Crybaby Bakery

Butter Cake + Vanilla Bean Buttercream Cupcakes

$32.00

click for description

Custom Cake

Looking for a cake that’s as special as your celebration? You’ve come to the right place! At Crybaby Bakery, every custom cake is handcrafted with love, layers of flavor, and your vision in mind. Whether you're dreaming up a classic combo or something totally unique, we let you choose your perfect pairing of cake and filling flavors. (Yes, you can mix and match to your heart’s content!) Each cake is built with 3 moist, delicious layers and 2 generous layers of filling. Our standard fillings are buttercream-based, but if you’re craving something extra—like lemon curd, fruit compote, ganache, or custard—just know there’s a small upcharge for that extra indulgence. 🎉 Sizes available: 6-inch – Serves 10–12 people 8-inch – Serves 20–24 people 10-inch – Serves 30–38 people To ensure your cake gets the full Crybaby love it deserves, please allow up to 24 hours for a response to all custom cake inquiries. Orders placed less than 3 weeks in advance may incur a rush fee depending on availability—because let’s be real, these cakes are in high demand! I can't wait to bring your cake vision to life and make your celebration so much sweeter. Let’s make something unforgettable together! 💕🍰

Starting at $185.00

click for description

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Our chocolate chip cookies are thick, chewy, and loaded with hand-chopped chunks of dark, milk, and German chocolate for the perfect bite every time. Rich, gooey, and made with love—these cookies are anything but basic.

$24.00

click for description

Bundt Cake - NEW!

Meet our newest obsession: Crybaby Bundt Cakes ✨ Soft, buttery, impossibly moist, and made to be cried over (in the best way). These dreamy little bundts are perfect for celebrating, sharing… or keeping all to yourself 🎂😋 Choose your flavor fantasy: 💛 Butter Cake + Vanilla Glaze — classic, rich, and melt-in-your-mouth with a silky vanilla drizzle that hits every bite just right. ❤️ Red Velvet + Vanilla Cream Cheese Buttercream — velvety, tender, and generously covered with our signature tangy-sweet cream cheese buttercream. Topped with moist Red Velvet Crumbles to complete a fan favorite. 🍪 Chocolate Chip Cake + Vanilla Bean Buttercream — fluffy butter cake packed with mini milk & semi-sweet chocolate chips throughout, finished with smooth vanilla bean buttercream for the ultimate chocolate chip cookie inspired moment. Freshly baked, wildly delicious, and made with that unmistakable Crybaby magic ✨ Trust us — one slice won’t be enough. Serves 12-16 crybabies.

$60.00

click for description

Banana Pudding Cupcakes

$36.00

click for description

Peanut Butter Overload Cookies

Calling all peanut butter lovers—this one’s for you! Our Peanut Butter Overload Cookie is soft, thick, and packed to the max with rich peanut butter chips in every bite. As if that wasn’t enough, we top each cookie with melty, golden chunks of real Reese’s cups for the ultimate sweet-salty combo. It’s gooey, it’s dreamy, and it’s unapologetically over the top in the best way. Perfect for snack attacks, late-night cravings, or gifting someone their new favorite cookie. 💛 One bite and you’ll see why it’s called Overload. You’ve been warned. 😉

$26.00

click for description