Ratings & Reviews

Ordered a cake for my 5th anniversary & it was exactly what I asked for! I sent reference pictures & she did it perfect!

I ordered 2 of the Mother’s Day cakes from Shelby at Butter and Bliss and omg it was amazing! The buttercream is out of this world and not too sweet, the cake was rich and moist and the decor put it all over the time! I cannot wait to order again!

The BEST Mothers Day cake ever!! So well decorated and beautifully presented. Will definitely order from Butter+Bliss again soon!!!

Shelby has been our go-to baker for every occasion—from the most delicious cookies to gorgeous custom cakes, and even holiday loaves that disappear faster than she can bake them. She made my daughter’s quinceañera cake and absolutely nailed it. It’s completely obvious she bakes with love and never misses the mark. If you’re thinking about ordering from her, just know: SHELBY. DON’T. MISS.

Best cake I’ve had! Seriously run don’t walk! Frosting is amazing too! Total gem!

I will preface by saying I'm not very hard to please when it comes to food, but I know what I like and what I do not. Normally, I am repulsed by fruit involved in my desserts....but wow! The lemon blueberry loaf is so decadent and light and fresh. All the loaves are so moist, but still hold that classic shape really well so it's not falling apart in your hand. Another normal for me is having a distaste for peanut butter...buttttt I am in LOVE with these peanut butter cookies! Oh my gosh! Whatever you choose, you really can't go wrong.

This cake was moist, flavorful, and beautifully made. You can tell it was baked with care. Everyone loved it—will definitely be ordering again!

Shelby’s local bakery is a true treasure—her handmade cakes are out of this world. Each one is beautifully crafted, rich in flavor, and clearly made with love. Shelby’s warm, personal touch makes every visit special. You won’t find better cakes anywhere!