Ratings & Reviews

Caitlin was able to squeeze me in just a few days before I needed the cake & let me tell you, DID SHE DELIVER!!!! The cake was delicious & everything I could’ve expected & more! I highly recommend!

absolutely phenomenal. She replicated my picture perfectly and it was delicious.

At some point in your life, you’ve probably thought, “Wow, these are the best chocolate chip cookies ever. Surely, nothing could beat them.” BUT THEN you try Caitlin’s recipe, and boy, oh boy… you realize these are somehow even better than the ones you swore were the best. 🍪🤤 Needless to say, but our family highly recommends Caitlin

Caitlin did an amazing job making a beautiful cake + cupcakes for my baby’s birthday! She was super accommodating with our dietary restrictions (vegan), and the flavors were spot on — no one knew it was vegan. Overall, highly recommend.

These baked goods are so good! The recipes are really amazing and thought out. Will definitely continue helping this small business!

This is the sweetest little gem home bakery Iv ever found. I’m not even from the area but I found Caitlyn through Google Search and gave her a call. At first she didn’t know if she could fit me in on such short notice, but then she called me back and said she could do it and I was so excited. I requested a chocolate cake with peanut-butter buttercream frosting, and decorated with pearls and pink flowers. It came out so delicious and beautiful!! I highly recommend this bakery as it was so efficient. Caitlyn is so good at her craft, and if I’m ever back in the area, I would definitely order from her again.

Caitlin made my birthday cake and it was absolutely incredible! It was beautiful & tasted amazing! You can tell so much time and care went into making it. Everyone loved it, and I couldn’t have asked for a better cake! Highly recommend!

Caitlin is an absolute angel to work with! I hired her for a simple wedding cake. She was patient while I changed my mind a few times and happily helpful when I asked for her input. The cake was beautiful, classy looking and absolutely delicious! My guests raved about it! I'm keeping All or Nothing Baking Co. In my contacts for future events. Her prices are extremely reasonable and she literally has the only buttercream frosting I have ever liked. I recommend All or Nothing for all your sweet needs!

I got the biscoff cookie butter cupcakes and they were AMAZING! Such great communication, quick fulfillment of order, and they looked super cute. 10/10 recommend!

These are the BEST chocolate chip cookies. I bought a half a dozen to share with friends, and they were amazing! Everything I've tried has been so delicious - the coconut cupcakes, banana bread cookies, and the carrot cake cookies! If you're looking for a treat to share with family or friends All or Nothing Baking has the treats you need.

I've tried several of the items made, and every one is delicious, fresh, and unique. A few favorites were the coconut cupcakes, the dark chocolate with sea salt cookies, and the banana bread chocolate chip cookies with sea salt.

Caitlin was amazing to work with! She was very responsive and accommodating. The cake she made was fabulous and our guests all raved about it

Amazing! Really some of the best cupcakes I've ever had. I got three kinds - vanilla, cookies and creme and strawberry. They also made my order on short notice. I would absolutely order anything from here! Thank you so much.

I ordered a cake last minute and not only did she make it happen but the cake and frosting were both delicious. Would highly recommend.

Thank you Caitlin! Best service worked with me last minute notice and gave me the most amaizing banana bread for the best price totally recommended!! ❤️❤️