Ratings & Reviews

Five star - I would highly recommend

Stephanie was quick to respond, easy to work with, super willing to personalize my corporate project, accommodating with delivery and best of all the finished product is so, so cute!! Will definitely work with again and recommend!

The best custom cookies in the area! I’ve ordered from All Buttered Up Bakery multiple times now, and somehow each order is even better than the last. The designs are always absolutely stunning and so detailed, but what really stands out is how amazing the cookies taste too! Every time I bring them to an event, my family and friends can’t stop talking about them. Stephanie is also incredibly kind, responsive, and easy to work with throughout the whole process. You can really tell how much care and creativity goes into every order. Highly recommend for birthdays, showers, holidays, or any special occasion!

In the past, most personalized cookies I’ve come across were honestly more for photos than actually eating. That’s why I was so impressed with her cookies. They completely changed that expectation for me. Every time I’ve ordered, the designs are beautiful and exactly what I asked for, but what really stands out is how good they taste. They’re flavorful not just decorative. Whenever I bring them to an event, they don’t just sit there looking pretty…they actually get taken and eaten quickly. You can tell she puts a lot of care into both the appearance and the quality. It’s rare to find someone who does both so well. I’ll definitely keep ordering from her for special occasions.

The entire experience from ordering, delivery, and finished product with Stephanie was wonderful! I am thrilled with the cookies they are so beautiful! Can’t wait to order more from her!

Stephanie made the most delicious cookies that were individually wrapped for freshness. Her style was exactly as I had hoped. Beautiful artist and baker.

This is my second time asking her to make her incredible cookies. They are so tasty, but most importantly her designs are AMAZING! Highly, highly recommended and I will always use her when am hosting something special.

Amazing. Beautiful. As always. These are my go-to for any event I am hosting or planning and they are always a hit. I trust Stephanie’s creativity and they always turn out incredible. Too beautiful to eat, except they taste delicious too. Snickerdoodle is my favorite! The designs are always unique and personal and just overall perfection.

Steph is incredibly talented and just as kind. She created custom cookies for my grandmother’s celebration of life and went above and beyond to make them special. They are beautiful and mean so much to our family. I can’t recommend her enough.

Stephanie’s cookies are a real treasure. They are beautiful and delicious. The attention to detail is impeccable and they were simply delicious! Each cookie was individually wrapped and they made my daughter’s baby shower so special. Thank you to All Buttered Up Bakery!

Stephanie made a beautiful assortment of 2 dozen bridal shower cookies for my future daughter in laws shower. The designs were perfect for the occasion and she ensured the colors matched the brides wedding color theme. The cookies will undoubtedly be a big hit at the shower. They are almost too pretty to eat! Stephanie was also very easy and pleasant to work with.

What an easy process to work with Stephanie on my cookies. I gave her absolute creativity and the freedom to design cookies for my 50th birthday and I was so excited to receive them at her house. She was really easy to work with and the designs are top-notch. I know the cookie will taste amazing as I am a repeat customer. Kudos x1000. Congrats on all of your success!

The cookies were incredibly well made.Very detailed and so cute. They tasted absolutely delicious. Stephanie was easy to work with and highly recommend her!!!! Thank you again!

Stephanie does FANTASTIC work creating wonderful creative cookies. All Buttered Up has helped us celebrate many company & family functions with designs that are not only creative but delicious as well! We highly recommend All Buttered Up for remarkable, unique cookies that everyone enjoys.

I give All Buttered Up Bakery my highest recommendation. I have used Stephanie multiple times and recommended her to my close friends. The order process is simple with excellent followup communication about specific details and requests. My daughter's graduation cookies were fantastic and the cookies for my mother's memorial service were everything I hoped they would be.

Stephanie made a beautiful array of cookies that were exactly what we envisioned. The designs were intricately detailed and perfect for our celebration. We gave out the cookies as party favors and our guests were very excited to take one home. The cookies were delicious and very soft. I would absolutely recommend Stephanie for a special occasion.

We ordered 13 dozen cookies for our party this past weekend and they were perfect! Beautiful, delicious, and gone within minutes.

The designs are AMAZING !! Affordable and the best customer service. Stephanie is very easy to work with and responds quickly to messages. Delivery service was great as well. Everyone at the shower loved the cookies, we got sooo many compliments. This is my second time booking her for an event and she never disappoints. Definitely gained a lifetime customer!

Stephanie always out does herself with any theme cookies that are requested. The wonderful thing about her cookies as well… they taste amazing!

Stephanie made Minecraft cookies for my son’s 5th birthday. The cookies looked amazing, and they also tasted so good! The kids (AND adults) loved them. Stephanie even included a very detailed cookie of Steve, which was a nice surprise. Thank you so much!

