Ratings & Reviews

Our baby’s cake was beautiful and delicious.

Every time we have a birthday coming up we always need to get a cake from her. Not only are they delicious but they look amazing. It doesn't matter what kind of theme you want she always kills it!

Cookielicious Cakes has been our custom cake maker for over eight years, and I wouldn’t trust anyone else. Her creativity, attention to detail, and ability to bring ideas to life never fall short of perfection. Every cake is not only stunning but absolutely delicious. She is incredibly personal, professional, and responsive, which makes the entire process seamless and stress-free. I always have complete confidence in her work and highly recommend her to anyone looking for a truly exceptional custom cake.

This is the second time I’ve ordered with her, and both times the cakes were very good. Highly recommend!

I was very happy with the attention, service, the flavor was great and the decoration was very beautiful, thank you for everythin

Everyone loved it. Would definitely recommend.

Cookie makes the most beautiful and delicious cakes ever!!

I ordered a Lisa Frank cake filled with Oreo filling inside and not only was it exactly like a typical Lisa Frank cake colorful with all the colors but it was also so delicious. I will definitely be buying from this company in the future. I highly recommend this company.

Absolutely loved our cake !! She went above and beyond and really personalized our cake to what we were looking far. Beyond delicious would definitely be recommending her to my friends and family. Very pleased with the quality of her service as well thank you!!!!

Beautiful and delicious treats. Thank you 🥰

Cookie was fantastic to work with! We’ve been in Naples for 6 years and had yet to find our “cake place”- excellent decoration and amazing cake/frosting taste. She made two cakes for my child’s birthday (and then the family party)- both were beautiful, delicious. She was very open to feedback after the first cake (less sugar in frosting and moister cake), and changed the recipe on the fly for us for the second cake. It was an absolute hit! The adults and kids ate the entire thing! Definitely our new cake place!

Perfect cookies! We absolutely LOVED our dinosaur themed cookies. They tasted so yummy and were perfectly designed to match our party decorations. Can’t wait to place another order for our next party.

Such a beautiful delicious cake, thank you so much I will definitely be ordering soon! I definitely recommend you and your delicious cake to everyone. Thank you.

I cannot stress enough the beauty, the presentation and the absolute perfection in detail of the cookies we ordered for a baby shower I was blown away! It was extremely easy to order, prompt responses and wonderful suggestions on the choices. I would not even think of using another company. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for your excellent artistry. Debi Carney

I submitted multiple pictures of a “vintage Winnie the Pooh” theme for a baby shower, and she nailed it!! She provided 5 different looks of cookies and all were spot on to what I wanted, she read my mind. The funfetti was delicious! Soo helpful, quick to respond, delivered exactly on time and easy to work with. 10/10 recommend!

Highly recommend Cookie. She was able to copy the look I was going for. Her cake was amazing. Not just the look but the flavors were out of this world.

Cookie made me a beautiful cake for my 60th. It was perfect and tasted so good as well as being a piece of artwork. Thanks Cookie! It was perfect!

Thank you for making us the most beautiful birthday cake. It was gorgeous and delicious!

Absolutely Amazing! I couldn’t be more thrilled with my custom cookie order! The cookies not only looked stunning, but they tasted incredible as well. Each design was exactly as I imagined, and you could tell they were made with so much care and attention to detail. They were delicious and fresh! I will definitely be ordering again for my next special occasion. Highly recommend to anyone looking for unique and tasty treats. Five stars all the way!

Cakes were nothing short of amazing!

Arlene does such an amazing job with her cookies! I have tried many personalized cookies in the past at different parties and they were not edible! These are special! They look and taste amazing! She really delivers a great product. Will continue to order from her

Cookies cake and cupcakes were so beautiful and delicious. They were such a hit at my daughter’s party and so beautiful!

The cake was enormous! Absolutely beautiful! We got exactly what we wanted and she still gave us other ideas to make the cake even more beautiful!

It was absolutely beautiful love it ….

I have ordered from Cookie for a while and her cake and cookies have always been a hit at our parties. Recently ordered a large birthday cake and 150 cookies for my daughter’s squishmallows birthday and once again it was amazing!! Taste is great and decorations are exactly what I asked for with the inspo pics. Will always recommend Cookielicious Cakes for any occasion!

The cake and cookies turned out spectacular and delicious. My guests and I were beyond impressed. Everyone loved the cake and cookies with printed graduate pictures on them. I'm beyond grateful. The party was a success because of cookieliciouscakes. Thank you millions!

I am a property manager at a local apartment community and whenever I have an event, Cookie is my go to! She makes the best looking cupcakes, cookies / cakes all my residents love them, and they taste amazing! 🤩 ❤️ She does great work, reliable, and fair prices!!!

Cookie has been doing my cakes since I was a little girl! She always makes my cake envisions come to life. This year she made my 21st birthday cake and she will make many more!!!

Cake was beautiful and delicious thank you ….

The best in Naples!

The design of the cake was exactly what I wanted and more, but the inside was even better. Perfectly moist red velvet and cream cheese filling.