Sourdough Pumpkin Crumble Coffee Cake • GIANT Slice 🍂
Our giant bakery-style Sourdough Pumpkin Crumble Coffee Cake 🍂 Soft, moist pumpkin sourdough coffee cake piled high with a buttery brown sugar crumble and finished with a maple vanilla espresso drizzle. These are BIG, thick slices and were one of our fastest sellouts at our last pop-up. Cozy fall coffee-shop goodness in every bite. ☕🤎 Sold by the large individual slice.
Starting at $6.00
click for description
Unleavened Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls
⭐ Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls ⭐ These aren’t just cinnamon rolls—they’re a whole testimony! 🥖 Slow-fermented sourdough dough made with real butter, warm milk, and love 🍬 Rolled up with brown sugar, cinnamon, and a secret sprinkle of cornstarch for that gooey center 🍁 Finished with a maple-kissed cream cheese frosting that melts right into the swirls ✨ Options: - Individually baked & iced - Individually baked with frosting on the side - Pans available with frosting on the side(allows you to heat and served warm like you just made them) Perfect for blessing your morning—sweet, bold, and made to be shared. Eat one warm and thank the Lord twice. 📦 Available in packs of 6 or 12 (refrigerate or freeze if you’re a “save some for later” type… but we won’t judge if they’re gone by morning). 👉 Also available: Giant Braided Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls – a completely different menu item! Same dough, but shaped and baked into one stunning braid. Big, bold, and all served with frosting on the side. A whole different experience!
Starting at $6.00
click for description
🍪 Sourdough Chocolate Chip Cookies
Sourdough Chocolate Chip Cookies Soft. Rich. Set apart. These bakery-style sourdough cookies are crafted with intention and ingredients you can feel good about—bringing together depth of flavor and a texture that hits every time. Made with: • Active sourdough starter • Raw turbinado sugar • Milk chocolate + dark chocolate chunks • Vanilla bean paste • Finished with Celtic sea salt Each cookie bakes up with crisp golden edges, a soft center, and layers of flavor you don’t get from a basic dough. The sourdough adds a subtle richness, the raw sugar brings a deeper sweetness, and that final touch of sea salt pulls it all together. These aren’t just cookies… they’re the kind you remember.
Starting at $4.00
click for description
Dozen Box Of Sourdough Double Dark Chocolate Chip Brownies
Rich. Decadent. Unforgettable. Our Double Dark Chocolate Chip Sourdough Brownies are the ultimate indulgence for chocolate lovers. Made with Special Dark Cocoa and loaded with premium dark chocolate chips, these brownies deliver an intense, fudgy chocolate flavor with every bite. Crafted with sourdough discard, unsalted butter, granulated sugar, black Dutch cocoa, and a touch of flaky Celtic sea salt on top, these brownies balance deep chocolate richness with a hint of tangy complexity. Their soft, chewy center and perfectly crackled top make them a bakery-style treat like no other. Each batch is handmade with care, featuring just the right amount of salt to enhance the bold flavors of dark chocolate. Perfect for special occasions or anytime you need an indulgent dessert that truly satisfies. Order now and experience the brownie you’ll be dreaming about long after the last bite!
Starting at $6.00
click for description
Classic Artisan Sourdough Loaf
Experience the beauty of simplicity with our handcrafted artisan sourdough loaf, made with just three wholesome ingredients: flour, water, and salt. Each loaf is naturally leavened, delivering a crisp golden crust, a tender crumb, and a tangy depth of flavor. Choose your shape – round or oval – to suit your preference or occasion. Perfect on its own, as toast, or paired with your favorite spread, our artisan sourdough loaf is a simple yet exceptional addition to your table. Order yours today and savor the art of small-batch sourdough!
