Simply Alyssa Baking Co.

View Cart

0

Custom Cookies
Simple Sweet Collection
Simple Sweet Collection
$50.00

Tap to view details

Signature Collection
Signature Collection
$65.00

Tap to view details

Character Collection
Character Collection
$75.00

Tap to view details

Petite Collection
Petite Collection
$48.00

Tap to view details

Custom Printed Cookies
Custom Printed Logo Cookies
Custom Printed Logo Cookies
$50.00

Tap to view details

Cupcakes
Specialty Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Specialty Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$38.00

Tap to view details

Classic Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Classic Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$36.00

Tap to view details

Custom Cupcakes
Custom Cupcakes
$45.00

Tap to view details

Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes (6 Pack)
Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes (6 Pack)
$24.00

Tap to view details

Custom Cookie Cake
Custom Cookie Cake
Custom Cookie Cake
$25.00

Tap to view details

Mystic Falls
The Classic Mystic falls Cookies
The Classic Mystic falls Cookies
$40.00

Tap to view details

Simply Mystic Collection
Simply Mystic Collection
$40.00

Tap to view details

Simply Mystic Collection- 1 Dozen
Simply Mystic Collection- 1 Dozen
$78.00

Tap to view details

πŸ₯ž Prison World Pancake Cookies (1/2 Dozen)
πŸ₯ž Prison World Pancake Cookies (1/2 Dozen)
$38.00

Tap to view details

πŸ₯ž Prison World Pancake Cookies-1 Dozen
πŸ₯ž Prison World Pancake Cookies-1 Dozen
$74.00

Tap to view details

Custom Cookie Dozen
Custom Cookie Dozen
$80.00

Tap to view details

πŸ–€ Team Damon 6-Pack
πŸ–€ Team Damon 6-Pack
$25.00

Tap to view details

🩸Team Stefan 6-Pack
🩸Team Stefan 6-Pack
$25.00

Tap to view details

Items Available for Shipping (September 28th)
Mini Cookie Bag
Mini Cookie Bag
$10.00

Tap to view details

Mini Cookie Bag- Bundle 3
Mini Cookie Bag- Bundle 3
$27.00

Tap to view details

Simply Mystic Collection
Simply Mystic Collection
$35.00

Tap to view details

Pumpkin Spice Mini Cookies
Pumpkin Spice Mini Cookies
$10.00

Tap to view details

Sweet Fall Things
Sweet Fall Things
$12.00

Tap to view details

Custom Cakes
4” Bento Cake (Round)
4” Bento Cake (Round)
$25.00

Tap to view details

6” Custom Cake (Round)
6” Custom Cake (Round)
$65.00

Tap to view details

8” Custom Cake (Round)
8” Custom Cake (Round)
$95.00

Tap to view details

10” Custom Cake (Round)
10” Custom Cake (Round)
$125.00

Tap to view details

12” Custom Cake (Round)
12” Custom Cake (Round)
$165.00

Tap to view details

Vampire Weekend 2026 🩸
The Classic Mystic falls Cookies
The Classic Mystic falls Cookies
$40.00

Tap to view details

10 left
Simply Mystic Collection
Simply Mystic Collection
$40.00

Tap to view details

10 left
Simply Mystic Collection- 1 Dozen
Simply Mystic Collection- 1 Dozen
$78.00

Tap to view details

10 left
πŸ₯ž Prison World Pancake Cookies (1/2 Dozen)
πŸ₯ž Prison World Pancake Cookies (1/2 Dozen)
$38.00

Tap to view details

10 left
πŸ₯ž Prison World Pancake Cookies-1 Dozen
πŸ₯ž Prison World Pancake Cookies-1 Dozen
$74.00

Tap to view details

10 left
Pour It Out 1/2 Dozen Set
Pour It Out 1/2 Dozen Set
$40.00

Tap to view details

10 left
Mystic Magnolia Collection (1 Dozen)
Mystic Magnolia Collection (1 Dozen)
$78.00

Tap to view details

10 left
πŸ–€ Team Damon 6-Pack
πŸ–€ Team Damon 6-Pack
$25.00

Tap to view details

7 left
🩸Team Stefan 6-Pack
🩸Team Stefan 6-Pack
$25.00

Tap to view details

7 left
Simply Fall πŸŽƒπŸ
Pumpkin Spice Mini Cookies
Pumpkin Spice Mini Cookies
$10.00

Tap to view details

Sweet Fall Things
Sweet Fall Things
$12.00

Tap to view details

Pumpkin Spice Cake Jars
Pumpkin Spice Cake Jars
$8.00

Tap to view details

Snickerdoodle Cake Jar
Snickerdoodle Cake Jar
$8.00

Tap to view details

Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes (6 Pack)
Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes (6 Pack)
$24.00

Tap to view details

Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip
Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip
$4.00

Tap to view details

ExitNext