Cookies
Most cookies come either half or full dozen. When ordering, hit the "Place Order" button on the item you want. Before your add it to your cart either add .5 for half dozen or push the + for 1 (dozen). Then hit add to cart. Price will be reduced by half for half dozen at checkout. The Cookie Jar 🍪 Fresh. Famous. Flavor-First. Handcrafted right here in Mishawaka, our cookies are more than just a treat—they’re a mood. From the classics you crave to the creative swirls you won't find anywhere else. The Texture: Golden, buttery, and baked to perfection. The Punch: Loaded with premium chips, chunks, and swirls.
All the flavors of a traditional cannoli packed into a soft, buttery cookie. It’s a sophisticated treat that brings the pastry shop right to your hand.
The Texture: A tender, melt-in-your-mouth base topped with a light, creamy ricotta-style whip.
The Punch: Bursting with sweet cream, mini chocolate chips, and a hint of citrus.
The Vibe: Elegance in every bite.
**When checking out, select .5 quantity for the small size. Hit + for quantity 1 Lg.
A whimsical, sugar-cookie base topped with smooth white icing and a splash of rainbow sprinkles. It’s a childhood classic reimagined for your sophisticated sweet tooth.
The Texture: A soft, buttery cookie with a satisfying snap from the festive icing and sprinkles.
The Punch: Pure vanilla sweetness paired with the fun, crunchy texture of authentic circus animal treats.
The Vibe: A colorful party in every bite.
**When checking out, select .5 quantity for the small size. Hit + for quantity 1 Lg.
Perfectly soft and chewy cookies with that signature irresistible tang and a generous coating of cinnamon sugar.
The Texture: The ultimate contrast: pillowy-soft centers with slightly crisp, sugar-dusted edges.
The Punch: A cozy, comforting burst of warm cinnamon and sweet sugar that hits all the right notes.
The Vibe: Nostalgic flavor that’s pure homemade happiness.
A chewy oatmeal and peanut butter base loaded with colorful M&Ms and rich chocolate chips. It’s the ultimate crowd-pleaser that packs a bit of everything into every bite.
The Texture: Thick, soft, and satisfyingly chewy with a slight crunch from the oats.
The Punch: A perfect sweet-and-salty balance of creamy peanut butter and chocolate.
The Vibe: Fun, bold, and impossible to resist.
A cocoa-infused dough loaded with even more rich chocolate chips for the ultimate chocolate-on-chocolate experience.
The Texture: Fudgy and dense, almost like a brownie in cookie form.
The Punch: Intense dark chocolate flavor that hits all the right notes.
The Vibe: A serious treat for serious chocolate lovers.
Rich, creamy peanut butter baked into a melt-in-your-mouth cookie with that classic fork-crisscross finish.
The Texture: Soft and slightly crumbly with a velvety, melt-away center.
The Punch: Intense peanut flavor balanced with just the right touch of sea salt.
The Vibe: A protein-packed powerhouse of sweetness.
Savor our homemade chocolate chip cookies baked into chewy mini cakes and bite-sized cups. Each is topped with a swirl of coral pink buttercream and finished with a festive dash of sprinkles for the perfect pop of color and crunch.
4 mini Cookie cakes
20 mini cookies
This homemade version of the classic childhood treat is even better than the original. These Oatmeal Cream Pies are made of soft and chewy oatmeal cookies sandwiching a sweet and creamy marshmallow frosting. This fun and nostalgic dessert is sure to be loved by both adults and kids alike.
sandwich cookies
6 sandwich cookies
20 mini cookies