Batter Up Confections

Active Sourdough Starter

This Active Starter for sourdough bread is mature and ready to bake! Use it for a fresh loaf or to keep your very own starter on hand! Orders for starter must be placed at least one day prior to pick up.

$10.00

Gingerbread

$24.00

Cookie Monster Chocolate Chip

$3.00

Birthday Celebration Pancake Mix

10 oz.

$8.00

Little League Line Up (Mini Cookies For Us- But Regular Sized Cookies For Others)

Little League Lineup Step up to the plate with our Little League Lineup—a dozen bite-sized versions of our signature cookies, all in one winning box. Handpick your lineup from our all-star roster of flavors and build your own custom assortment. Perfect for sharing after the big game or treating your team to a sweet victory!

$30.00

The Oreo All star

$4.25

The Banana Bunt

Soft, Sweet, and straight from the Southern Snack Playbook. This banana pudding-inspired cookie is stacked with vanilla chips, banana flavor, and Nilla crunch—light on the swing, heavy on nostalgia.

$4.25

The Hall Of Famer

A timeless classic that stands the test of time—this chocolate chip cookie is a true legend, with rich chocolate chips and the perfect chewy texture. “A cookie worthy of the hall of fame.”

$28.00

The Biscoff Bomb

🎤Now Batting… The Biscoff Bomb! Stuffed with creamy cookie butter, loaded with melt chocolate chips, and ready to knock your tastebuds outta the park!

$4.25

The Strawberry

The Darryl Strawberry This all-star cookie is a wild throwback to the sweet, chaotic glory days of the '80s. Packed with juicy strawberry flavor, rich white chocolate chunks, and crushed golden Oreos, The Darryl Strawberry hits harder than a late-night home run. It’s soft, sweet, and just a little out of bounds—like its namesake in his prime. Batter up, sweet tooths—this one’s swinging for the fences.

$4.25

The Walk-Off Nutella

Just like a walk-off home run, this cookie hits it out of the park with chocolate chips and a gooey Nutella center that’ll leave you craving more. “A game-winning flavor in every bite.”

$4.25

The Base Hit

You can always count on this M&M cookie to get on base. With chewy dough and vibrant M&M’s, it’s the perfect hit every time. “A base hit of sweet and colorful flavor.”

$4.25

The Power Play

When you need a cookie that brings the wow factor, this is the one. Three types of chocolate chips, sweetened coconut, honey-roasted almonds, and a full Almond Joy stuffed in the center come together for the ultimate power play. “Packed with flavor and ready to deliver a home run.”

$4.25

The Power Hitter

This cookie is ready to knock it out of the park with every bite. Packed with peanut butter, chocolate chips, Reese’s Pieces, and a full Reese’s Cup stuffed right in the center, it’s a major league treat that packs a punch. “This one’s got all the power—it’s your sweet spot for a big hit!”

$4.25

The Sandlot Chew

“You’re killin’ me, smalls!” This chewy churro-style cookie blends warm cinnamon sugar, buttery toffee bits, and creamy white chocolate for a flavor that hits like a summer afternoon at the ballfield. It’s nostalgic, it’s messy, it’s magic. Grab a glove and two of these—just in case one gets stolen by The Beast.

$4.25