Ratings & Reviews

I’ve used this bakery a couple of times and it is fantastic! The decorating, the taste, and the customer service is amazing! I highly recommend!

I had cookies created to CELL-ebrate the anniversary of my stem cell transplant, and Maddy absolutely exceeded my expectations. I didn’t give her much to work with, but she took the time to research my condition and created cookies that were not only beautifully designed, but incredibly meaningful and medically accurate. I shared them with the hospital staff, and everyone was blown away! The entire ordering process was incredibly easy, and pickup was smooth and convenient as well. Communication was great from start to finish, which made the whole experience stress-free. Beyond how amazing they looked, they tasted incredible too — the perfect texture and sweetness. I will absolutely be a return customer!

Maddy did a beautiful job on my request for billiards theme cookies for a birthday party. The designs were perfect and the cookies were delicious! Highly recommend!

Maddie's cookies are precise, beautiful, and totally delicious.

Everything Maddy makes is expertly done and treated with the care and attention to detail it deserves. I’ve ordered custom cookies from here for multiple events, and the most common remark I hear is “Wow, these taste just as good as they look!” It’s rare to find a treat that has both exceptional taste AND exquisite decoration, and to work with a reliable professional like Maddy is just the cherry on top. When I order with Maddy, I know that it will be done on time and that the finished product will surpass all of my expectations. 11/10!

My cookies came out amazing and tasted delicious!

As always, cookies are perfection! I ordered custom cookies for teacher appreciation week and gave Maddy complete creative freedom for the designs…they did not disappoint! They turned out SO CUTE and are even more delicious (thank you for the little extra so we could taste them!). This is my official permanent cookie place :)

WOW! I can’t say enough about all aspects of At Your Own Whisk Bakery. The ordering process was simple. Communication was clear and no surprises or added costs. The cookies themselves were unreal. We didn’t want to eat them because they looked so good. We did eat them and were stunned at how delicious they were. We will certainly be calling for our special orders in the future.

What an amazing job At Your Own Whisk Bakery did on a house shaped cake for me! From start to finish Maddy made sure everything was perfect! Excellent customer service, and the taste was out of this world!