Ratings & Reviews

Every once in awhile, you come across a cookie so extraordinary that it changes your perception of what a cookie can be. Recently, I had the pleasure of indulging in what can only be described as the most amazing cookies I’ve ever had! and still keep dreaming about them I keep wanting more! My fav are the Brown butter Cookies and S’mores! Each cookie was beautifully crafted and with perfect balance of crunch and chew!

My son ate these cookies and kept saying that they were the best cookies he ever had. He said it over and over that they were so good. My other son kept saying how amazing they are.

Ive gotten several products from Betsy and she always delivers outstanding items. Ive had her s'mores, cookie monsters, brown butter and PB fluff. And i cant decide which i like best yet. I will continue to try more of her stuff and tell anyone i can about her business. She deserves the praise. Never had a bad time with her, and shes fast to respond and delivers on time.

I ordered both the s’mores and chocolate chip walnut cookies and both were amazing! I took several dozen to a local nursing home as a way to say thanks to their great staff and I was overwhelmed by their comments. Best cookies, so gooey in the best way, one staff member thought they’d be good warmed up with a little ice cream. The chocolate chip cookies were our favorite! Can’t wait to try some of the other flavors!

These cookies were nothing short of amazing. Every detail was perfect, and you can truly taste the care and creativity in each one. If you’re looking for something unique and outstanding, this is the place to go. They take cookies to a whole new level!

Brown butter cookies are my very favorite!!! They are amazing and I don’t share them.

I ordered cookies online from Betsy's Bake's and the whole process from start to pickup was flawless. The cookies were beautifully wrapped and are absolutely delicious!! Ruth

I was able to get cookies shipped to my house and they were still extremely soft and immensely flavorful even days after they were made. 1000/10 recommend.

We tried four different flavors of Betsy’s cookies and all were delicious

Betsy didn’t disappoint with her Almond joy and dairy/nut/egg free chocolate chip cookies. Not only are they as big as my hand, they are delicious! From the flavor to the cute packaging, Betsy out did herself! If you have a sweet tooth Betsy is your girl. Will DEFINITELY order again!

Ginormous size cookies, soft, sweet & sugary. My favorite so far is chocolate with walnuts.

I’m trying so hard to lay off the sweets so I feel if I’m going to eat some, I need to make it worth something. I recently tried Betsy’s Cadbury egg chocolate chip cookies and I nearly stopped breathing. They were beyond delicious. I think of myself as a cookie snob of sorts, they have to be just right for me to enjoy them. I don’t like hard cookies. These were perfect! I also got to try her Cookie Monster cookies and they were the same beloved consistency. This girl is cookie gifted! I’m just lucky to reap the rewards of her talent.

Betsy was kind enough to bring us a batch of her delicious Cookie Monster cookies, and my staff and I instantly fell in love. I put some out for our clients to enjoy as well, and everyone went absolutely nuts over them! They were such a hit that I’ll be purchasing them weekly for our coffee station. Amazing flavor, perfect texture, and clearly made with love—highly recommend! 🍪💙

Betsy's cookies are by far the best that I have ever had!!! Each flavor is even more delicious than the last!!!! Try them, you will not regret it!!!

If a chocolate chip cookie and pecan pie had a baby, it would come out like these. Delicious!

Truly some of the best cookies I’ve ever had! Definitely not your average cookie!!

I ordered Dubai Chocolate Chip and Cadbury Mini Egg cookies which were baked to perfection with a soft center and loaded the Cadbury eggs and drizzled in the creamy chocolate. Ordering was simple and I was enjoying my cookies 2 days later, already trying to come up with a reason to order more!

Truly orgasmic cookies! Between the size and the taste. Betsy hits the spot every time!! My fave are the Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies!

I loved the gourmet cookies you can taste the homemade love that is put into her deliciousness

Betsy’s cookies are amazing. Sweet and delicious!! Can’t wait to see what she makes next.

Best cookies I have ever had!! The peanut butter and jelly are my Fav, but to be honest have not had a bad cookie from Betsy.

Hands down the best we have ever had, and we have had many!!

Amazing cookies and such a variety to choose from, will always order from here !!! Also excellent customer service, it's a win 🏆

I’ve tried many different cookies from Betsy’s Bakes and they are all so delicious! They are soft and tender! She has a wide variety of flavors and unique creations! I can’t wait to try them all! Definitely a crowd pleaser!

The most delicious cookies you will ever have! My favorite are the chocolate ones.

I have never had a better cookie than at Betsy's Bakes. They are by far, my favorite cookies ! I can't even tell you which one is my favorite because they are all amazing !!! Highly recommend... 5 stars !