How much are your custom cookies? How does pricing work?
Our cookies are custom and unique, designed for your specific event, hand-baked and hand-drawn. Our cookies start at $35 per dozen with a 2 dozen minimum for special orders.
Pricing is based off of design complexity, number of colors used, extensive lettering, metallic details, florals, number of designs and character cookies. These will all add cost to the base price of $35. I will do my best to make sure you can still receive beautiful custom cookies within your price range!
Once you submit an order request with as much detail as possible, I will send over an invoice with the total amount.
Do you deliver cookies?
The meeting pickup location is at Chartley Country Store in Rehoboth, MA. If that location does not work for you, other meeting point pickups may be accommodated upon request during less busy times but a fee will be applied. For deliveries/pickup locations within 15 miles of Chartley Country Store, a $15 charge will be applied, for deliveries/pickup locations within 15-25 miles a $25 charge will be applied. Over 25 miles needs to be discussed with customer.
Where are you located?
We do not currently have a storefront and are working from our home bakery in Rehoboth, MA. Meeting pickup location is at Chartley Country Store in Rehoboth, MA. Other meeting locations may be accommodated upon request.
How does shipping work?
I am currently in a trial run for shipping custom cookies. All cookies are individually packaged and sealed and wrapped in bubble wrap. I am offering a $5 discount and free shipping on custom cookies at the moment. No refunds are available and feedback on how the cookies arrived would be much appreciated. Shipping orders must be paid in full at the time of order and can be fully refunded up to 2 weeks before shipping date
How far in advanced should I place my order?
You are able to place an order up to 4 months before your pickup date. The sooner the better, however I take orders 1 week in advance for smaller orders and would appreciate 1 month notice for larger order (4+ dozen). Please do not hesitate to reach out if your event is more than 4 months away and you would like a quote
What designs can you do?
I’m lucky to have all the tools and gadgets needed to complete most custom cookie orders. I’m a newer baker, so anything extremely advanced or complex may not be possible, but I will do my best to create a product you will love that still aligns with my prices and portfolio. One request I cannot accommodate is printing exact images onto cookies as all are hand drawn.
Can you copy an inspiration picture?
I will take inspiration from any pictures customers provide, however I do require creative freedom and the final product may differ. Color palette and theme will be as the customer requested, I just cannot copy another artists work and I enjoy putting my own creative spin on custom orders!
What flavors do you have?
Currently, our cookies are a classic sugar cookie decorated with royal icing. We are working to add other flavors into our selection soon!
For cupcakes, we have flavor options on our site, but I love experimenting and can usually make any unique flavor a custom requests. We do not offer any vegan or gluten free baked goods at this time.
The date I want isn’t available, what can I do?
Always feel free to ask for accommodation on block off dates. Dates are blocked off either for personal commitments, or a large number of orders.
Cookies will stay fresh in their packaging up to two weeks so ordering a week in advanced is also an option in case your week/day is blocked off.
Why do custom cookies cost so much?
Each cookie is hand baked, hand designed and hand drawn by me. Think of Custom cookies like a little piece of art for your event and for guests to enjoy! The going rate for the MA/RI area for custom cookies is around $50-60+ per dozen. I’m a newer baker hence why my prices are a bit lower. They never fail to be a talking point at any party. Lots of love, time, effort and research go into creating your unique batch of custom cookies 😊
How long do the cookies stay good for?
If kept at room temperature, the cookies will be good for up to 2 weeks. Each cookie is individually packaged and sealed to contain freshness.
For freezing cookies: lay cookies flat in an air tight container. When you’re ready to use the cookies, take the container out and leave sealed on the counter until thawed. However, I cannot guarantee cookies will maintain design and consistency if frozen.
What allergens do the cookies contain?
Our cookies contain Flour, Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Vanilla Extract, Baking Soda, & Salt. The Icing is made out of Powdered sugar, water, Meringue Powder & food coloring.
While the cookies do not contain nuts, it is not baked in a nut free environment and may contain traces of nuts and other allergens. If anyone in your party has a severe food allergy, it is best to avoid as residential kitchens often have higher risk of cross contamination.
The cookies are a bit out of my price range. What can I do?
The custom cookie industry range is typically $50-60+ per dozen. I am a new baker so, our lowest tier of custom cookies are $35 / dozen with a 2 dozen minimum. These prices are lower than most competitors due to the newness of the business. I will do my best to accommodate every order and work with you to see what is in your price range. If your cookies are priced higher than $35 / dozen, I will work with you to see what different types of designs might be more budget friendly.
What is the difference between normal cupcakes and luxury cupcakes?
Regular cupcakes come in a variety of unique and delicious flavors! They all have a filling topped with frosting and a topper.
Luxury cupcakes come in chocolate, vanilla or red velvet with beautiful and detailed icing on the top. These are more intricate and great for special occasions. (For an example, please see the Valentine’s Day cupcakes in the gallery).