her work is impeccable. The cookies had such a buttery flavor and we decorated to perfection. We were so pleased and they came in just right with the colors or vibrant. Everything looked wonderful. She did four different cookie cutters is it just fit the theme perfectly never been happier with an order that I’ve placed. Thank you, Karen. You have many more orders coming your way.

Perfect match to the wedding theme! Cookies added the perfect touch to each guest place setting and everyone loved the delicious cookie ………almost too beautiful to eat!

I ordered sugar cookies for a safari-themed baby shower and they turned out absolutely beautiful! Every little detail was perfectly done, and the cookies were not only gorgeous but also delicious. These were a such a hit with everyone at the party. These even came with an ingredients list which is a huge plus since a lot of people have food allergies. Karen, was so sweet and kind throughout the whole process. You can tell she really cares about her work and her customers. I’m so glad I found her, I’ll definitely be ordering again!

Beautiful and delicious - so pretty we used them in the place setting!

Frosted by Gia does the most beautiful, creative, fun and innovative cookies. Also, they are very delicious! I ordered angels and the artwork was exquisite. Prompt and professional. No need to look at anyone else.

Karen’s cookies and cake pops were a hit at my daughter’s grad party! We went with a floral theme and they were beautiful! I’m planning a client’s event next month and feel fully confident and excited to have Karen’s treats as a highlight!

I've never seen such beautiful and creative cookies before. They were absolutely delicious and everyone loved them. They were a huge hit! I will definitely be ordering more!!

The cookies were exactly what I wanted! Gia was so easy to work with. They were individually wrapped with the cutest tag attached. And most of the cookies I’ve ordered before look great but don’t taste great, but everyone commented how soft and delicious these cookies were!! I will definitely order again!

Delicious cookies and she fit me in for a last minute order. Thanks!

The cookies were not only cute but delicious! She made minis for my daughter's 40th and they were a definite hit! Karen always does a great job!

Frosted By Gia is so great to work with! I love the flexible cookie designs that can be coordinated with school colors or grad names. The best part? The cookies taste amazing!

Stunning design Hit of the gala. Highly recommend for any event !!!

Gia’s gluten free cookies are so good. We had to double check the label and call her to make sure they were truly GF. She took the time to listen to my party theme and then created the most beautiful set of cookies to match. Can’t recommend her enough!

Karen did AMAZING with my cousins baby shower cookies! They were so good and everyone kept talking about how cute they were. I wish I could add a photo because I'm still obsessed with them. Can't thank you enough for adding the perfect touch to my cousins baby shower!!

From communication to creativity to execution, every aspect was a pleasure. Definitely recommend!

She created the sweetest baby shower cookies for us! Just gave her our theme and she creates such beautiful designs. I was afraid to order because I have never had a sugar cookie I actually liked before but hers are AMAZING! Best tasting sugar cookie you will ever eat. I say order more than you think you will need because people will grab all the extra!

These cookies were such a hit at our party. I gave Karen an inspo photo & she designed the cutest cookies. One of the guests asked if they were made in a factory! Other guests were shoving them in their pockets on their way out the door. I can’t wait to use Karen again for my next party!

I ordered a few packages of cookies and was pleasantly surprised at how she personally gift wraps each order. The cookies were great quality and the packaging made it a wonderful experience for friends and family. I would recommend this to anyone who is looking for a unique experience that can be shared with friends and family.

I can’t say enough good things about Frosted by Gia cookies! They are absolutely amazing, so soft and flavorful. Each order is customized adding special touches to the designs. The presentation is also unique, perfect for gifts or treating yourself. I’ve bought these cookies for family, friends and work events and highly recommend this local business. Customer service is top-notch too — friendly, responsive, and genuinely passionate about creating a unique gift to be remembered. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

A great cookie isn’t just a treat it’s an experience. Frosted By Gia cookies are so delicious you’ll be tempted to keep them all to yourself. Forget about counting calories and indulge!

