New! Cookie Monster Cookie

Milk chocolate. White chocolate. Cookie chunks on cookie chunks.

Our Cookie Monster Cookie is thick, gooey, and packed with crushed chocolate sandwich cookies and sweet cookie crumbles for the ultimate treat-on-a-treat experience. A guaranteed favorite for kids, families, and anyone who loves an extra indulgent dessert.

Baked fresh from scratch with Faith & Flour’s signature warmth.

For the true cookie butter lover.

This indulgent cookie is made with crushed Biscoff cookies baked right into the dough for the perfect mix of crisp and soft. Each one is filled with warm, gooey cookie butter, then finished with a hand-drizzled layer on top. Sweet, spiced, and buttery — it’s a European classic with a melt-in-your-mouth twist that fans can’t get enough of.

🍪 Please note: There’s a 3-cookie minimum per order — mix & match any flavors!

Cookies & cream, bakery-style.

Loaded with crushed Oreos and creamy white chocolate chips, this soft and chewy favorite brings everyone’s favorite cookie combo to life — but bigger, thicker, and better. It’s nostalgic, fun, and dangerously good — the kind of cookie that disappears the moment it hits the box.

🍪 Please note: There’s a 3-cookie minimum per order — mix & match any flavors!

The comfort of Grandma’s banana pudding — in cookie form.

Soft, buttery, and melt-in-your-mouth, this southern-inspired favorite is packed with white chocolate chips and chunks of real vanilla wafers. Each cookie is drizzled with a light powdered sugar glaze that ties it all together. Every bite tastes like a spoonful of banana pudding — cozy, nostalgic, and downright addictive.

🍪 Please note: There’s a 3-cookie minimum per order — mix & match any flavors!