Ratings & Reviews

I ordered "Little Bear" themed cake pops for my daughter's birthday party. With just a couple inspiration photos she made us the most beautiful designs! My daughter absolutely loved them! Will definitely order again!

If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! The cookies, cakepops, and pretzels for our daughter's baby shower from Coleys, were outstanding. They were the highlight of our event! The attention to detail blew our guests away. Nikki will exceed your expectations to create beautiful and incredibly delicious desserts.

Nicolle is very talented her cake is not only aesthetically pleasing but also very moist & delicious. You can tell it is made with love!

Absolutely amazing cake pops from Coley’s Cakepops! From start to finish, the communication was clear, friendly, and professional. Every detail was handled with care, and the presentation was flawless—beautifully designed and packaged to perfection. The cake pops themselves were incredibly fresh, moist, and full of flavor. You can truly see and taste the passion and attention to detail in every bite. Highly recommend Coley’s Cakepops for any occasion—you won’t be disappointed! It was great pleasure to work with you 😊

The kpop demon hunter inspired cake pops were a huge hit at my son’s birthday party!

My daughter was requesting a Lilo & Stitch birthday theme, so Coley made me cake pops, cupcakes and even a mini cake for her to blow out the candles on. All delish and looked adorable! Party goers complimented all the sweets and kept asking who made them. I raved about Coley's work and I'm sure I will be using her services again.

Had a gender neutral baby shower and had Nicole with Coley Cake Pops do my cake pops for desserts/ going away goodie bags! They turned out beautiful. Very soft and moist.

Her treats were both beautiful & delicious! For my friend’s dovorce party over the weekend, we ordered chocolate covered strawberries, chocolate raspberry bars & vanilla cake pops. They were decorated to perfection and tasted even better than they looked. You can tell she puts a lot of love into both taste annd anesthetic. Every strawberry was carefully curated, perfect and plump. Every bite outstanding. 🤤 This was my first time using Coley’s and I will definitely be calling for another order again soon!

I ordered for the first time last fall for a themed birthday party and I was blown away with the final product! Nicole is very creative and is so easy to work with. Not only are her designs unique, but they are delicious too!! I just received my second order…it was a last minute request and Nicole came through! Our end of summer BBQ is now complete with this order! Would highly recommend!

The pharmacy themed cookies Coley’s made were the perfect graduation surprise. Beautifully decorated & the taste was amazing. Coley’s went above & beyond to make our special occasion even more perfect & we can’t thank her enough!❤️

Nicole went above and beyond for our desserts! They matched our farm theme perfectly, were adorable, and tasted great! We will definitely be using her for all of our upcoming parties!

I have used Coley's for my baby shower and my son's baby dedication. At both events, people raved how delicious the desserts were! Nicole always provides great customer service. I highly recommend Coley's Cake pops!

Nicole and her creativity is out of this world! Her attention to detail does not go unnoticed. I will be calling her for all of my sweet treats. Thanks Nicole!

They are so cute . Bakesy shop did an awesome job !!

I wish I could give this more stars. Presentation 100/10, designs and details, 100/10 and taste… soooo good, 100/10! Highly highly recommend.

Ordered cookies for my 30th birthday, the party theme was 13 Going on 30 and the cookies couldn’t have come out better! They were super delicious too. My friends were very impressed

I was an awe of the sweets for my daughter’s first birthday!! They turned out even better than I imagined. So yummy❤️ Also, Nicole did a great job with my theme. Would highly recommend.

The desserts we ordered were beyond expectations! Everything about our experience was above and beyond. We will be recommending you to everyone we know! Thank you for making a special day even more memorable!

Truly the most DELICIOUS, fresh cakeops we ever had! They were a huge hit at my little boys Birthday party! I should also add they looked as amazing as they tasted! Already booking for December !

Amazing!!!!

They were BEAUITFUL and delicious! Nicole was super easy to work with and everyone said the were the prettiest desserts they’ve ever seen!

I ordered cookies for favors for my brother’s bridal shower and they were nothing short of AMAZING. I will continue to order from Coley’s Cakepops for any event I need sweets for!!

I ordered Elmo and Baby Shark cake pops and they were incredible!!! I’ve already made my next order for 2 birthday cakes and can’t wait to see the design! Highly Recommend!

I ordered cake pops for a baby shower, and they were an absolute hit! Everyone loved them. The cake pops were perfect — not only did they taste delicious, but they were also presented beautifully. Each one was individually wrapped with a coordinating bow that matched the theme perfectly. The attention to detail was impressive. Working with Nicole was a pleasure; she really understood what I was looking for and delivered beyond my expectations. I highly recommend her for any event — she truly nailed it!

Nicole was wonderful! She was extremely accommodating and very personable! Her cupcakes were beautiful and very detailed in the design! She delivered my cupcakes with love! 💕

The service was great. Very easy to work with and very accommodating. 💕

They were delicious and adorable! She is easy to work with, polite, professional. Excellent job!

U do beautiful work and the cake pops and cookies were delicious Nothing but compliments from everyone

Nicole created the most beautiful cake pops for our Earth Day event at the ALDI campus. She was communicative, kind, and willing to take on our large order even though it was pretty last minute! I highly recommend her to anyone looking for a wonderful local business to partner with for any event! Thank you, Nicole!