We are fully Booked till the end of August!
×

Bake My Day

Seaford, New York

(16)

Featured Products

Custom Sugar Cookies

Starting at $54.00

click for description

Cake Pops

Starting at $34.00

click for description

4 in. 2 layer Cake (Serves 4)

Starting at $25.00

click for description

Dip & Delight (4 Dozen)

Starting at $120.00

click for description

Cookies

Custom Sugar Cookies

Starting at $54.00

click for description

Party Packages

Little Sampler

Starting at $60.00

click for description

Triple Dip (3 Dozen)

Starting at $75.00

click for description

Dip & Delight (4 Dozen)

Starting at $120.00

click for description

Bake My Bundle (8 Dozen)

Starting at $270.00

click for description

Sweet Dozen (12 Dozen)

Starting at $340.00

click for description

Favor Boxes (10 Ct.)

Starting at $150.00

click for description

About

Hi, I’m Karly, the baker behind Bake My Day! What began as a love for baking in my home kitchen has grown into a business dedicated to creating desserts that are as beautiful as they are delicious. From cupcakes to party packages, every treat is made with care and high-quality ingredients to make your celebrations a little sweeter.

Capabilities & Pricing

Prices vary; if you’re having trouble finding what you need to order, shoot me a dm or email!

**Custom cookies need at least 5 days notice for orders**

Policies

Order minimum: $30
Typical Deposit: 50%
Typical lead-time needed: 4 days

Delivery Fees🚛

Delivery and meetup fees are based on distance: • Under 10 miles: +$10 • 11-15 miles: +$25 • 16–20 miles: +$40 • 20+ miles: To be discussed prior to booking Orders traveling over 15 miles require a $150 order minimum. This policy applies to both delivery orders and meetups.

Cake Pops🍭

Our bite-sized cake dough are the perfect party treat—cute, customizable, and always a crowd favorite! Sold by the dozen • Starting at $34/dozen • Available in classic round or flat disc styles • Custom shapes for special occasions, like: 🎓 Graduation Caps ✝️ Baptism Crosses •Cakesicles available $36/per dozen • Flavor options: Chocolate, Vanilla, Red Velvet, Chocolate Chip (tastes like cookie dough!), & Funfetti

Party Packages🎉

BUNDLE & SAVE!! Little Sampler $60+ (basic dip/drizzle) -6 Strawberries -6 Cake Pops -6 Rice Krispie Treats Triple Dip $75+ (basic dip/drizzle) -12 Pretzels -12 Rice Krispie Treats -12 Oreos Dip & Delight $120+ (basic dip/drizzle) -12 Cake Pops -12 Pretzels -12 Rice Krispie Treats -12 Oreos Sweet Dozen $340+ (basic dip/drizzle) -24 Cake Pops -24 Mini Cupcakes -24 Pretzels -24 Oreos -24 Cheesecake Shooters -12 Rice Krispie Treats -12 Strawberries

Cakes🎂

The centerpiece of any celebration—three layers of moist, flavorful cake frosted and decorated to perfection. 🎂✨ Sizes & Starting Prices: • 4-inch, 2-layer (serves 2–4) — from $25 • 6-inch (serves 10–15) — from $65 • 6-inch HEART (serves 10–15) — from $70 • 8-inch (serves 20–24) — from $85 • 8-inch HEART (serves 20–24) — from $90 *Starting prices include a simply frosted cake with white buttercream only. Custom colors, designs, décor, and additional details are priced separately. • Unless stated otherwise, all cakes are three layers tall for that extra wow factor ✨ • Flavor options: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet • Custom designs are available upon request • Available upgrades: Colored buttercream, sprinkles, edible luster dust, gold/silver flakes or detailing, fondant details, fresh florals, edible toppers, themed décor, and more for an additional cost.

Cupcakes🧁

•Sold by dozens •Classic $35 •Signature flavors $48 -Oreo, Nutella, Funfetti, Biscoff, Peanut Butter •Deluxe $48 -Custom themed cupcakes (edible toppers, elaborate themes) Cake Options: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet Custom Pull-Apart Cupcake Boards: $50 (based on 2 dozen) **If needed more for design, an additional dozen will be charged. Extra cupcakes not used in design will be packaged separately** Custom cupcake board starts at $50 Floral Cupcake Boards SMALL: $35 (14 mini cupcakes, 1 flavor) XL: $185 (50 large cupcakes)

Chocolate Covered Rice Krispie Treats

A nostalgic favorite with a sweet twist—crispy marshmallow bars dipped in smooth chocolate and decorated to fit any theme! • Sold by the dozen • Starting at $30/dozen

Chocolate Covered Oreos

Everyone’s favorite cookie, leveled up! Double-stuffed with flavor, dipped in chocolate, and decorated to perfection. • Sold by the dozen • Starting at $30/dozen Custom images are +$10 per dozen!

Chocolate Covered Pretzels🥨

The ultimate sweet + salty combo! Crunchy pretzels dipped in rich chocolate and dressed up with sprinkles, drizzle, or custom colors. • Sold by the dozen • Starting at $22/dozen

Dessert Table Set Up

$50 on top of delivery fee Includes: • Dessert trays/stands • Gorgeous layout spread • Worry free planning **This is an additional service, this is not items to be bought. All items will be dropped off and set up for you. When your event is over they will be picked up.**

Custom cookies🍪

Soft, buttery sugar cookies topped with smooth royal icing and customized to match your celebration. Each cookie is individually heat sealed for freshness and designed to be just as delicious as it is beautiful. 🤍 Standard Size: 3.5–4 inches • Starting at $4+ per cookie • Minimum order: 1 dozen • Fully customizable to match your theme, colors & event • Custom sizing available upon request Final pricing varies based on design detail, shape, colors, and quantity. ✨ Available upgrades: Customized packaging, edible images, metallic details, specialty finishes, and more for an additional cost. Discounted cookie pricing is available when booked as part of a dessert package.

Follow us!