Starting at $11.00
click for description
Sourdough Bagels By The Dozen 🥯
Our sourdough bagels are the ultimate combination of chewy and tangy, made with our signature sourdough starter for unparalleled flavor. You can enjoy them in their simplest and most classic form—plain—or take them to the next level with flavorful additions. Customize your dozen (or half) with irresistible options like: Everything Bagel: A savory favorite loaded with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, and onion. Blueberry: A touch of sweetness for the perfect morning pick-me-up. Garlic Butter Parm: A rich, savory blend of garlic and Parmesan that’s utterly indulgent. Whether you love them plain or with a flavorful twist, our sourdough bagels are a delicious and affordable way to elevate any meal. Order your dozen (or half) today and experience the difference of freshly baked goodness!
Starting at $24.00
click for description
Green’s Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies Dozen Box
🍪 Green’s Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies Soft, chewy, and packed with oats, chocolate chips, and rich flavor, these cookies carry a story. They’ve been a favorite in my husband’s family for years, and I’ve put my own twist on them—keeping the heart of the recipe but swapping Crisco for real lard (the secret that sets them apart). Perfect with a glass of milk, a cup of coffee, or straight off the cooling rack. ✨ Available by the dozen only 📖 Want to try making them yourself? The full recipe is available when you join me on Patreon as a free member. Paid members get even more exclusive recipes, behind-the-scenes content, and baking tips.
$20.00
click for description
Jalapeño Cheddar Artisan Sourdough
🔥 Jalapeño Cheddar Artisan Sourdough 🔥 This handcrafted sourdough loaf is the perfect blend of bold flavors! Slow-fermented and baked to perfection, it features: 🥖 A crisp, golden crust with a chewy, airy interior 🧀 Sharp cheddar folded throughout for rich, cheesy goodness 🌶️ Just the right kick of heat from fresh jalapeños Perfect for toasting, dipping, or enjoying on its own—this one’s a must-try! Grab yours before they’re gone.
$15.00
click for description
Cinnamon Swirl Soft Sourdough Loaf
Meet the bread that turns every day into a special occasion—our Cinnamon Swirl Sourdough Loaf. This soft, tender bread takes all the love of our classic sourdough and swirls it with warm cinnamon and sweet brown sugar for a loaf that’s as beautiful as it is delicious. Every slice is a little work of art, with ribbons of cinnamon goodness weaving through fluffy sourdough perfection. Toast it, butter it, or savor it as is—this bread is the kind that fills your home with cozy vibes and your heart with joy. Perfect for breakfast, dessert, or a mid-afternoon snack (because who can resist?), this cinnamon swirl loaf is here to sweeten your day. Handcrafted with love, because you and your taste buds deserve nothing less!
$12.00
click for description
Blueberry Lemon Artisan Sourdough
💙🍋 Blueberry Lemon Artisan Sourdough 💙🍋 This handcrafted sourdough loaf brings a sweet and tangy twist to tradition! Slow-fermented and baked to golden perfection, it features: 🥖 A crisp, chewy crust with a soft, airy center 🫐 Juicy blueberries folded throughout for bursts of sweetness 🍋 Bright lemon zest that adds a refreshing citrus kick Perfect for breakfast toast, an afternoon snack, or paired with a drizzle of honey—this loaf is as beautiful as it is delicious. Don’t wait to snag one!
$15.00
click for description
Sourdough Soft Sandwich Bread
This isn’t just bread—it’s a hug in loaf form. Our soft sourdough sandwich bread is everything you’ve been dreaming of: pillowy, slightly tangy, and perfect for all your favorite spreads, stacks, and snacks. Slow-fermented with love and a whole lot of patience, it’s the kind of bread that feels like coming home. Whether you’re crafting the ultimate BLT, dunking buttery slices into a bowl of soup, or sneaking a piece straight from the bag (no judgment here), this loaf is your go-to for every occasion. It’s soft enough to please the pickiest eater but sturdy enough to handle the heartiest sandwich. From my oven to your table, this sourdough loaf was made to nourish, comfort, and make every bite a little more special. Because life’s too short for boring bread!
