Featured Products
2 Dzn Premium Cookie Bites
Cookie bites with unique designs, custom toppers, custom chocolates, etc. Available in additional 1 dozens beyond 2 dozen minimum.
$45.00
click for description
2 Dzn Original Cookie Bites
Up to 2 colors (plus white) and sprinkles. Rosettes, swirls, and puffs. —- Custom toppers, molded Chocolate, unique designs, and lettering available in Premium bites.
$36.00
click for description
15in Round
9in round cookie cake in either chocolate chip, peanut butter, sugar, or double chocolate.
Starting at $60.00
click for description
9in Round
9in round cookie cake in either chocolate chip, peanut butter, sugar, or double chocolate.
Starting at $30.00
click for description
1/4 Sheet *Precut* Cookie Cake
Quarter sheet (approximately 9x13) serves 12 large slices or up to 24 smaller pieces. Available standard or precut.
Starting at $40.00
click for description
🐾 Butler University 💙🤍
Delivery to Butler
For any order outside of the Cookie Drop subscription or “limited time specials” (such as back to school) there is a $10 delivery fee to campus. In the order notes, please include your student’s name, cell phone number, and campus address.
$10.00
click for description
6-Pack Dawg Paw 4in Mini Cookie Cakes
6 x 4-in cookie cakes with buttercream frosting and custom chocolate Dawg Paws. Specify chocolate chip, vanilla sugar cookie, double chocolate brownie, or peanut butter. No combinatios- one flavor only.
$30.00
click for description
🍪 Cookie Cakes
2 Dzn Premium Cookie Bites
Cookie bites with unique designs, custom toppers, custom chocolates, etc. Available in additional 1 dozens beyond 2 dozen minimum.
$45.00
click for description
2 Dzn Original Cookie Bites
Up to 2 colors (plus white) and sprinkles. Rosettes, swirls, and puffs. —- Custom toppers, molded Chocolate, unique designs, and lettering available in Premium bites.
$36.00
click for description
15in Round
9in round cookie cake in either chocolate chip, peanut butter, sugar, or double chocolate.
Starting at $60.00
click for description
9in Round
9in round cookie cake in either chocolate chip, peanut butter, sugar, or double chocolate.
Starting at $30.00
click for description
4in Mini Cookie Cake Single
4in round cookie cake in either chocolate chip, peanut butter, sugar, or double chocolate.
$6.00
click for description
1/4 Sheet *Precut* Cookie Cake
Quarter sheet (approximately 9x13) serves 12 large slices or up to 24 smaller pieces. Available standard or precut.
Starting at $40.00
click for description
About
Hi! I’m Stephanie Sullivan
👨🏻🤝👨🏼👩🏻🤝👩🏼Mom • 💖 Wife •
🌍 Traveler 🍪 Baker and
🔥 Indy girl with Flour Power
I’ve had my hands covered in flour for decades and I’m currently obsessed with all things cookie cake.
I look forward to making your special occasion memorable…and delicious!
Capabilities & Pricing
Delicious, fresh hand-crafted cookie cakes for every occasion.
Chocolate chip, sugar, peanut butter and chocolate cookies ranging from cookie bites to half sheets.
Lots of other options available. Let’s talk!
Policies
Order Details
All prices shown reflect a basic 2-color design
Specialized decor, additional colors, multi-layer, and cutout cakes (numbers, letters) are all possible. Let’s discuss!
All orders available for pickup near 146th and Springmill
Delivery in the Indy metro area available and priced by mileage