Most Popular Items
Banana Split Cake
This cake is sure to be the show stopper for any occasion! A strawberry poke cake frosted in cream cheese whipped cream with an absurd amount of chocolate covered strawberries, pineapples, bananas and maraschino cherries!
Starting at $125.00
click for description
Custom Cut Outs
Custom sugar cookies are the perfect addition to any celebration! Our cookies are made with delicious vanilla flavor and are frosted in royal icing.
Starting at $42.00
click for description
Custom Cakes
Please select this option to order a custom cake! Cake Flavors: Yellow, Chocolate, White, Almond, Confetti, Cookies & Cream, Banana, Cherry Chip, Coconut Fillings: Vanilla Custard, Chocolate Ganache, Cherry, Raspberry, Lemon, Strawberry, Blueberry, Cannoli & Chip, Cassata, Peanut Butter, Nutella, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, HoHo, Cookies & Cream, Fresh Berries, Cream Cheese, Raspberry Mousse, Strawberry Mousse Frostings: Vanilla, Almond, Coconut
Starting at $75.00
click for description
Pumpkin Pie
$28.00
click for description
Double Apple Pie
$30.00
click for description
Apple Crumble Pie
$30.00
click for description
Thanksgiving
“Slush”
A shortbread crust topped with layers of cream cheese, pudding, and whipped topping! Serves 12-15
Starting at $30.00
click for description
Cheesecake
Starting at $30.00
click for description
Pumpkin Roll
$25.00
click for description
Cut Out Cookies
$36.00
click for description
DIY Cookie Kit - 1 Dozen
$25.00
click for description
Caramel Apple Cake
A spiced apple cake with apple filling and a brown butter, cream cheese frosting with salted caramel drizzle. Serves 20
$65.00
click for description
Oreo Cream Pie
$30.00
click for description
Cannoli Cream Pie
$35.00
click for description
Lemon Cream Pie
$25.00
click for description
Coconut Cream Pie
$30.00
click for description
Banana Cream Pie
$25.00
click for description
Peanut Butter Cream Pie
$30.00
click for description
Chocolate Cream Pie
$25.00
click for description
Pecan Pie
$30.00
click for description
Triple Berry Pie
$30.00
click for description
Cherry Pie
$30.00
click for description
Blueberry Pie
$30.00
click for description
Pumpkin Pie
$28.00
click for description
Double Apple Pie
$30.00
click for description
Apple Crumble Pie
$30.00
click for description
Halloween 👻
9in Cookie Cake
Chocolate chip cookie cake with buttercream frosting! Serves 8-12
$30.00
click for description
Cupcakes
A mix of chocolate and vanilla cupcakes with buttercream frosting and Halloween decorations!
Starting at $18.00
click for description
Cut Out Cookies
A mix of Halloween themed sugar cookies with royal icing!
$32.00
click for description
6in Single Layer Cake
Yellow cake layer with buttercream frosting and choice of Halloween theme! Serves 6-8
$32.00
click for description
“Boo” Box
A mix of cookies, cake pops, brownies and cupcakes! About 12-15 items total.
$45.00
click for description
About
At Baked by Burns, every treat is crafted with passion, precision, and a whole lot of love. Founded by pastry chef Maddie Burns, a Niagara Falls native with a background in Baking & Pastry Arts and Business, our bakery blends classic techniques with creative flair. Rooted in Maddie’s Italian family traditions and years of professional experience—including managing a Fortune 500 bakery—our mission is to bring people together through handcrafted cakes, cookies, and seasonal specialties.
In 2025, Baked by Burns was honored with Best Bakery in Niagara Falls and the People’s Choice Award at Kiss 98.5’s Cupcake Challenge, and was proudly featured in the Niagara Falls Culinary Institute’s Business Spotlight. Baked by Burns is best known for the Cherry Chip cake and Banana Split cake!
Now, we’re excited to serve our community through custom orders, wholesale offerings, and pop-up events—continuing to make life’s sweetest moments even more memorable.
Capabilities & Pricing
Most custom orders require two weeks notice with a 50% non refundable deposit in order to secure your order.