$10.00
click for description
Loaf of Love – Buy/Donate a Loaf 🫶🖤
Loaf of Love starts at $10. Each contribution helps cover the cost of flour, butter, salt, and all the other ingredients that go into baking extra loaves of sourdough. Those extra loaves are then given away to women’s shelters, homes for people in recovery, homeless shelters, ministries, and anyone the Lord places on my heart to bless that week. When you give, you’re not just buying bread—you’re helping spread love, hope, and the reminder that God sees and cares for His people.
$10.00
click for description
Sourdough Pumpkin Crumble Coffee Cake • GIANT Slice 🍂
Our giant bakery-style Sourdough Pumpkin Crumble Coffee Cake 🍂 Soft, moist pumpkin sourdough coffee cake piled high with a buttery brown sugar crumble and finished with a maple vanilla espresso drizzle. These are BIG, thick slices and were one of our fastest sellouts at our last pop-up. Cozy fall coffee-shop goodness in every bite. ☕🤎 Sold by the large individual slice.
Starting at $6.00
click for description
Pumpkin Spice Cake Pop Dozen Box
Soft, spiced, and absolutely dreamy. Each cake pop begins as a warmly spiced cake ball, baked to tender perfection. Every one is then individually filled with our smooth, rich cream cheese filling — so you get that creamy center in every bite. They’re dipped in a pumpkin spice coating, finished with a vanilla drizzle, and rolled in our brown sugar–cinnamon cookie crumble for that cozy, fall-is-here flavor. Perfect for Thanksgiving dessert boards, hosting gifts, teacher treats, or just to keep on hand for “mom needs something sweet” moments. Sold by the dozen. And yes, they go fast.
$30.00
click for description
Mini Carrot Cake Tins
Single-serve sourdough carrot cakes baked in adorable pink tins and topped with a matching spoon. Made with fresh-shredded carrots, warm spices, and a touch of sourdough for extra moisture and depth. Finished with whipped butter + cream cheese frosting, candied pecans, and a hand-piped candied carrot on top.
$5.00
click for description
Caramel-Apple Sourdough Focaccia
(8x8 Holiday/Brunch Pan – Share… or don’t.) Warm, cozy, and absolutely dripping in fall flavors — this Caramel Apple Focaccia is what happens when a bakery-style apple fritter and soft artisan bread decide to settle down and start a family. We start with our hand-crafted sourdough focaccia dough — soft, airy, and beautifully chewy — then swirl in tender cinnamon-spiced apples and pockets of buttery caramel. As it bakes, the caramel melts down into the dough, creating those glossy little caramelized edges that everyone fights over. Finished with a gentle (let’s be honest, generous) drizzle of vanilla glaze, this dish lands somewhere between breakfast casserole, dessert, and the reason your family now shows up early for holiday meals. Perfect for: Thanksgiving morning coffee Christmas brunch boards Potlucks where you actually want to impress people Eating directly from the pan in the car before you even make it home (zero judgment) Warm it up. Smell the cinnamon clouds. Serve in squares. Bask in the compliments. One pan. One fork. One wildly unforgettable bite.
$16.00
click for description
Unleavened Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls
⭐ Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls ⭐ These aren’t just cinnamon rolls—they’re a whole testimony! 🥖 Slow-fermented sourdough dough made with real butter, warm milk, and love 🍬 Rolled up with brown sugar, cinnamon, and a secret sprinkle of cornstarch for that gooey center 🍁 Finished with a maple-kissed cream cheese frosting that melts right into the swirls ✨ Options: - Individually baked & iced - Individually baked with frosting on the side - Pans available with frosting on the side(allows you to heat and served warm like you just made them) Perfect for blessing your morning—sweet, bold, and made to be shared. Eat one warm and thank the Lord twice. 📦 Available in packs of 6 or 12 (refrigerate or freeze if you’re a “save some for later” type… but we won’t judge if they’re gone by morning). 👉 Also available: Giant Braided Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls – a completely different menu item! Same dough, but shaped and baked into one stunning braid. Big, bold, and all served with frosting on the side. A whole different experience!