Stephanie is wonderful, talented and extremely creative! Her cookies are delicious and there are never left-overs (because most people can't eat just one!). I've ordered cookies from her for several occasions and will continue to do so! I highly recommend her and her cookies -- she's just amazing!

These Christmas cookies are almost too cute to eat… almost! Every single one is festive, delicious, and clearly made with so much love 🎄🍪

We have been working with Buttered Up since my daughter was turning one (and she is turning seven soon); the memories of our celebrations are so sweet because Stephanie's delicious creations have been a part of all of them - from birthdays to holidays and many little days in between! We are so grateful for not only her craftsmanship and creativity but also her attention to detail with such care. For example: fulfilling my daughter's dream cookies by perfectly capturing the aurora borealis (with a black labrador in the frame) on. a. cookie (who can claim that?!)! She is truly one of a kind. There are many local custom cookie bakers and more seem to pop-up every day. I have tasted others at friend's events and they simply do not compare. Stephanie's cookies have everything that matters: TASTE, ARTISTRY, PACKAGING, QUALITY, & FOOD SAFETY. Quality custom cookies have an associated cost that is above the basic - and we are more than happy to pay it because (most important to my husband) Buttered Up cookies TASTE BETTER than all the others! We look forward to many more years of delicious cookies at our most special events!

I absolutely loved the cookies I purchased! From ordering to picking up was a breeze! If you are looking for cookies don't look any further and order from All Buttered Up Bakery!

Stephanie is so talented and puts her heart & soul into each cookie she makes. She’s the sweetest person to know. Her cookies are simply beautiful.

The cookies were gorgeous and personalized. Love that you can choose various flavors.. TY

Beautiful cookie designs and phenomenal customer service! Thank you!!

My family and I have had Stephanie at All Buttered Up bakery design and create cookies for every big family moment - from engagements, to baby showers, to birthdays - and we are so incredibly grateful for how she has made each and every event so special. Her cookies are beyond delicious, and her cookie designs are so creative, detailed and thoughtful - she truly blows us away every time!!! Sometimes the cookies just feel too beautiful to eat they are so incredible (but we never even have one leftover everyone loves them so much)! We have absolutely loved working with Stephanie and feel she has become a part of our family - I highly highly reccomend working Stephanie/All Buttered up Bakery!!

Stephanie does an absolute fabulous job with her cookies!! She is incredibly talented and the cookies not only look great but they taste great too! We are repeat costumers and will continue to be!

I’ve ordered cookies from Stephanie three times now—first for a baby shower, then my puppy’s birthday, and most recently for Thanksgiving—and she absolutely crushes it every single time. She’s collaborative on design, brings legit creativity to every set, and the detail she puts into her work is insane. And the best part? The cookies taste even better than they look. I’m planning to use her for every future milestone and celebration because she’s just that good. Highly recommend.

All Buttered Up is AMAZING!! The cookies are ALWAYS soft and tasty. Stephanie and her family are the most nicest and friendly people you'll ever meet. I always order the "Just Because" cookies. Because sometimes you just want a GOOD cookie. LOL

Cookies are delicious and decorated so well! Stephanie is great to work with and communicated effectively and promptly!

All Buttered up is EXCELLENT in every category ~ Superior decoration/presentation, cookies are delectable and delicious and service is simply outstanding !! You will be delighted with these gems !!!! Yummmm

Stephanie was so lovely to work with! She is beyond talented and created the most darling, yummy cookies for my daughter’s kindergarten Halloween party. Thank you!

I ordered a whole bag of beautiful spooky Halloween cookies. They were even better than expected. Wonderfully packaged, hand delivered and made with love. They tasted great almost too beautiful to eat but kids they just want the yummy cookie and these delivered.

Every design Stephanie comes out with is absolutely adorable. She’s so professional and easy to work with. Would recommend to all my friends and families!

We ordered Halloween specialty cookies for our grandchildren. They were phenomenal looking and tasted great. The girls were so excited to get them, since we had ordered Christmas and back to school packages. Stephanie put the girls name on one of the cookies to personalize them. Both girls said they tasted great. She also had them wrapped and in a Halloween bag. Bottom line they were grade A from looks to packaging and most of all delicious. Can’t wait to get the Christmas ones.

The very best! Very detailed, so cute, and they’re delicious. Always impressive. Thank you!! ❤️

Stephanie made the most beautiful cookies for a baby shower I was throwing. I sent her the invitation and she made cookies to match some of the animals on it. She was so responsive and a pleasure to work with. They came out perfectly. And they were also delicious. Incredibly impressed!

All Buttered Up cookies are amazing!!! Not only are the cookies delicious, but they are also beautifully made. The designs for our baby girl shower were adorable. I gave Stephanie some ideas and she went above and beyond!! The cookies were a wonderful surprise and delight to our guests.

The most amazing cookies I’ve seen! Gave her free rein with my idea and she made it better than I could have even imagined. Highly recommend