Ratings & Reviews

Andi’s sourdough bread, cookies and bagels are the best around! We’ve been ordering for a while now and it’s the only bread our family will eat. Always delivered delicious and it’s gone before I know it. Does not disappoint!

The cookies were awesome. The bakery owner couldn't be nicer and more responsive. I highly recommend

I’ve had the chocolate chip cookies, fun fetti cookies s’mores cookies and the sourdough bread and everything has been amazing! If you have not tried anything, I highly suggest you do

I got the chocolate chip cookies and they were to die for! Andi was super sweet to work with and extremely flexible! Can’t wait to get more cookies!

I am speechless while eating the plain sourdough bread this morning, it’s light, airy and bursting with flavor! It’s AMAZING with simple ingredients! The cookies, I ate 2 after we finished with dinner last night, the cookies just melt in your mouth, thick and tastey! We will be ordering again and again! Thank you and keep going with this amazing business!

Tried Andi’s Bakes for the first time and it definitely won’t be the last! Everyone raved about the cookies, and my kids have already asked that I get another loaf of bread as soon as this one is gone. Looking forward to trying some other items and will probably make the bread a regular treat :)

I recently moved from Chicago to Madison and have been exploring new restaurants and bakeries, mostly through a few local foodie bloggers. Andi’s Bakes was recommended for having the best cookies in the area, so I went ahead and ordered 6 chocolate chip and 6 confetti cookies. OMG, when I say these are the best cookies I’ve ever had, I’m not lying. I love chocolate chip cookies but have never tried a sourdough cc cookie. It blows any other one I’ve had out of the water. Andi should open a local bakery! That’s all I need to say. 😄

Andi’s chocolate chip cookies are some of the best I have ever had! They are soft and chock full of chocolate chips. I also appreciated the great communication throughout the whole buying process. Highly recommended!!

I initially learned of Andi’s Bakes by reading a review from “Eat with Troy” on Facebook. He mentioned that he bought the best chocolate chip cookies ever!!! Then I noticed that the baker was only 20 miles from my house and just a few minutes from my chiropractor, Noble Chiropractic in Sun Prairie. I had an appt today and was prepared to pick up the cookies but Andi offered to deliver them to the clinic. They were there when I arrived and the employees at the clinic were interested in the cookies but didn’t try any until I got there. I agree with Troy…best chocolate chip cookies ever and she delivered them too!!!!!! I bought 12 but only got to bring home 4 since I shared with the chiropractic office staff.

My whole family loved it. The sourdough was amazing. I love how clean the ingredients are. It’s so nice of her to drop off the bread with no extra charge!

So good and fresh!

Quality, taste, freshness, packaging, customer service was incredible!!! Andi’s bakes is a five star gem!!

Absolutely phenomenal, incredible quality, Taste, packaging, Everything was so yummy and intricately baked and put together, HIGHLY recommend!!!

Everything is delicious! The Jalapeño Cheddar Loaf & Chocolate Chip Cookies are our must haves in every order.

Truly the best sourdough I’ve ever had! Andrea’s bread is next-level — perfectly crusty on the outside, soft and flavorful on the inside. You can taste the love and care in every loaf. Fresh, handmade, and absolutely delicious. A true gem of a home bakery!

Best homemade Sourdough around!!!