Starting at $6.00
click for description
🍪 Sourdough Chocolate Chip Cookies
Sourdough Chocolate Chip Cookies Soft. Rich. Set apart. These bakery-style sourdough cookies are crafted with intention and ingredients you can feel good about—bringing together depth of flavor and a texture that hits every time. Made with: • Active sourdough starter • Raw turbinado sugar • Milk chocolate + dark chocolate chunks • Vanilla bean paste • Finished with Celtic sea salt Each cookie bakes up with crisp golden edges, a soft center, and layers of flavor you don’t get from a basic dough. The sourdough adds a subtle richness, the raw sugar brings a deeper sweetness, and that final touch of sea salt pulls it all together. These aren’t just cookies… they’re the kind you remember.
Starting at $4.00
click for description
Dozen Box Of Sourdough Double Dark Chocolate Chip Brownies
Rich. Decadent. Unforgettable. Our Double Dark Chocolate Chip Sourdough Brownies are the ultimate indulgence for chocolate lovers. Made with Special Dark Cocoa and loaded with premium dark chocolate chips, these brownies deliver an intense, fudgy chocolate flavor with every bite. Crafted with sourdough discard, unsalted butter, granulated sugar, black Dutch cocoa, and a touch of flaky Celtic sea salt on top, these brownies balance deep chocolate richness with a hint of tangy complexity. Their soft, chewy center and perfectly crackled top make them a bakery-style treat like no other. Each batch is handmade with care, featuring just the right amount of salt to enhance the bold flavors of dark chocolate. Perfect for special occasions or anytime you need an indulgent dessert that truly satisfies. Order now and experience the brownie you’ll be dreaming about long after the last bite!
Starting at $6.00
click for description
Classic Artisan Sourdough Loaf
Experience the beauty of simplicity with our handcrafted artisan sourdough loaf, made with just three wholesome ingredients: flour, water, and salt. Each loaf is naturally leavened, delivering a crisp golden crust, a tender crumb, and a tangy depth of flavor. Choose your shape – round or oval – to suit your preference or occasion. Perfect on its own, as toast, or paired with your favorite spread, our artisan sourdough loaf is a simple yet exceptional addition to your table. Order yours today and savor the art of small-batch sourdough!
Starting at $11.00
click for description
Sourdough Bagels By The Dozen 🥯
Our sourdough bagels are the ultimate combination of chewy and tangy, made with our signature sourdough starter for unparalleled flavor. You can enjoy them in their simplest and most classic form—plain—or take them to the next level with flavorful additions. Customize your dozen (or half) with irresistible options like: Everything Bagel: A savory favorite loaded with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, and onion. Blueberry: A touch of sweetness for the perfect morning pick-me-up. Garlic Butter Parm: A rich, savory blend of garlic and Parmesan that’s utterly indulgent. Whether you love them plain or with a flavorful twist, our sourdough bagels are a delicious and affordable way to elevate any meal. Order your dozen (or half) today and experience the difference of freshly baked goodness!
Starting at $24.00
click for description
Jalapeño Cheddar Artisan Sourdough
🔥 Jalapeño Cheddar Artisan Sourdough 🔥 This handcrafted sourdough loaf is the perfect blend of bold flavors! Slow-fermented and baked to perfection, it features: 🥖 A crisp, golden crust with a chewy, airy interior 🧀 Sharp cheddar folded throughout for rich, cheesy goodness 🌶️ Just the right kick of heat from fresh jalapeños Perfect for toasting, dipping, or enjoying on its own—this one’s a must-try! Grab yours before they’re gone.
