Ratings & Reviews

We are so thankful we found Evermore Sweets for a last minute baby shower order. She did an amazing job and they tasted great! THANK YOU!

Evermore Sweets made the cutest custom logo cookies for Mocktail Mamas, and they were absolutely perfect! They looked amazing, tasted delicious, and were such a fun addition to our event. Great communication, beautiful attention to detail, and a product that truly exceeded my expectations. Highly recommend!

We love evermore sweets!! Beth’s cookies are always fresh, beautifully decorated to whatever theme you choose, and taste just as amazing as they looked. Can’t wait to order again soon for our next event. 🩷

The cookies were a perfect touch for my daughter’s first birthday. Evermore Sweets always elevates our special occasions with decadent and beautifully designed cookies. We can’t say enough great things about this small business.

We have gotten to watch this sweet mama grow this business from the beginning and she only gets more impressive. The cookies are so detailed and delicious. We order them for all of our kids’ birthday parties and they are always one of the biggest hits of the party!

She did the most amazing job. I only gave her a theme and she ran with it. The cookies not only looking amazing but taste so good as well.

This is our third time ordering with Evermore sweets and every time has been nothing but an amazing experience! Beth is so talented and truly pours her heart and soul into these cookies! The amount of detail on them is amazing and they taste as good as they look! I can’t wait for the next occasion to place another order!

I ordered 24 gymnastics themed cookies for my daughter’s 8th birthday. Beth was so friendly & efficient to work with. The cookies were beautifully decorated, packaged & presented and they tasted delicious. I would 100% order again!

Evermore Sweets really made my vision come to life. Not only were they beautiful but they tasted sooooo good!!!

My girls had the best time painting their Easter egg cookies with edible paint. Beth went above and beyond to make sure my order was perfect. Definitely recommend! The cookies are delicious too!

These cookies are the best! They look amazing and taste even better. So happy to have found evermore sweets!

Evermore Sweets made cookies for my daughter’s 10th birthday and they were a hit! Theme was different but she made it look great and the kids just gobbled them up. Thanks Beth!!!

What great cookies we enjoyed today for my grandson's 2nd birthday! Thank you Evermore Sweets for another amazing batch of your delicious cookies for our celebration. Everyone enjoyed them! Thank you Evermore Sweets!

I can’t say enough great things about Evermore Sweets! Beth has made cookies for all of my boys’ birthdays and perfectly captures the theme every single time. Not only are they stunning, but they taste incredible too. They’re always a crowd favorite, and I’ll definitely be going to her for all my future cookie orders!

Easy communication and assistance in designing our custom cookies! Everyone enjoyed! Highly recommend!!

We ordered cookies for my niece's birthday party. The cookies were the biggest hit!!! Not only were they stunning they tasted incredible! I wish I could leave 10 stars! ⭐️

I have ordered several cookies from Evermore Sweets for my kids birthdays and they always turn out amazing and exactly what I was looking for! We have also done the DIY cookie decorating kits which my kids have really enjoyed. I recently ordered Spider-Man cookies for my son’s 5th birthday which turned out perfect and my son was so excited about them! I always recommend Evermore Sweets for custom cookies! Beth is so sweet and accommodating!

These cookies don’t only look amazing but they’re actually delicious and beat any other sugar cookies I have ever had! I use Beth for all my cookie orders! She’s quick, easy and overall amazing !

Beth was SO easy to work with. The cookies she made for my class were exactly what I had envisioned, DELICIOUS and adorable! She took a last minute order and even delivered them so that my students could have them in time for their friendship day celebration. I couldn’t have asked for better communication and customer service. 100/10 recommend to anyone looking to add a little something to their event, holiday, or special occasion!

Evermore Sweets always delivers the most delicious cookies - they are the prettiest themed designs and always so soft and delicious! My entire family loves them! Can’t recommend enough!

The cookies were exactly what we wanted from the theme to the colors used. Beth never misses!

Beth at Evermoresweets made the most adorable, custom cookies for my work event. She was very easy to communicate with and responded promptly when I had any questions about the design. The cookies were reasonably priced and turned out great! Thanks Beth!

Evermore Sweets did an awesome job on Labubu themed cookies for my daughters birthday, they were adorable and delicious!!

We loved our cookies! The design was amazing and right on point for our party theme. The cookies were delicious too. They were a hit at my son’s birthday party. I highly recommend!

Beth made me the most beautiful and delicious Christmas sugar cookies for decoration. She was so accommodating for a last minute order to make my event special. Highly recommend Evermore Sweets!

The cookies were perfection! My son loved every bite. Beth is also very kind and responsive. Will definitely order again and highly recommend!

These cookies are so delicious and so cute. I got stockings with names on for my Grandkids and a box kit of cookies for them to decorate. They have done her cookie kits before and they just enjoy it so much !

I have been working with Beth for quite some time to handle a variety of events over the years. Every single time she takes my inspiration to the next level & wows myself & others with the flavor and the imagery of her cookies. She truly has a special talent and so sweet to work with. I recommend her 11/10!!!

Delicious and beautiful. Beth is soooooo accommodating and professional as well as dedicated to providing an amazing product.

We have ordered cookies from Evermore Sweets multiple times over the last 2 years and they are ALWAYS the talk of the party. Not only are the cookies beautiful, detailed and made with love, they taste delicious too! We love ordering personalized cookies to help elevate our events. We are grateful to have found such delicious cookies and a great small business to support! 10 Stars ⭐️

Thanks to Evermore Sweets for making the beautiful cookies for my daughter’s Girl Scout Troop meeting! The girls loved the cookies and they were gone fast lol.

Beth’s organization, attention to detail, talent, and baking skills are top notch. My order was perfectly executed and the most special addition to our event. I will order from her over and over again! Thank you!!

These cookies are the best both taste and looks she always kills it on the design.

Not only did Beth meet me for delivery, she added some extra cookies! The sprinkles, icing and perfect cookies were so much fun to decorate and taste SO good! Highly recommend!!

I ordered decorated Halloween cookies for my child’s school class, and they exceeded all expectations, in design and taste! Evermore Sweets is a must try for all occasions!

I love beth's cookies. Cookies are soft and just as described.

I’d give 20 stars if I could! The cookies are incredibly soft and light, the frosting is spot-on, and Beth is truly the best. Can’t recommend her enough!