Best Sellers
S'mores Bars
A chewy graham cracker cookie crust surrounds a gooey marshmallow cream and chocolate filling.
Starting at $18.00
Variety Box - 1.5oz Cookies
1 dozen of our most-loved cookie flavors - (3) Chocolate chip - (3) Double chocolate chip - (3) Loaded peanut butter - (3) Sugar with sprinkles
$15.00
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
These cookies have a decadent brown butter base and are loaded with chocolate chips. They bake up deliciously chewy with buttery crisp edges and a nice crackly top. Toasted pecans optional, select during order request. 1 dozen (1.5oz) cookies - $15 1 dozen (3.0oz) cookies - $30
Starting at $15.00
Chocolate Chip Blondies
The chewy blondies are soft and buttery and loaded with two different kinds of chocolate chips. Toasted pecans optional, select during order request. 8" square - $20 9x13" pan - $40
Starting at $20.00
Frosted Sugar Cookie Bars
Frosted sugar cookie bars with sprinkles baked in - they are soft, chewy, and topped with creamy vanilla buttercream and more sprinkles. 8" square - $25 9x13" pan - $50
Starting at $25.00
Scotcheroo Bars (Rice Krispies)
Ultimate scotcheroos - chewy, gooey, with a soft-bite frosting. These are made with Rice Krispies cereal. 8" square - $20 9x13" pan - $40
Starting at $20.00
Chocolate Chip Cookies
A delicious classic loaded with chocolate chips - perfectly chewy with crisp buttery edges and a lightly crinkled top. Toasted pecans optional, select during order request. 1 dozen (1.5oz) cookies - $15 1 dozen (3.0oz) cookies - $30
Starting at $15.00
Loaded Peanut Butter Cookies
These cookies are loaded with creamy peanut butter, peanut butter chips, Reese's Pieces and chopped peanut butter cups. They bake up with beautifully crispy edges and a chewy center. 1 dozen (1.5oz) cookies - $15 1 dozen (3.0oz) cookies - $30
Starting at $15.00
Oreo Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our classic chocolate chip cookie base loaded with tons of chopped Oreo cookies and both semi-sweet amd white chocolate chips. 1 dozen (1.5oz) cookies - $15 1 dozen (3.0oz) cookies - $30
Starting at $15.00
Sugar Cookies With Sprinkles
Classic thick and chewy sugar cookies packed with rainbow sprinkles and rolled in granulated sugar prior to baking. 1 dozen (1.5oz) cookies - $15 1 dozen (3.0oz) cookies - $30
Starting at $15.00
About
Hello, and welcome to my home bakery! I'm Sara Kadrmas, proud owner of The Cookie Lady, located in the heart of Fargo, ND. As a dedicated wife and mom, I’ve been baking for decades - but it was a quest for the ultimate chocolate chip cookie that unlocked my passion.
I tested dozens of recipes over the better part of a year. Each was delicious, yet none quite captured what I envisioned. Through trial and error - along with countless "not quite right" batches - I ultimately created my own recipe. That success fueled my drive to do the same with other classic treats. My enthusiastic taste-testers encouraged me to share my baked goods with the world, leading to the creation of The Cookie Lady in 2024.
At The Cookie Lady, my mission is to bring the most scrumptious versions of your favorite treats from my kitchen to your table. Each item is crafted with love, meticulous attention to detail, and the finest ingredients. My goal is to ensure your special moments are filled with delicious memories.
I am committed to maintaining high-quality standards while keeping my treats affordable. No matter the size of your event, I'm thrilled to be part of your celebrations. Please feel free to look around and let me know how I can help you bring home something sweet.
Policies
Pricing & Payment Info
Thick & chewy bakery-style cookies by the dozen
- 1.5oz starting at $15
- 3.0oz starting at $30
Brownies, blondies, cereal bars, and traybakes starting at $17
(price varies with type & pan size)
Allergen warning: This is a home-based bakery and I use common allergens like dairy, eggs, nuts, soy, and wheat in my kitchen. Please contact me if you have specific allergy concerns.
Payment policies: Payment is due in full at the time of order confirmation. I accept debit or credit cards, CashApp, and Venmo. Your order will not be guaranteed until payment is received.
Pick-Up/Delivery: Order pick-up is available at my home during designated hours. Delivery is available within Fargo for a flat rate of $5. Please select pick-up or delivery at time of submission.
Powered by