$15.00
click for description
Cinnamon Swirl Soft Sourdough Loaf
Meet the bread that turns every day into a special occasion—our Cinnamon Swirl Sourdough Loaf. This soft, tender bread takes all the love of our classic sourdough and swirls it with warm cinnamon and sweet brown sugar for a loaf that’s as beautiful as it is delicious. Every slice is a little work of art, with ribbons of cinnamon goodness weaving through fluffy sourdough perfection. Toast it, butter it, or savor it as is—this bread is the kind that fills your home with cozy vibes and your heart with joy. Perfect for breakfast, dessert, or a mid-afternoon snack (because who can resist?), this cinnamon swirl loaf is here to sweeten your day. Handcrafted with love, because you and your taste buds deserve nothing less!
$12.00
click for description
Blueberry Lemon Artisan Sourdough
💙🍋 Blueberry Lemon Artisan Sourdough 💙🍋 This handcrafted sourdough loaf brings a sweet and tangy twist to tradition! Slow-fermented and baked to golden perfection, it features: 🥖 A crisp, chewy crust with a soft, airy center 🫐 Juicy blueberries folded throughout for bursts of sweetness 🍋 Bright lemon zest that adds a refreshing citrus kick Perfect for breakfast toast, an afternoon snack, or paired with a drizzle of honey—this loaf is as beautiful as it is delicious. Don’t wait to snag one!
$15.00
click for description
Giant Braided Sourdough Cinnamon Roll
⭐ Giant Braided Sourdough Cinnamon Roll ⭐ Go big or go home—this one’s a showstopper! 🥖 Same soft, slow-fermented sourdough dough you love 🍬 Twisted and braided into one giant loaf, swirled with cinnamon & brown sugar 🍁 Served with maple cream cheese frosting on the side, so you can drizzle, dip, or spread as much as your heart desires Perfect for gatherings, gifts, or just blessing your family breakfast table. It’s bold, beautiful, and baked to share. Pricing & Orders: Each Giant Braided Sourdough Cinnamon Roll is $5 apiece. Minimum order of 6. Build your bundle by the half dozen or dozen—perfect for sharing at brunch, gatherings, or just blessing your family table.
$5.00
click for description
Sourdough English Muffins by the dozen
Bring home the irresistible flavor of freshly griddle-cooked sourdough English muffins crafted in small batches with love and care. Each dozen is made using our naturally fermented sourdough starter, creating a perfectly soft interior and golden, craggy exterior that’s ideal for toasting or enjoying fresh. With their tangy flavor and rustic charm, these muffins are perfect for breakfast, sandwiches, or a comforting snack. Sold by the dozen (or half) to keep your pantry stocked, these preservative-free treats are a wholesome addition to any meal. Taste the difference of true artisanal baking!
$15.00
click for description
Sourdough Soft Sandwich Bread
This isn’t just bread—it’s a hug in loaf form. Our soft sourdough sandwich bread is everything you’ve been dreaming of: pillowy, slightly tangy, and perfect for all your favorite spreads, stacks, and snacks. Slow-fermented with love and a whole lot of patience, it’s the kind of bread that feels like coming home. Whether you’re crafting the ultimate BLT, dunking buttery slices into a bowl of soup, or sneaking a piece straight from the bag (no judgment here), this loaf is your go-to for every occasion. It’s soft enough to please the pickiest eater but sturdy enough to handle the heartiest sandwich. From my oven to your table, this sourdough loaf was made to nourish, comfort, and make every bite a little more special. Because life’s too short for boring bread!
$10.00
click for description
Honey Oat Sourdough Loaf
Rustic, wholesome, and just the right amount of sweet, our Honey Oat Sourdough Loaf is the bread your table has been waiting for. Made with a touch of golden honey and topped with rolled oats for a bit of texture and charm, this loaf is as nourishing as it is beautiful. Whether shaped as a classic oval or a stunning round loaf, it’s perfect for everything from hearty sandwiches to toast slathered with butter or jam. The gentle tang of sourdough paired with the natural sweetness of honey creates a flavor profile that feels both nostalgic and fresh. Each loaf is handcrafted with love, slow-fermented for depth of flavor, and finished with a sprinkle of oats for that homemade touch. Simple, satisfying, and oh-so-delicious—this is bread you’ll want to savor.
