Featured Products
Round Cookie Cake
The 16-inch round cookie cake is the ultimate crowd-pleaser! Choose chocolate chip or M&M's, single or double layer, and fully iced or border-only with our signature cream cheese icing. Add a personalized message, sprinkles, or fun custom toppers (like Paw Patrol!) to make it extra special. Feeds 8-12 people! Single Layer - Base price Double Layer - Add $15 Border Only - Base price Fully Iced Flat & Border - Add $2 Fully Iced 3D - Add $5 Sprinkles - Add $2 Custom Toppers (Princesses, Paw Patrol figures, etc.) - Add $5-$10, depending on character/size Message - Included ($5 for complex messages)
Starting at $30.00
click for description
Rectangle Cookie Cake
Our 12x16 rectangle cookie cake is perfect for bigger celebrations! Choose chocolate chip or M&M's, single or double layer, and fully iced or border-only with our signature cream cheese icing. Add a personalized message, sprinkles, or fun character toppers to make it extra special. Feeds 15-20 people! Single Layer - Base price Double Layer - Add $20 Border Only - Base price Fully Iced Flat & Border - Add $3 Fully Iced 3D - Add $8 Sprinkles - Add $2 Custom Toppers (Princesses, Paw Patrol figures, etc.) - Add $5-$10, depending on character/size Message - Included ($5 for complex messages)
Starting at $40.00
click for description
Number Cookie Cake
Celebrate with a show-stopping Number Cake! Choose any number (1, 21, 50, 100, and beyond), and I’ll create it with chocolate chip or M&M's, single or double layer, and fully iced or border-only with my signature cream cheese icing. Add a personalized message, sprinkles, or fun character toppers to make it extra special. Size can be adjusted to feed your crowd! Single Layer - Base price Double Layer - Add $12 Border Only - Base price Fully Iced Flat & Border - Add $2 Fully Iced 3D - Add $5 Sprinkles - Add $2 Custom Toppers (Princesses, Paw Patrol figures, etc.) - Add $5-$10, depending on character/size Message - Included ($5 for complex messages)
Starting at $25.00
click for description
About
Hi, I’m Macy — a 29-year-old mom of two with a lifelong love for cookies and a nickname that stuck: Mae. Cookie Mae’d is my way of sharing nostalgic cookie cakes, and since “Mae” is part of me, every cake is a little piece of me. 🍪
Capabilities & Pricing
At Cookie Mae’d, every order is baked fresh by request. I offer classic round and rectangle cookie cakes, mini cookie cakes, and individual cookies—all made in either Chocolate Chip or M&M.
Customizations are always welcome! I use chocolate letters for writing (most of the time), and any colors or themes are fair game. Double-layered cookie cakes are also available for an extra sweet touch.
Pricing varies by size and design, with options starting at a budget-friendly rate and adjusted based on custom details. (More pricing details listed on the items.)
Pickup is always free!
Delivery is available:
• 0–5 miles: free
• 5–10 miles: $5
• 10–20 miles: $10
• 20–30 miles: $15
• 30–40 miles: $20
• 40+ miles: varies depending on location and availability
Orders accepted with as little as 3–5 days’ notice, whenever possible.
Policies
Powered by
