Ratings & Reviews

so amazing and fast!! Ordered and were ready 20 minutes later!! There are so yummy!

If you’re in the Jacksonville area, Cake by Katie makes the absolute best cakesicles! There’s such a great variety of flavors, and each one is truly a little work of art. They’re always super moist and flavorful, not overly sweet, just perfect. The strawberry shortcake flavor is definitely our favorite! The presentation is always stunning, and her custom designs are consistently beautiful. You can tell she puts so much care and attention into everything she creates. Perfect for gifts or special occasions, and pickup is always smooth and easy. We will definitely keep coming back!

Every flavor we tried was great. Well packaged, moist cakes, great presentation. Don’t think twice about ordering these!

The cake pops were so moist and delicious. Best out there!!!!

Seriously the absolute best cake pops I’ve ever had the pleasure of eating! Would definitely recommend to everyone!

The cake was moist and delicious. The variety was also insane. Best cake pops I've ever had.

Katie made the most adorable Formula One themed pops for my sons first birthday! She was very thoughtful to the theme. Each one was a work of art and made it so much easier for everyone at the party to enjoy some cake! I highly recommend!

So cute!!! I love them and they taste delicious 😋

Awesome! Not only were they super cute, but they tasted amazing! Thank you!

Best cake pops I’ve ever had! And Katie was so easy to work with. I’ll definitely be ordering again!

The cake pops look great! Katie was soooo responsive and brought my inspiration to life. 10 out of 10 recommend!

Wow! These cakesicles were absolutely delicious! Perfectly moist, so beautifully decorated, and amazing flavor. I immediately went home and tried 1 because I couldn’t wait till the actual celebration tomorrow lol 🤤😁

INSANE!!! My friend had me try one of the Thin Mints and I had to order ASAP. Picked up half a dozen and ate 4 already LOL. She has great communication, knows what she’s doing and the decoration/packing is so cutie:’)

Wow…not only were the cakesicles absolutely gorgeous, the taste was a 10 out of 10!! Hands down the best I’ve ever had!! Ordering was easy, great communication from Katie and pick up was a breeze!! Thank you Katie!!

Soooooo cute!!!!

Katie was prompt in responding to any questions I had about my order. Such creative work and packaged beautifully. I have no doubt these pops will taste delicious for our event! I would absolutely order again!

Delicious product in beautiful packaging!

I'm so happy I managed to snag an extra dozen! They were so beautiful and delicious. An absolute hit with everyone at our party! I will definitely be ordering again 😀

I ordered the Duval Dozen Jags cake pops from Katie. Flavors: chocolate salted caramel, Funfetti, and strawberry shortcake. First, they were absolutely beautiful in presentation….and even BETTER in taste! They were an amazing hit with all our friends. Will definitely be ordering more from Katie!

First time ordering from Cake by Katie and it was a wonderful experience. Easy to order and arrange pick-up. Everyone loved the cake pops. . . I tasted the double chocolate salted caramel one and it was delicious! They were beautifully decorated, too! Thanks, Katie.

First time ordering from Cake by Katie and let me tell you, I will be ordering again!! Ordered the specialty, Duval Dozen and was not disappointed! Everyone loved the attention to detail and the flavors were out of this world. Do not sleep on this local business for your next party or gathering!!!

Scored these for the Jags playoff game party and they were a hit! We’ll definitely be ordering again!

I ordered cake pops for the Jags game and they were so cute! Everyone loved them. Will order again. Thank you!

We ordered the Duval pack of cakesicles and there were a HUGE hit! Only regret is not ordering extra to take home. I have tried cakesicles from a few Jax local bakers and Katie’s are by far our favorite. Can’t wait to put our next order in! ❤️

Katie’s Jaguar themed cake pops were amazing! They were decorated so elegantly with beautiful color and topping detail, and were absolutely delicious! Every flavor was a hit at our party. Will definitely be ordering again!

The cakesicles were absolutely phenomenal!!! They were so pretty and the taste was absolutely delicious! Everyone loved them. We will definitely be doing business with them again in the future!

These Jaguar cake pops were absolutely outstanding- delicious and beautifully decorated with incredible attention to detail. You could truly taste the skill that went into making them. Everyone was over the moon about them, and they were a huge hit from start of finish. As gorgeous as they were tasty- highly recommend.

What a treat! Katie makes the best cake pops! She has really fun flavors and does an amazing job creating those flavors and with the presentation as well! They are the cutest cake pops! If you’re looking for a sweet treat try these! You won’t regret it! - Officially a cake pop lover

This a was a last minute find and I’m so glad I found them. Delicious treats and even sweeter service.

So happy with our order!! They look and taste amazing! Crowd pleaser for sure. Definitely are hoping to get some for more holidays!

These cake pops were soooo good. We got the pumpkin flavor / fall theme and they were a hit for Thanksgiving! They are designed perfectly and have the best taste! Perfect size too! Thank you so much Katie 🤩