$12.00
click for description
Sourdough Starter - (100g Active Starter)
Kickstart your sourdough journey with 100 grams of active, bubbly sourdough starter, ready to bring your homemade bread to life! This starter has been carefully nurtured and fed, making it the perfect foundation for creating delicious sourdough loaves, pancakes, crackers, and more. With this starter, you’re not just buying an ingredient—you’re gaining a companion for your baking adventures. Complete with simple feeding instructions, this starter will grow with you, providing endless opportunities to bake wholesome, flavorful creations. Start your journey today and experience the magic of sourdough! (Pro tip: Give your starter a name—it’s tradition!)
$10.00
click for description
Loaf of Love – Buy/Donate a Loaf 🫶🖤
Loaf of Love starts at $10. Each contribution helps cover the cost of flour, butter, salt, and all the other ingredients that go into baking extra loaves of sourdough. Those extra loaves are then given away to women’s shelters, homes for people in recovery, homeless shelters, ministries, and anyone the Lord places on my heart to bless that week. When you give, you’re not just buying bread—you’re helping spread love, hope, and the reminder that God sees and cares for His people.
$10.00
click for description
Sourdough Dark Chocolate Brownie Bite Packs
$8.00
click for description
Custom Artisan Loaf
$15.00
click for description
Welcome to Unleavened—where every loaf and treat is made with love, intention, and the hope of bringing light into dark places.
Rooted in faith, this is more than a bakery—it’s a ministry. I offer handcrafted sourdough and sweet creations that nourish both body and soul, always baked with care, prayer, and purpose.
Unleavened isn’t just a name—it’s my testimony. In Scripture, unleavened bread represents purity, deliverance, and new beginnings. That’s the story God wrote in me: He delivered me from shame, addiction, and trauma, and gave me freedom, peace, and identity in Him. Every loaf is a reflection of that transformation.
Through Unleavened, my mission is simple:
To feed people—physically and spiritually.
To create with love and serve with joy.
To remind the weary that Jesus is still the Bread of Life.
At Market 1858 and in our community, we share bread, sweets, and hope through the Loaf of Love program, Worship Under the Stars, and weekly bakes. Whenever possible, leftovers are donated to bless those in need—because nothing made in love should go to waste.
Thank you for being part of this story. Your order fuels a movement of faith, kindness, and giving back.
“Taste and see that the Lord is good; blessed is the one who takes refuge in Him.” – Psalm 34:8
Sourdough breads: artisan loaves, soft sandwich loaves, rolls, bagels, cinnamon swirl, and seasonal flavors.
Sweet treats: cake pops, cupcakes, dessert jars, dipped pretzels, brownies, and more.
Weekly Market Specials: rotating flavors & seasonal offerings.
Custom Orders: available with deposit; pricing varies by size & design.
💡 General pricing:
Bread loaves: $6–$12
Cake pops/dessert pops: $30+ per dozen
Cupcakes: $30+ per dozen
(Custom pricing provided when ordering.)
I bake fresh for Wednesday & Saturday pick-up days(unless my calendar is blocked off), so you can always count on fresh sourdough and goodies. 🥖✨
⏰ Order Lead Time
Please place orders at least 3 days in advance so I can plan bakes for the weekend you’d like pickup.
🎂 For custom cakes, cupcakes, or gourmet treats on sticks:
Please allow 1–2 weeks to confirm your order and gather ingredients.
📍 Pickup Options
Prefered:
- Coldwater Lake Pickup (at my home)
Optional:
- Some Hillsdale deliveries
- other deliveries once discussed and confirmed
👉 Check us out on Google or Facebook under Unleavened w/ Rayray’s Sweet Shoppe for weekly updates.