Frosted By Gia did a phenomenal job on my son’s birthday cookies. They were taekwondo themed and even made gluten free for our guests. Love the creativity and consistency every time we order from this great company! Check them out if you haven’t already done so!!!

Karen’s cookies were amazing! She went above and beyond to create a custom allergy sensitive Cookie for me. The time and energy she puts into decorating is obvious with the appearance of the cookies. My family and friends were blown away by the cookies for my party. Definitely look forward to ordering from her again!

Not only were these cookies beautiful with such attention to detail, they were delicious. I ordered wedding dress cookies for a shower. Beautifully packaged Guests loved them!!!

My kiddos were so excited to gift their teachers the cutest baskets of strawberry cookies for teacher appreciation week! As always, just the most beautiful delicious cookies 🤩

Amazing as always!!! Flexible with pick up. Super easy to order and pay! Will continue being a repeat customer of Karen’s!!!!!

Delicious cookies and beautifully decorated! Always a go to for holidays, parties, and gifts! We have purchased Frosted by Gia cookies many times and will continue to do so! Karen is so easy to work with and quick to respond. Highly recommend!!!

I had these made for a wonderful teacher my son has. They were a absolute hit. I had her cookies prior to these and I love them. They are always great. I am a repeat costumer and will stay a repeat costumer. I have and will recommended to everyone.

Frosted Gia’s cookies are best! My family loves them and they make the best gifts. This year’s teacher application cookies were beautiful and packaged so nicely. She has a gluten free cookie option which is so helpful since I have a gluten free child and his teacher happens to be gluten free too. Highly recommend!

The cookies were delicious and the decorating was top notch! Really made our nursing team happy!

I have worked with Karen twice and have been impressed each time. Karen pays special attention to all the details in the cookies and they come out beautiful! The cookies taste delicious and Karen has been so accommodating with making regular cookies for us as well a gluten free and even gluten and dairy free. Each cookie taste amazing! We look forward to working with her in the future and recommend her!

Karen’s cookies from Frosted by Gia are nothing short of amazing! She has faithfully provided beautiful, delicious cookie donations to our Royal Family KIDS Club mentors and staff year after year, for both Christmas and end-of-year gifts. Her creations are not only a treat to eat, but also a joy to receive — each one is crafted with care, creativity, and love. Our team always looks forward to her sweet surprises. Thank you, Karen, for your generosity and for making our celebrations extra special!

Frosted by Gia provides a top quality cookie that tastes phenomenal and looks amazing. I ordered some cookies for my book club and Karen took the time to create a custom cookie that perfectly fit our theme. They were a huge hit with all the ladies and left them all wanting more. Karen consistently goes above and beyond on every order and her cookies are worth every penny. I highly recommend Frosted by Gia cookies for any special occasion!

Karen is amazing to work with. We’ve been getting our cookies from her for years and have never been disappointed. It’s hard to pick which design has been my favorite but I think I’d have to go with the Thanksgiving pie slices (brownie).

So thankful to find a local person to create this artistic and delicious cookie. I have already passed along their information to another friend. Thanks for making my event all the more beautiful!

Our cookies were exactly what we were looking for, they were adorable, and tasted delicious! Communication and pick up were great too!

Cookies for our Open House were a big hit! Beautifully decorated and delicious!

Karen made the cutest sugar cookies for my “Baby it’s cold outside” themed baby shower! I was so impressed with how they turned out and how delicious they were. Karen is the sweetest, very responsive and so easy to work with on planning the designs🩵

Purchased Gia’s cookies for both gifts and personal party consumption. Holiday designs were amazing per usual. The gluten free cookies tasted just like regular batter and were a huge hit with my family. Can’t wait for our next festive order. Thank you for being a brand we can truly trust!

Flavor is wonderful. Ordered at last minute and ready on time !!! Design worked perfectly ! Thank you !!!!!

We ordered regular and gluten free. They were absolutely delicious! Highly recommend and will order again!