Ratings & Reviews

The most beautiful cookies I’ve ever seen ! Not only were they beautiful, they were absolutely delicious. So happy I found my cookie lady! Her packaging was also very detailed oriented. Everything was absolutely perfect. Can’t wait till my next event to order more cookies ❤️

My order came out beautiful, honestly more than I could ask for! Mik was so excited to work on the design with me and offered so many personal touches. I was blown away and so were my guests!

THE COOKIES WERE DELICIOUS! I saw how amazing Mikala's talent was when I saw all the different designs on her page and I knew I had to try. We got the Fourth of July cookies and they were a hit!! Not only did they look good, but they most definitely tasted so fresh and delicious. If you're looking to check both boxes off, these are for you!! I did the funfetti flavor and each cookie was individually wrapped which was so clean and efficient. The process to order and pick up was extremely easy as well. Highly recommend!!

So impressed with the cookies for my daughter’s baptism! They came out better than I even imagined, cannot wait to show them off to family and friends. Will definitely order here again 🥰

I’ve ordered these cookies 3 times now for different occasions as well as referring them to everyone I know! Not only do they look beautiful but they taste SO good too. The cookies and cream doesn’t skip a beat! Definitely recommend.

The cookies came out absolutely amazing!! I saw them and my jaw instantly dropped! Thank you so much!

My daughter wanted end of the year gifts for her teachers for when she graduated highschool. I saw Cookies by Mik had posted cookies for teachers day so I reached out. Mikala is super nice, her customer service is superb and the cookies are amazing! She made cookies for my daughter’s teachers, even customized some for the principals. We loved them so much we ordered 7 dozen for her graduation party. The details that went into the cookies from taking the order to the finished product were amazing. Everyone complimented how beautiful the cookies were and they tasted amazing also!! I would highly highly recommend Cookies by Mik to anyone in the market for custom cookies. Her prices are extremely reasonable, and her cookies are a work of art! I’m glad that we found her and we will definitely be using her again … and not only for parties but probably just to have some of her delicious cookies in our house!!

Mikayla did a phenomenal job custom creating some Taylor Swift cookies for us. Not only were they beautiful but they tasted delicious as well. An unexpected family matter came up and she rushed our order. I highly recommend Mikayla!

I have been wanting to have an event that i could use CookieCreations and I finally found one and she did NOT disappoint! Not only was she completely patient with me and my crazy scheduling, she was so helpful with any questions I had. I'm in love with the decorative designs she did, they're even better than the reference photos I found! I can't believe how good they came out, I am so excited to show everyone at the gender reveal!

So I was gifted one pencil cookie with my name on it from a student during teacher appreciation week. Cookies that are beautifully decorated like that usually do not taste good. The cookies sat on my desk for four days and one night after working late I was starving and ate the cookie. I could not believe, how delicious this cookie was. I immediately got the wrapper out of the garbage and called Mikala to make cookies for my son's graduation party from medical school. Well I picked up those cookies yesterday and I was blown away. I actually carried the two boxes to my car and then opened them and inspected each one and cried. They were so beautiful. She even added more designs than I had given her and they were just amazing!!!! Yes, I did eat one in the car. It was mouthwateringly delicious!!!!🍪

Mikala does the best work i’ve seen in a long time ! She takes her time and makes sure to take your input into consideration and makes your ideas/requests come to life with her work !! thank you so much ! will be using you for EVERY cookie need !

Mikala was extremely professional! She responded to my inquiry super quickly and was a pleasure to work with. She did a fantastic job with my cookies and I will definitely be ordering again!

Cookies were so cute and seller was great to work with.

I bought some cookies for Mother’s Day and not only were they gorgeous but they were so delicious! I will be ordering my custom cookies from Mikala, here on out!

Love Mikala cookies. Specially her decorate your own kits. Taste of her cookies are really good. Never disappoint. Great product for a great price.

Love them!

Fast turn around time and the cookies are beautiful!

Mikala never disappoints! The designs, the flavors and customer services is always stellar. I will always order from her for special events.

Mikala did a beyond amazing job on my daughter’s 1st birthday cookies! I highly recommend her for any occasion!

Extravagant cookies that add a cute touch to my friends baby shower! The intricate designs and delicious flavors are going to be a hit with everyone. Highly recommend this cookie business for any special occasion!

These cookies are not only delicious, but they’re beautifully made as well! I ordered on a Sunday, and was able to pick up my 12 cookies for my kiddo by Wednesday. $54 for 12 cookies can seem like a lot, but cookies designed specifically for your loved ones and the look on their face is priceless ❤️ She’ll work with your potential designs to find what works! They taste SO good too!! They aren’t rock hard cookies, they’re soft perfectly cooked sugar cookies :) even come with instructions for keeping them tasting delicious if you have leftovers! Individually wrapped!!

My daughter and I are absolutely amazed by the Pokemon cookies. The way they look and taste are beyond perfect!