Ratings & Reviews

I can’t say enough good things about this place! The cookies and cupcakes are hands-down the best I’ve had in a long time. Everything tastes homemade and absolutely delicious - you can tell real care goes into every batch. My 4-year-old is completely obsessed with them, which says it all! 😍 Supporting a small business that puts out treats this good feels like finding a true gem. I’ll definitely be a repeat customer. Highly recommend!

I have never been a cupcake person, but Burnt Toast Bakery completely changed my mind. The cupcakes here are exceptional—perfectly balanced, moist, and flavorful without being overly sweet. If you think you aren't a fan of cupcakes, this place will convert you. Highly recommend.

Best cupcakes I've had in a while! The coffee crunch cupcake was amazing. It was light, moist, and packed with rich coffee flavor without being overpowering. The coffee honeycomb topping was out of this world! I would buy only that if I could. The chocolate caramel crunch cupcake was equally satisfying. I especially like the caramel center which reminded me of all time fave, dulce de leche. Both cupcakes had the right amount of sweetness, were beautifully presented, incredibly fresh, and tasted like they were made with high-quality ingredients. I can't wait to try more of Stacy's creations!

The July drop cupcakes, coffee crunch and chocolate caramel crunch, were delicious. You can absolutely taste that these are small-batch, homemade cupcakes, using quality and curated ingredients. The honeycomb topping was a fun texture to the cupcake. The balance of the sweet frosting with a light, airy cake was great. Also appreciated the size of the cupcake! 10/10

Both the churro and lemon cupcakes are deliciously moist and flavorful. The lemon cupcake is perfect for the lemon-lover with its delectable curd filling. The frostings are the perfect sweetness complimented by fun flavored crunchies. The chocolate toffee crunch cookies are also a standout with the perfect balance of being not-too-sweet, but with rich chocolate and toffee bites of flavor. Yum yum yum.

Moist and tender cake with a rich, caramel center and silky dulce de leche frosting. Perfect balance of sweetness and texture, every bite melts in your mouth. Highly recommend.

I thoroughly enjoyed the 2 flavors of cupcakes that I tried recently from Burnt Toast Bakery. The lemon crunch cupcake had a delicious zesty lemon jam filling and I found the texture of the actual cupcake to be moist and fluffy. One of the best part of this cupcake though was the honeycomb bits on top which added a nice contrasting crunch. The Dulce de Leche Churro cupcakes also had great flavor and the Swiss meringue topping was soooo good!! You can tell the baker puts a lot of thought into the flavors and presentation of her cupcakes. They are top notch!!