Ratings & Reviews

I love the cookies that I ordered from Lindsay! Not only did she follow my exact vision with what I wanted, but she exceeded what I even imagined the cookies to look like! I gave these cookies as a gift to my friends and they said they tasted so good!

We had such a wonderful experience partnering with Cookies by Artsy Lindsay for our Open House event at Vetopia Animal Health! She thoughtfully created cookie designs that perfectly complemented our space and elevated the overall look of our event - all while providing a delicious treat for our guests. Lindsay was creative, responsive, reliable, and an absolute joy to work with. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to add a beautiful (and tasty!) touch to their special occasion or event!

I am beyond impressed! These cookies were EVERYTHING! The designs were so gorgeous I almost didn’t want to eat them (almost 😂). But once I took a bite—ohhh my God—they were insanely good. Soft, fresh, and perfectly sweet without being overwhelming. Total win. I’m officially obsessed! You can truly taste the love and quality in every bite. These cookies are not just treats, they’re an experience. Highly recommend to anyone looking for cookies that are as stunning as they are delicious!

Lindsay did a perfect job with these cookies. They were even better than I imagined. 10/10!

The cutest cookies! They are so detailed and love the easy ordering/pickup. Will order again!

The cookies I received were absolutely BEAUTIFUL, while also being delicious!!! You can see the thought, skill, and creativity Lindsay put into each cookie. I asked and she 100% provided. They were spot on with the theme of my son’s ocean themed baby shower, and was a total guest favorite. I highly recommend and will order for future events and parties!

The cookies were so amazing! They're all anyone at my daughter's party could talk about. I ordered 2 dozen and they were gone so fast! Next time I'll order more!

I told Lindsay that I would like to send some cookies as a thank you and she came up with the best design. They were perfect! I would use her again, Lindsay was very professional, keep in communication over all pleasure to work with.

We had 4th of July themed cookies made for our daughter’s first birthday party and Lindsay absolutely crushed the vision. They cookies were delicious and totally on theme. I almost didn’t want anyone to eat them! Highly recommend!

I loved the cookies Lindsay made. They were absolutely adorable. I gave her a few things for our theme and she totally handled it and delivered exceptional (and delicious) cookies! Will use again. For sure.

I have used Lindsay multiple times and I am blown away with the work she does! Not only do they look amazing they taste great too!! Highly recommend!

I threw a baby shower and ordered bug theme cookies and they were BEAUTIFUL and exceeded my expectations. Lindsay nailed exactly what I was needing. And not only did they look great, they were also DELICIOUS. I had several guests come up to me and say this was the only cookie with that decoration style that actually tasted yummy! People were grabbing seconds and stuffing them in their pockets to take home!! Book Lindsay for every event!

Lindsay does such great work! I have used her for several occasions. The cookies don’t only look cute but tastes good as well. I definitely recommend!

Lindsay did my son’s birthday cookies as a last minute add-on, and I was so grateful she did! The cookies not only LOOKED amazing but TASTED amazing!! She also was so sweet and kind to be flexible with the pick up days and times. She really went above and beyond to make sure the cookies were perfect and took away so much of my stress getting them done. I will definitely book her again for the next event!

our cookies were so much more beautiful than i could imagine, they tasted so good!!

Ordered cookies for a baby shower & everyone loved them! Lindsay is so talented and pays so much attention to every detail. Will be ordering again for future events!

🌟 Absolutely thrilled with the stunning cookies made by Lindsay for my friend's baby shower! 🍪🎉 From start to finish, her communication and creativity were top-notch. She truly brought my vision to life! A huge thank you for your patience and guidance during my first fancy cookie experience. 🙌💕 Highly recommend—5/5 stars! ⭐️✨

The cookies looked just like the photos I sent for inspo! Such an easy process and pick-up!

Lindsay made BEAUTIFUL cookies for my daughter’s Winter Onederland themed birthday party! I sent a picture of the invitation, color scheme, and a few inspo pictures and she made magic happen. Exquisite detail, flawless execution, and DELICIOUS! Everyone at the party was asking who made the cookies because they were so yummy and adorable!

I gave Lindsay creative freedom and she did not disappoint. My family and I loved her cookies. 10/10 recommend

Lindsay is nice and friendly. Her cookies are so delicious and pretty to look at! She’s very creative. I would definitely buy her cookies again. My sister in law says “ she’s my cookie lady”

Lindsay did an amazing job creating custom Chattanooga-themed cookies for our law office’s grand reopening party! She perfectly brought our vision to life, and her attention to detail was incredible. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about how beautiful and delicious the cookies were! Lindsay’s kindness and excellent communication made the whole process a breeze. We highly recommend her for any of your cookie needs!